Saturday, February 27, 2016

Jerome and Ambrose on Epicurus

In the fourth century (perhaps even beginning in the third century), the common ascetic practices of the Christian community became the target of significant criticisms. One of the critics about whom we know the most, although almost entirely indirect, was a man named Jovinian. A former monk himself, he repudiated his monastic status and began writing works and preaching arguing that consecrated virginity was not any better than marriage and that fasting was no better than eating with thanksgiving. (It's perhaps worth noting that this indifferentism toward ascetic practice was combined with the view that all sins were equal and that no one baptized with the Holy Spirit could possibly sin.) He came to the attention of Rome, and Pope St. Siricius had his works condemned in synod. St. Ambrose in Milan followed suit with his own synod condemning him. Jerome, who had good connections to the papal curia in Rome, would shortly afterward write an intensely polemical book (so polemical that it was an embarrassment in Rome), Adversus Jovinianum, attacking his views in some detail -- and it is Jerome's work from which we get the most information about Jovinian himself. Jerome calls him "the Epicurus of Christianity."

But Jovinian was by no means alone. We have a letter from Ambrose to the Christian church in Vercellae, probably written not more than a few years after the condemnation of Jovinian, in which he mentions two other monks, Barbatianus and Sarmatio, who seem to have been advocating something very similar, and who were very likely disciples of Jovinian himself. Ambrose summarizes what he has heard of their teaching as saying that "there is no merit in abstinence, no grace in a frugal life, none in virginity, that all are valued at one price, that they are mad who chasten their flesh with fastings". Since the community of Vercellae had been having severe difficulty in choosing a bishop due to divisions in the community, it is sometimes speculated that they may have arrived in town to try to influence the choice. Notably, Ambrose also links their views to Epicureanism, and seems to suggest that they regarded themselves as philosophers. It's unclear whether they themselves affirmed the link between their views and those of Epicurus; both Jerome and Ambrose say things that can be taken either way.

Jerome and Ambrose both argue that Epicureanism is an odious philosophy, but one of the things that they also both do is argue that the views of these hedonistic ex-monks are in fact much more piggish than those of pagan Epicureans. Jerome, for instance, notes that Epicurus never refers to anything other than simple foods, fruits and vegetables, bread and water, and that he actually recommends that people not marry.

Ambrose says a number of interesting things in his development of this argument. For instance, at one point he says:

Epicurus himself also, whom these persons think they should follow rather than the apostles, the advocate of pleasure, although he denies that pleasure brings in evil, does not deny that certain things result from it from which evils are generated; and asserts in fine that the life of the luxurious which is filled with pleasures does not seem to be reprehensible, unless it be disturbed by the fear either of pain or of death. But how far he is from the truth is perceived even from this, that he asserts that pleasure was originally created in man by God its author, as Philomarus his follower argues in his Epitomæ, asserting that the Stoics are the authors of this opinion.

Nobody knows who Philomarus is, and in fact it's even possible that the name is a corruption of another name. The Epitomae sound like they were probably a digest of Epicurean arguments against the Stoics, although Ambrose's reference is a bit unclear.

A bit further on, he says:

But as to that Epicurus himself, the defender of pleasure, of whom, therefore, we have made frequent mention in order to prove that these men are either disciples of the heathen and followers of the Epicurean sect or himself, whom the very philosophers exclude from their company as the patron of luxury, what if we prove him to be more tolerable than these men? He declares, as Demarchus asserts, that neither drinking, nor banquets, nor offspring, nor embraces of women, nor abundance of fish, and other such like things which are prepared for the service of a sumptuous banquet, make life sweet, but sober discussion. Lastly, he added that those who do not use the banquets of society in excess, use them with moderation. He who willingly makes use of the juices of plants alone together with bread and water, despises feasts on delicacies, for many inconveniences arise from them. In another place they also say: It is not excessive banquets, nor drinking which give rise to the enjoyment of pleasure, but a life of temperance.

