The Hume Conference begins tomorrow at the University of Toronto.
Plenary sessions are open to the public and may be attended without registration. All plenary sessions will be held in the George Ignatieff Theatre at Trinity College. The plenary speakers are:
Tuesday: Martha Nussbaum (U of Chicago)
Wednesday: Michel Malherbe (U de Nantes)
Friday: Dan Garber (Princeton)
Saturday: Don Garrett (NYU)
Individual sessions are also open without registration to any UT students or faculty, if they are intending to attend only one or two of the sessions. Lunch and other events require registration.
The schedule for the conference can be found by following the relevant link from the Department of Philosophy homepage.
If you can make it, I strongly recommend it: Hume Society events are quite enjoyable for anyone with a taste for philosophy. There's a reason they call it the Nice Society of Fun People.
Monday, July 18, 2005
A Long Poem Draft
Very rough. For the original, see Judges 5.
Song of Deborah
Then Deborah sang, and Barak sang,
and with these words their voices rang:
When in this land the locks are long,
sing to the Lord a blessing-song;
when people courageously volunteer.
Hear, O kings, and princes give ear,
to the Lord I will now sing,
and make my melody to Israel's King.
Lord, when you marched from out Seir,
the earth did tremble in its fear,
the heavens vanished as you neared,
the clouds with water poured,
the mountains quaked before the Lord,
the Sinai God, Israels' God.
When Shamgar held the judge's rod,
in the days of Jael the roads were waste,
as merchants on the ways made haste,
but the peasants prosper in our day,
the plunder pours upon the way,
because Deborah the judge arose,
a mother whom the God of Israel chose.
When Israel chose other gods to praise,
then war was the demon at the gates,
nor our shields were seen, nor our warriors' spears,
but my heart swells high to the leaders here,
who gave themselves with spear and sword
to save this people; praise the Lord!
You who on white donkeys ride,
or on embroidered cloth abide,
or on the roads now make your way,
frame a song, your praises say
to the music sounds of an oasis sun,
recount the battles the Lord has won,
sing the triumph of the peasants' fate,
when with the Lord they marched on the gates!
Awake, O Deborah, awake!
Arise, your music now to make;
arise, O Barak, captives take!
Then down marched the remnant of the elite,
when the people of God with martial beat
marched out agains the mighty,
marching out into the valley,
following the kin of Benjamin.
From Macher marched the mighty men,
from Zebulun the captains came;
then also was fair Issachar's name
with Deborah and with Barak blessed.
They came at his heels and without rest.
But Reuben wandered in his heart.
Why did you take the slower part?
Why did you stay with the bleating sheep?
Why did Gilead his places keep?
Why did Dan with the ships sit still,
and Asher as though robbed of will,
sitting down by the settled sea?
But Zebulun went, and without fright,
and Naphtali went to the battle heights.
The kings, they came; their swords did ring
against the swords of Canaan's kings.
At Taanach by Megiddo's stream
were banished all of Canaan's dreams.
The stars in their courses Sisera fought
when they from heaven wonders wrought,
when Kishon in torrents swept them away,
when the rain poured down this blessed day!
March on, my soul, with all your might;
the horse's hoof does not tread light
in the galloping of the army steeds.
Says God's angel: Meroz curse,
may the blight on its people yet be worse,
for they did not come to the Almighty's side,
when He cast to the depths the mighty's pride.
Let the deed now be confessed:
Jael is of all women blessed!
He asked for water, she gave him milk,
as smooth and fine as purest silk;
to the nail of the tent she put her hand,
then took up a hammer to save her land,
then struck a blow through Sisera's head.
He sank, he fell, at her feet lay dead.
His temple pierced with the hammer's beat,
he sank and lay still at her feet!
Out of the lattice his mother peers,
Sisera's mother with all her years;
she sits there, exclaiming, wondering:
Where are the chariots thundering?
Why tarries the pounding hoof of horse?
Her ladies answer in due course:
Do they not divide the loot?
