Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Pardons

Today, President Obama 'pardons' two turkeys.

One month ago, the nation's oldest prisoner, 92-year-old Drayton Curry, died in prison, still waiting after two years for the Office of the Pardon Attorney even to get back to him on his request for clemency so he could spend his last few years with his family. Curry was a World War II Army veteran who had had some off-and-on-again problems with drugs. When he was caught again in 1991, four years after having been put on five-year probation, he was sentenced to life as a career offender. As he became increasingly frail in prison, he submitted a pardon application in early 2011, which noted his frail health, his exemplary behavior in prison, and his active involvement in anti-drug counseling for young prisoners.

Now, there is no question that Drayton Curry was guilty of at least some of the charges brought against him -- the charge that put him on probation was a relatively minor one, but he was arrested for a heroin transaction, caught in the act. But the point of the constitutional power pardon is not just to prevent miscarriages of justice but to make sure that the application of law considers the actual circumstances in which people find themselves. The vast majority of pardon applications are from people who have already served their sentences. There are lots of things former felons are restricted from, and so they are essentially applying for a restoration of their rights. Others are cases, as with Drayton Curry, in which the prisoner has become seriously sick or frail, asking to be allowed to go back to their family for their last days. A number of other cases are people who are serving sentences that would be counted excessive by current law -- that is, the sentencing requirements have changed, so that the sentence for the crime they committed is now much lighter than it was when they were convicted.

P. J. Ruckman, Jr. has a table of the clemency rates of recent presidents. President Obama has in his four years pardoned 22 people and commuted 1 sentence; since Thomas Jefferson, only George W. Bush, in his first term, has been so stingy with the pardons.

There are reasons why the pardon power is enshrined in the U.S. Constitution. If you look at discussions of it by the Founding Fathers, people like Alexander Hamilton or James Wilson, their arguments clearly have the implication that the pardon power is an integral and extremely important part of our justice system, one in which we make clear the fundamental principle of American governance, that government must be for the people. Law is unbending; but our application of it must take into account the actual circumstances in which people find themselves. And that is the whole point: the law, all the law, serves us, not we it. It is very important for Americans to start respecting the pardon power again.

2 comments:

  1. MrsDarwin2:34 PM

    This is dreadful, and heartbreaking.

    In other pardoning news, PETA has urged the president to forgo the annual Turkey Pardoning ritual:

    "The White House turkey 'pardon' is a sorely outdated event. It makes light of the mass slaughter of some 46 million gentle, intelligent birds and portrays the United States' president as being in some sort of business partnership with the turkey-killing industry," PETA president Ingrid Newkirk wrote in a letter to the White House released Tuesday.

    "Turkeys do not need to be 'pardoned'—they are not guilty of anything other than being born into a world of prejudice. They are innocents who should be respected for who they are: good mothers, smart birds, and interesting animals," Newkirk wrote.The group suggested a vegetarian alternative for Obama and his family to eat at their Thanksgiving celebration."This year, we encourage you to forgo this event, which so many Americans find offensive, and choose a delicious, healthy Tofurky roast for your family's holiday table," she asked.Newkirk also compared the treatment of turkeys and other animals to the struggles of marginalized humans for dignity and self-respect."You understand so well that African-Americans, women, and members of the LGBT community have been poorly served throughout history, and now I am asking you to consider other living beings who are ridiculed, belittled, and treated as if their sentience, feelings, and very natures count for nothing," she wrote."

    Yes, the slaughter of turkeys, the Great American Holocaust! God forbid we should hold a human in higher esteem than a bird.

    ReplyDelete
  2. branemrys5:16 AM

    The progression African-Americans, women, LGBT, turkeys is the crowning touch; turkeys are the civil rights issue of our day.

    ReplyDelete

No anonymity (but consistent pseudonyms allowed). Abusive comments, especially directed toward other commenters, will be deleted; abusive commenters will be hunted down and shot. By posting a comment you agree to these terms and conditions.

Please understand that this weblog runs on a third-party comment system, not on Blogger's comment system. If you have come by way of a mobile device and can see this message, you may have landed on the Blogger comment page; your comments will only be shown on this page and not on the page most people will see, and it is much more likely that your comment will be missed (although I do occasionally check to make sure that no comments are being overlooked).