'Demarchus' is also unknown, although, since the name itself might be a corruption of another name, some have suggested it should read 'Hermarchus'. If so, that would be quite interesting, since Hermarchus was the immediate successor of Epicurus himself: after Epicurus's death, he became the head of the Garden and continued to maintain the school. None of his writings have survived, although we have a few quotations and summaries. The claim made is very similar to that made by Jerome (Book II, section 11), but Jerome does not seem to be directly quoting anyone, as Ambrose does.

In any case, it's notable that the views of the Epicureans in both cases are presented as insisting on simplicity of life: instead of fine foods and banquets, which are more trouble than they are worth, bread and water, vegetables and fruits, sufficient to satisfy need and no more. And they are in both cases presented as seeking wisdom, at least of the sort that you can get in "sober discussion". This is confirmed by other sources we have. Particularly interesting is Ambrose's possible quotation from whomever-it-was, "It is not excessive banquets, nor drinking, which give rise to the enjoyment of pleasure, but a life of temperance."

Both Jerome and Ambrose do not leave it at that, of course, and argue quite vociferously for the excellence of both consecrated virginity and fasting, and their arguments, of course, would be widely copied and distributed. In part by their efforts, the importance of ascetic practices would be maintained throughout the Church. But it is interesting to see the Epicureans pop up in this way.

Lent XVI

Every action, therefore, and performance of miracles by Christ are most great and divine and marvellous: but the most marvellous of all is His precious Cross. For no other thing has subdued death, expiated the sin of the first parent, despoiled Hades, bestowed the resurrection, granted the power to us of contemning the present and even death itself, prepared the return to our former blessedness, opened the gates of Paradise, given our nature a seat at the right hand of God, and made us the children and heirs of God, save the Cross of our Lord Jesus Christ.

John of Damascus, Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, Book IV, Chapter 11.

Friday, February 26, 2016

Dashed Off V

As always, dashed off notes, to be taken with a grain of salt.

the rhapsodic & hortatory aspects of Mass

the significance of the fact that marriage links Genesis and Revelation

The Holy Spirit, communicating through those He first inspired to all others who through faith are capable of sharing in the inspiration the influence of that first divine expression, creates a chain and a succession. Through all these links God draws the souls of men according to His good pleasure, having attached them to one another by the power sent forth from Himself.

responses to the problem of induction // responses to objections to tradition

narrative explanations as descriptions of relevance

threefold human sublimity: reason, free will, capacity for beatitude

Suppositions are evaluated by means-end reasoning.

angelology as contributing to our understanding of understanding

the monstrous as an aesthetic idea

Emotions imitate and express music.

Instrumentality links composition and change.

SBN 160: parallel between mathematical and causal necessity

the existence of substantial forms
(1) indirectly indicated by equilibria
(2) subordinations in organizations as a sign of
(3) from accidental forms
(4) from material cause
(5) from efficient cause
(6) from final cause (primary argument)

parts external to each other -> quantity

(1) All evil defects from good.
(2) What defects from good must be initially good.
(3) Were a good supremely good, there would be no defection from good.
(4) Good that is not supremely good is good by participation.
(5) Good by participation is from supreme good.

Coherence in scientific theories is of importance only teleologically.

Judith, Tobit, I & II Maccabees, Sirach, & Wisdom as a system of moral catechesis

faith as an index, icon, & symbol
faith as encryption in God

sources of the sense of futility
(1) loss of purpose
(2) loss of order
(3) loss of responsibility

dog : pet :: cat : pet
simplifies to dog//cat qua pet (analogy and reduplication)

Gospel Harmony as classificatory inquiry

the perfume analogy of the Trinity (from Song 2:1)
the burning coal analogy (from Isaiah 6:6-7)
The Church Fathers usually draw their Trinitarian analogies directly from Scriptural images.

Nicaea II is Christological because it settles that iconic representation of Christ is neither Nestorian (dividing the natures) nor Monophysite (confusing the natures).

punitive, purgatorial, and prophylactic functions of pain.

Charmides as the analysis of a well-ordered life

baptism : armor of God :: confirmation : gifts of the Holy Spirit
(cf. Theodoret Ecc Hist 4.12)

Conservation laws indicate natural genera.

Reference is just talking-about.

DNA & the concept of template
(we also get templates in paleontology)

If Plato is inclined to treat virtue as knowledge, it is because he regards good as in some sense the primary object of intellect.