For every man a girl or two,
for Sisera the finest suit,
spoil of embroidered stuff, well-made,
that might around the neck be laid?
So may perish, O Lord, your foes,
but your friends are like the sun that shows
in the rising of its might
the dawning of our peace and light.
Song of Deborah
Then Deborah sang, and Barak sang,
and with these words their voices rang:
When in this land the locks are long,
sing to the Lord a blessing-song;
when people courageously volunteer.
Hear, O kings, and princes give ear,
to the Lord I will now sing,
and make my melody to Israel's King.
Lord, when you marched from out Seir,
the earth did tremble in its fear,
the heavens vanished as you neared,
the clouds with water poured,
the mountains quaked before the Lord,
the Sinai God, Israels' God.
When Shamgar held the judge's rod,
in the days of Jael the roads were waste,
as merchants on the ways made haste,
but the peasants prosper in our day,
the plunder pours upon the way,
because Deborah the judge arose,
a mother whom the God of Israel chose.
When Israel chose other gods to praise,
then war was the demon at the gates,
nor our shields were seen, nor our warriors' spears,
but my heart swells high to the leaders here,
who gave themselves with spear and sword
to save this people; praise the Lord!
You who on white donkeys ride,
or on embroidered cloth abide,
or on the roads now make your way,
frame a song, your praises say
to the music sounds of an oasis sun,
recount the battles the Lord has won,
sing the triumph of the peasants' fate,
when with the Lord they marched on the gates!
Awake, O Deborah, awake!
Arise, your music now to make;
arise, O Barak, captives take!
Then down marched the remnant of the elite,
when the people of God with martial beat
marched out agains the mighty,
marching out into the valley,
following the kin of Benjamin.
From Macher marched the mighty men,
from Zebulun the captains came;
then also was fair Issachar's name
with Deborah and with Barak blessed.
They came at his heels and without rest.
But Reuben wandered in his heart.
Why did you take the slower part?
Why did you stay with the bleating sheep?
Why did Gilead his places keep?
Why did Dan with the ships sit still,
and Asher as though robbed of will,
sitting down by the settled sea?
But Zebulun went, and without fright,
and Naphtali went to the battle heights.
The kings, they came; their swords did ring
against the swords of Canaan's kings.
At Taanach by Megiddo's stream
were banished all of Canaan's dreams.
The stars in their courses Sisera fought
when they from heaven wonders wrought,
when Kishon in torrents swept them away,
when the rain poured down this blessed day!
March on, my soul, with all your might;
the horse's hoof does not tread light
in the galloping of the army steeds.
Says God's angel: Meroz curse,
may the blight on its people yet be worse,
for they did not come to the Almighty's side,
when He cast to the depths the mighty's pride.
Let the deed now be confessed:
Jael is of all women blessed!
He asked for water, she gave him milk,
as smooth and fine as purest silk;
to the nail of the tent she put her hand,
then took up a hammer to save her land,
then struck a blow through Sisera's head.
He sank, he fell, at her feet lay dead.
His temple pierced with the hammer's beat,
he sank and lay still at her feet!
Out of the lattice his mother peers,
Sisera's mother with all her years;
she sits there, exclaiming, wondering:
Where are the chariots thundering?
Why tarries the pounding hoof of horse?
Her ladies answer in due course:
Do they not divide the loot?
For every man a girl or two,
for Sisera the finest suit,
spoil of embroidered stuff, well-made,
that might around the neck be laid?
So may perish, O Lord, your foes,
but your friends are like the sun that shows
in the rising of its might
the dawning of our peace and light.
