Sunday, September 22, 2013

The Theban Legion

It won't get celebrated in any liturgies today, since it is Sunday, but today is the memorial for the Theban Legion. The Theban Legion, as its name implies, was originally garrisoned in Thebes, Egypt; but, it is said, they were sent by the Emperor Maximian to Gaul to try to keep things in order there. This is very plausible historically, although not all details of the Theban Legion legend are. The commander of the Legion was Mauritius, usually known as St. Maurice, and a lot of the officers, at least, were Christians -- here, too, it was not an uncommon thing for soldiers in this period to be members of an eastern religion like Christianity, particularly on the borders of the empire. The Theban Legion, according to legend, was given the order to sacrifice to the emperor, and St. Maurice and his officers refused. Given the close connection between legions and their officers, it is perhaps not surprising that the entire legion followed their lead. In response the legion was decimated -- every tenth man killed -- as punishment; and when the legion still refused to sacrifice, it was repeatedly decimated until all were dead.

The plausibilities and implausibilities are interesting here -- it's implausible that there was an entire legion that was Christian to a man, but soldiers sticking with their captains is not implausible, and the Gaul campaign is perfectly historical, although our information about it is somewhat sketchy. Our earliest definite reference to the Theban Legion is about a century and a half afterwards, which leaves time for embroidery, and some historians have concluded, on the basis of what other information we have about that campaign (how many soldiers seem to have been involved, etc.), that if it occurred, it was probably a cohort, not an entire legion, that was martyred, or to put it another way, probably several hundred men rather than several thousand. That's a plausible way in which legends form around historical events. Some historians have argued that the decimation is implausible at this point, having long since fallen out of use; on the other hand, if we're talking about a group of soldiers refusing to show recognition to the Emperor in the midst of a major campaign, we're not talking slap-on-the-wrist, either. Others have argued that Christian participation in the Roman military at this stage of the game was actually fairly rare; but, again, the basic structure of the story requires little more than a few officers capable of inspiring loyalty in men. Having organized the plausibilities here we're probably at the edge of what we can actually know about the real roots of the Theban Legion legend, barring some unanticipatable discovery of new direct evidence.

There is a famous painting of the Martyrdom of St. Maurice and the Theban Legion by El Greco.


3 comments:

  1. Enbrethiliel10:22 AM

    +JMJ+



    This must be the only story I've read in which "decimated" was the precise word to use for a mass killing! Was decimation frequently used to punish entire legions in the Roman Empire? ("Frequently" here meaning no more than "used more than once or twice.")


    I really like the idea of being so loyal to your officer that you would die with him if he were martyred. It's like the story of Ruth and Naomi, but with a lot more testosterone!

    ReplyDelete
  2. branemrys3:48 PM

    My understanding was that it was an occasional punishment in the Roman Republic for severe crimes like mutiny or treason, but it was usually never applied to groups larger than a cohort (which was around five hundred people), and that was rare enough.

    I like the idea of such a loyalty as well; Roman soldiers were largely stuck with each other for long periods of time, fighting and working together, so you can imagine how intense the bonds might sometimes have been.

    Of course, I suppose in the long run such loyalty turned out not to be so good for the Roman Empire, because it meant that a charismatic enough general could start a civil war just because he wanted to be Emperor!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Brendan Hodge9:29 PM

    I'm trying to recall where I read about it (wikipedia tells me that both Livy and Polybius mention the practice, so I guess it was probably one or both of those) but decimation does indeed linguistically derive from the Roman practice (meaning literally "taking of a tenth").

    ReplyDelete

Please understand that this weblog runs on a third-party comment system, not on Blogger's comment system. If you have come by way of a mobile device and can see this message, you may have landed on the Blogger comment page, or the third party commenting system has not yet completely loaded; your comments will only be shown on this page and not on the page most people will see, and it is much more likely that your comment will be missed.