Everyone recognizes that leisure should be one of the rewards of excellence.

In sexual matters it is difficult to distinguish objects and occasions of desire. This is due, I think to the fact that the object of sexual desire is really quite general; it is the occasion that differentiates and individuates. Sexual desire doesn't take this person, qua person, as object; only acts of will do.

the insinuation of a text in light of other texts

An epistle is a semi-dialogue.

kinds of proverb
(1) feature: X is a feature of Y; e.g., "The wise lay up knowledge but the mouth of the foolish is near to destruction." Builds a template or constructs a profile.
(2) rather: Rather (better) X than Y, e.g., "Open rebuke rather than secret love." Orders priorities.
(3) query: Rhetorical question designed to make the hearer complete the thought, e.g., "Who knows what is good for mortals while they live the few day sof their vain life, which they pass like shadow?" Builds a template or constructs a profile, sometimes by negation.
(4) magisterial: Advice with link to authority, e.g., "My son, if sinners entice you, do not consent."
(5) edifying simile: e.g., "A fair woman without discretion: like a jewel of gold in a pig's mouth." Evokes a template or profile by means of image.

grace as possibility-maker

sentiment as a guide of conjecture

immateriality of intellectual operation
(1) The intellect is self-reflexive.
(2) Identity and individuation conditions for concepts are ineliminably intensional.
(3) Thought is constituted by universal acts.
(4) In thought the intellect has the form of things other than itself, without perishing.
(5) Intentional relations do not require the existence of all terms.
(6) Thought exhibits rational order in itself.
(7) Deliberative thought involves foresight and purpose.

Hume's account of education could be adapted to tradition.

Motives of credibility are signs.

demonology as a representation of temptation

"History, the great mistress of wisdom, furnishes examples of all kinds; and every prudential as well as moral precept, may be authorized, by those events which her enlarged mirror is able to present to us." Hume

An account of causation for theoretical reason is itself an explanatory strategy for practical reason.

infinite regress arguments using diminution principles in finite contexts

Tendentious rhetoric inevitably arises in political contexts because the primary forms of political reasoning are classificatory.

"The detective is a prophet looking backwards." Ellery Queen

sacrament of marriage as inherently epiclesis-like
matrimony as eucharist-by-sign
Matrimony shares with Confirmation that both receive the Holy Spirit as seal, although in very different ways.

set/class distinction as a distinction between collection & extension of predicate
Note Bernays: a class is not a fixed domain of individuals but an open universe

Suarez: sacraments are instruments separated secundum esse but conjoined secundum causalitatem of Christ's ascended human nature

sagacity in the modes of dialogue, address, epistle, song, allegory, proverb

comparative philosophy as an instrument of balanced reasoning

Figurative language is as much a matter of fleeing indications as of definite words.

To say things in juxtaposition is to suggest possible lines of analogy and contrast.

historical novels as speculative studies of practices

microdeviations in inference

the external heritage of a tradition

societies as structured by privacy constraints & publicity expectations

'Similar cause, similar causata' is rigorously true for constitutive causes.

St. Rafqa and the consistency of flourishing with suffering

docilitas as an essential economic virtue

logical fallacies have counterparts in measurement -- equivocation, irrelevance, illicit presumption, circularity

Berkeley Siris #160: connection between secondary causes (instrumental causes) and regular course of nature

popular piety as an ecosystem in constant motion
It requires conservation and reclamation, and, where clergy have been negligent, or extrinsic factors have massively interfered with their work, active restoration, and cultivation under carefully guided conditions.

the gifts of the Holy Spirit as superprudence

There needs to be recognition of the fact that names have a universe of discourse.

love of what you do, excellence in what you do, benefit from what you do

promise to Abraham -> beatitudes

humility as a motivation for excellence

Technological advance is filtered through social expectation.

superpositions of speculations

reasoned freedom in a harmonious balance with the world around one

Sacrifice gets its sublimity solely from the sublimity of common good.

Every generation is part of the good of the whole prior generation.