Sunday, July 17, 2005
Three Algerines in 18th-Century London
Part of Boswell's London Journal entry for July 18, 1763:
At the head of St. James's Street I observed three Turks staring about in a strange manner. I spoke a little of English, French, and Latin to them, neither of which they understood a word of. They showed me a pass from a captain of a ship declaring that they were Algerines who had been taken by the Spaniards and made slaves. That they made their escape, got to Lisbon, and from thence were brought to England. I carried them with me to a French house, where I got a man who spoke a little Spanish to one of them, and learnt that they wanted to see the Ambassador from Tripoli, who though not from the same division of territory, is yet under the Grand Signior, as they are. I accordingly went with him to the Ambassador's house, where I found a Turk who could speak English and interpret what they said; and he told me that they had landed that morning and had already been with the Ambassador begging that he would get liberty for them to go in an English ship to their own country; that he was to get them liberty from the Lords of the Admiralty; and that he had ordered them victuals. I gave them half a crown. They were very thankful, and my Turkish friend who spoke English said, "GOD reward you. The same God make the Turk that make the Christian. But the English have the tender heart. The Turk have not the tender heart."
I was anxious to have my poor strangers taken care of, and I begged that they might sleep in the house with the Ambassador. The landlady, a hard-hearted shrew, opposed this vehemently. "Indeed," said she, "I would not suffer one of 'em to sleep in my beds. Who knows what vermin and nastiness they may have brought with them? To be sure I may allow them to sleep on the floor, as they do in their own country; but for my beds, Sir, as I'm a Christian, I could not let them sleep in a bed of mine." Her Christian argument was truly conclusive. Abandoned wretch! to make the religion of the Prince of Peace, the religion which so warmly inculcates universal charity, a cloak for thy unfeeling barbarity! However, I was glad to have it fixed that they should sleep under a roof; and I begged my friend to take care that they lay comfortably.
From Boswell's London Journal 1762-1763, Pottle, ed. McGraw-Hill (New York: 1950) 307-308.
Good for Boswell. As for the landlady -- alas, things never change. It's interesting to get a little glimpse of English attitudes toward foreigners in the eighteenth century, though.
At the head of St. James's Street I observed three Turks staring about in a strange manner. I spoke a little of English, French, and Latin to them, neither of which they understood a word of. They showed me a pass from a captain of a ship declaring that they were Algerines who had been taken by the Spaniards and made slaves. That they made their escape, got to Lisbon, and from thence were brought to England. I carried them with me to a French house, where I got a man who spoke a little Spanish to one of them, and learnt that they wanted to see the Ambassador from Tripoli, who though not from the same division of territory, is yet under the Grand Signior, as they are. I accordingly went with him to the Ambassador's house, where I found a Turk who could speak English and interpret what they said; and he told me that they had landed that morning and had already been with the Ambassador begging that he would get liberty for them to go in an English ship to their own country; that he was to get them liberty from the Lords of the Admiralty; and that he had ordered them victuals. I gave them half a crown. They were very thankful, and my Turkish friend who spoke English said, "GOD reward you. The same God make the Turk that make the Christian. But the English have the tender heart. The Turk have not the tender heart."
I was anxious to have my poor strangers taken care of, and I begged that they might sleep in the house with the Ambassador. The landlady, a hard-hearted shrew, opposed this vehemently. "Indeed," said she, "I would not suffer one of 'em to sleep in my beds. Who knows what vermin and nastiness they may have brought with them? To be sure I may allow them to sleep on the floor, as they do in their own country; but for my beds, Sir, as I'm a Christian, I could not let them sleep in a bed of mine." Her Christian argument was truly conclusive. Abandoned wretch! to make the religion of the Prince of Peace, the religion which so warmly inculcates universal charity, a cloak for thy unfeeling barbarity! However, I was glad to have it fixed that they should sleep under a roof; and I begged my friend to take care that they lay comfortably.
From Boswell's London Journal 1762-1763, Pottle, ed. McGraw-Hill (New York: 1950) 307-308.
Good for Boswell. As for the landlady -- alas, things never change. It's interesting to get a little glimpse of English attitudes toward foreigners in the eighteenth century, though.
Saturday, July 16, 2005
Something New Every Day
A post at Panda's Thumb points out Wells's book God the Invisible King (the Project Gutenberg version has no pop-ups), written in 1917, where Wells lays out what he calls "modern religion," the core of which is "a profound belief in a personal and intimate God," and says, "Without God, the 'Service of Man' is no better than a hobby or a sentimentality or an hypocrisy in the undisciplined prison of the mortal life." Not having read it before, I was surprised; I had thought Wells an atheist, too. He certainly is almost universally considered to be one, perhaps because his The Outline of History had such an influence on so many freethinkers in the English-speaking world. Apparently the matter is more complicated than it is commonly made out to be. Shame on me for presuming in this case; I should know better.
UPDATE: Ralph Luker left a helpful comment, which I'll put here so that it doesn't eventually get deleted when HaloScan gets rid of it:
UPDATE: Ralph Luker left a helpful comment, which I'll put here so that it doesn't eventually get deleted when HaloScan gets rid of it:
Right. H. G. Wells went through some changes. God the Invisible King represents the high tide of his theism and its emergence can be tracked in the work immediately preceding it. I suspect that the theism, which is neither identifiable with Christianity nor particularly hostile to it, had something to do with the spiritual crisis felt by many western intellectuals in the World War I era. In Wells's case, that theism began to ebb soon thereafter and he participates fully in, becomes a major spokesman for, the secularism of the inter-war years.
Ninth Amendment
Jeremy has a good post on the Ninth Amendment at "Parableman". It seems to me that the function of the Ninth Amendment is primarily to make clear the fundamental importance of the people: no one can appeal to the fact that the Constitution doesn't enumerate a right in order to infer that the people do not have it. The Constitution is a set of delegated powers and restrictions made by the people on the government: its purpose is to restrict the government (to the extent that this can be done and the national objects of union, justice, tranquillity etc. be met), not to restrict the rights of the people. A major worry about a bill of rights was the possibility that if any rights were left out, that would be an occasion for someone to argue that they didn't exist at all; preventing that is the basic rationale for an amendment of this sort.
Which is all well and good, theoretically; but how should it function practically? The key phrase for practical use should be the phrase "retained by the people". The way I think a court should regard the Ninth Amendment is this: the people have not retained some rights; the rights given up are those in which we have (in the Constitution) allowed the government to interfere with our lives. However, they have retained many rights, some of which are enumerated, some of which are not. The rights that are enumerated must be protected, simply speaking. As to the unenumerated rights, the point is basically this:
People can never be presumed by the government not to have a right, as long as it does not fall into the category of rights they have explicitly (in the Constitution) not retained.
Or, in practical terms: when it comes to determining whether the government can do a given thing, the burden of proof should fall on the government to show that in this action it remains within the field of Rights Explicitly Not Retained By the People. In other words, the real force of the Ninth Amendment should be to require that the government stay within its Constitutionally authorized bounds, and be able to show that it has done so. (The Tenth Amendment does something similar.)
I think Jeremy is right that attempting to parse the Ninth Amendment by enumerating the unenumerated rights is doomed to failure. It's on the right track, in the sense that the courts have the responsibility not to ignore the Ninth Amendment and the duty to take it seriously. But the best way to do that is not to enumerate the rights the people have retained, but to make clear that the government gets no free passes to do something merely because the Constitution doesn't explicitly say it can't; in other words, to make sure that the government only do what the Constitution says it can. The enumerated rights go one step further, since they have to be respected even where the government has been given power; and Jeremy is right, I think, that when it becomes necessary to enumerate a right (as it sometimes has been necessary), the way to do it is by amendment.(*) Indeed, as Jeremy notes, the only constitutional way to enumerate a right is by amendment. For other rights, the Constitution merely says we can't be presumed by the government not to have them.