"God only has union with creation through His Son in His Spirit." Cyril of Alexandria (Commentary on John)

individual good as uplifted into common good

good as missive

Avoidance of the bad is not a good reason for action except in light of some positive good, because bad can only be understood in light of some positive good.

That a good is destructible does not make it an evil to be avoided.

Eulogy has a nasty habit of replacing rational account in politics.

"A monistic tendency of thought, gathering momentum, creates a meltdown in a polytheistic mythology." Thomas McEvilley, The Shape of Ancient Thought

silence as a kind of logos

Empiricism collapses logical relations to analogy.

first person Socratic dialogues: Lovers, Lysis, Charmides, Republic
first person Socratic after introduction: Protagoras, Euthydemus
first person non-Socratic: Parmenides, Symposium, Phaedo
undated: Hipparchus, Minos, Lovers, Philebus
abrupt beginning: Hipparchus, Minos
Socrates does not appear: Laws, Epinomis
abrupt ending, Socrates breaks off discussion: Meno, Theatetus
abrupt ending, Socrates goes silent: Clitophon
abrupt ending, dialogue unfinished: Critias

Indo-Greek philosophical intersection
(1) Pyrrho (see Diogenes Laertius)
(2) Onesicratus (see Strabo)
(3) the Milinda Panha
(4) Aristoxenus fragment 53

libertas ecclesiae is to religious liberty & other liberty of conscience as baptismal character to natural imago Dei

work as able to occur within prayer (in the same way it is able to occur within conscience)

Platonic scholarship as built out of insinuations of the text

heresies
that confuse the distinct
that divide the unified
that deny the necessary
that misplace authority
that abuse the sign

deduction : geometrical mind :: classification : esprit de finesse

Music on My Mind



Billy Joel, "Two Thousand Years".

Lent XV

A soul which gives itself to prayer, either much or little, should on no account be kept within narrow bounds. Since God has given it such great dignity, permit it to wander at will through the rooms of the castle [of the soul], from the lowest to the highest. Let it not force itself to remain for very long in the same mansion, even that of self-knowledge. Mark well, however, that self-knowledge is indispensable, even for those whom God takes to dwell in the same mansion with Himself. Nothing else, however elevated, perfects the soul which must never seek to forget its own nothingness. Let humility be always at work, like the bee at the honeycomb, or all will be lost. But, remember, the bee leaves its hive to fly in search of flowers and the soul should sometimes cease thinking of itself to rise in meditation on the grandeur and majesty of its God. It will learn its own baseness better thus than by self-contemplation, and will be freer from the reptiles which enter the first room where self-knowledge is acquired. Although it is a great grace from God to practise self-examination, yet ‘too much is as bad as too little,’ as they say; believe me, by God’s help, we shall advance more by contemplating the Divinity than by keeping our eyes fixed on ourselves, poor creatures of earth that we are.

Teresa of Avila, Interior Castle, First Mansion, Chapter II.

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Hid in the Pleasaunce

Linquenda
by Arthur Christopher Benson


In my soul's mansion there are many rooms,
Chamber and oratory, hall and dome,
And some are bare and cold, some dark, and some
Noisy with humming of a hundred looms.

But one pavilion by the water's brim,
Hid in the pleasaunce, for myself I keep,
Where swinging roses through the window peep,
And stockdoves murmur in the elm-trees dim.

The voices of the morning call me thence,--
The harsh laborious voices,--and I know
That some day my mysterious Lord shall come
To thrust me from my sweet familiar home.
How will He greet me when He bids me hence,
My master? Will He call me loud or low?

'Linquenda' is Latin for 'that which is to be forsaken or departed from'. A 'pleasaunce' or pleasance, also called a pleasure-garden, is a garden or portion of a garden that exists only to please the senses, thus bearing no fruit.

Lent XIV

Doing penance for one's sins is a first step towards obtaining forgiveness and winning eternal salvation. That is the clear and explicit teaching of Christ, and no one can fail to see how justified and how right the Catholic Church has always been in constantly insisting on this. She is the spokesman for her divine Redeemer. No individual Christian can grow in perfection, nor can Christianity gain in vigor, except it be on the basis of penance.

John XXIII, Paenitentiam agere