(*) It occurs to me, though, as one possible exception to this, that people do have enumerated rights that are not enumerated in the U.S. Constitution: namely, additional rights enumerated in their State Constitutions. This, when combined with the Tenth Amendment, has the potential for special judicial bite. Thus, to take just one example, the Vermont Constitution explicitly gives the people (through their legal representatives) "the sole, inherent, and exclusive right of governing and regulating the internal police" of Vermont; it gives each member of society "a right to be protected in the enjoyment of life, liberty, and property," "a natural and inherent right to emigrate from one state to another that will receive them," and so forth. When the Ninth Amendment is combined with the Tenth Amendment, the effect is that residents of Vermont have certain enumerated rights, although they are not enumerated in the U. S. Constitution, that the federal government must respect in any matters to which both the Ninth and Tenth Amendments extend. Thus, even if one thinks the Ninth Amendment weak on its own, it has the potential for important effects when combined with other amendments.
Which is all well and good, theoretically; but how should it function practically? The key phrase for practical use should be the phrase "retained by the people". The way I think a court should regard the Ninth Amendment is this: the people have not retained some rights; the rights given up are those in which we have (in the Constitution) allowed the government to interfere with our lives. However, they have retained many rights, some of which are enumerated, some of which are not. The rights that are enumerated must be protected, simply speaking. As to the unenumerated rights, the point is basically this:
People can never be presumed by the government not to have a right, as long as it does not fall into the category of rights they have explicitly (in the Constitution) not retained.
Or, in practical terms: when it comes to determining whether the government can do a given thing, the burden of proof should fall on the government to show that in this action it remains within the field of Rights Explicitly Not Retained By the People. In other words, the real force of the Ninth Amendment should be to require that the government stay within its Constitutionally authorized bounds, and be able to show that it has done so. (The Tenth Amendment does something similar.)
I think Jeremy is right that attempting to parse the Ninth Amendment by enumerating the unenumerated rights is doomed to failure. It's on the right track, in the sense that the courts have the responsibility not to ignore the Ninth Amendment and the duty to take it seriously. But the best way to do that is not to enumerate the rights the people have retained, but to make clear that the government gets no free passes to do something merely because the Constitution doesn't explicitly say it can't; in other words, to make sure that the government only do what the Constitution says it can. The enumerated rights go one step further, since they have to be respected even where the government has been given power; and Jeremy is right, I think, that when it becomes necessary to enumerate a right (as it sometimes has been necessary), the way to do it is by amendment.(*) Indeed, as Jeremy notes, the only constitutional way to enumerate a right is by amendment. For other rights, the Constitution merely says we can't be presumed by the government not to have them.
(*) It occurs to me, though, as one possible exception to this, that people do have enumerated rights that are not enumerated in the U.S. Constitution: namely, additional rights enumerated in their State Constitutions. This, when combined with the Tenth Amendment, has the potential for special judicial bite. Thus, to take just one example, the Vermont Constitution explicitly gives the people (through their legal representatives) "the sole, inherent, and exclusive right of governing and regulating the internal police" of Vermont; it gives each member of society "a right to be protected in the enjoyment of life, liberty, and property," "a natural and inherent right to emigrate from one state to another that will receive them," and so forth. When the Ninth Amendment is combined with the Tenth Amendment, the effect is that residents of Vermont have certain enumerated rights, although they are not enumerated in the U. S. Constitution, that the federal government must respect in any matters to which both the Ninth and Tenth Amendments extend. Thus, even if one thinks the Ninth Amendment weak on its own, it has the potential for important effects when combined with other amendments.
A Hopeless Errand in a Long Defeat
Loren Rosson has a great post, called Tolkien vs. Jackson: One Man's Hopelessness, Another Man's Hope, at "The Busybody." He uses Jackson's film adaptation to highlight a major difference between it and the book: Jackson's masterpiece is about hope, but Tolkien's masterpiece is about hopelessness -- not an absolute hopelessness, since hope does occasionally pop up, but certainly a general hopelessness. Tolkien's characters are fighting a battle they all know they will lose; they are on quests that they intend, at most, to buy time in the face of inevitable defeat. They make it through not on the basis of hope but on the basis of cheer and courage in the face of an apparently irresistible doom.
Friday, July 15, 2005
Bonaventure on the Image of God
Bonaventure says a great deal about the Image of God; I can't possibly do justice to all of it. A set of selections from the Itinerarium, Chapter III:
He then goes through the powers, showing how each of the activities of each of the powers participates God in some way. At the end he says:
He then gives the standard Augustinian Trinitarian exposition:
Then we have the distinctively Bonaventuran discussion. Bonaventure, if you've never read him, is ingenious at making lists; most medieval scholastics are, but he is the Great List-maker among all the scholastics. This comes through clearly when he continues by discussion how the Trinitarian image of the soul is reflected in philosophy:
All these triads are traditional, but the steady adaptation of traditional triads to Trinitarian thought is one of Bonaventure's strengths.
These are by no means the only things Bonaventure says about the Image of God. But a full account of them, with adequate commentary, would take a book. My intention here is just to point out some of them.
[English translations are from Saint Bonaventure, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum, Philotheus Boehner, tr. The Franciscan Institute (Saint Bonaventure, New York: 1956) 63-71. I don't entirely like this translation, but it is the most easily available. I've added the Latin, not very consistently, where I think the translation might be a little misleading.]
Enter into yourself, therefore, and observe that your soul loves itself most fervently; that it could not love itself unless it knew itself, nor know itself unless it summoned itself to conscious memory, for we do not grasp a thing with our understanding unless it is present in our memory. Hence you can observe, not with the bodily eye [oculo carnis], but with the eye of the mind [oculo rationis], that your soul has three powers. Consider, therefore, the activities of these three powers and their relationships, and you will be able to see God through yourself as through an image; and this indeed is to see God through a mirror in an obscure manner [in aenigmate].
He then goes through the powers, showing how each of the activities of each of the powers participates God in some way. At the end he says:
See therefore, how close the soul is to God, and how, through their activity, the memory leads us to eternity, the intelligence to Truth, and the elective faculty to the highest Good [in bonitatem summam secundum operationes suas].
He then gives the standard Augustinian Trinitarian exposition:
Moreovoer, if one considers the order, the origin, and the relationship [habitudinem] of these faculties to one another, he is led up to the most blessed Trinity itself. For from the memory comes for the intelligence as its offspring, because we understand only when the likeness which is in the memory emerges at the crest of our understanding [in acie intellectus] and this is the mental word. From the memory and the intelligence is breathed forth love, as the bond of both. These three -- the generating mind, the word, and love -- exist in the soul as memory, intelligence, and will, which are consusbtantial, co-equal and contemporary, and interpenetrating [circumincedentes]. If God, therefore, is a perfect spirit, then He has memory, intelligence, and will; He has both a Word begotten and Love breathed forth, which are necessarily distinct, since one is produced by the other -- a production, not of an essence [non essentialiter], nor of an accident [non accidentaliter], but of a Person [ergo personaliter].
The soul, then, when it considers itself through itself as through a mirror [speculum], rises to the speculation [speculandum] of the Blessed Trinity, the Father, the Word, and Love, Three Persons co-eternal, co-equal and consubstantial, so that whatever is in any one is in the others, but one is not the other, but all three are one God.
Then we have the distinctively Bonaventuran discussion. Bonaventure, if you've never read him, is ingenious at making lists; most medieval scholastics are, but he is the Great List-maker among all the scholastics. This comes through clearly when he continues by discussion how the Trinitarian image of the soul is reflected in philosophy:
For all philosophy is either natural, or rational, or moral. The first is concerned with the cause of being [de causa essendi] and thus leads to the power of the Father; the second is concerned with the basis of understanding [de ratione intelligendi] and thus leads to the Wisdom of the Word; the third deals with the order of life [de ordo vivendi] and thus leads to the goodness of the Holy Spirit.
Hence the first, natural philosophy, is divided into metaphysics, mathematics, and physics. Metaphysics deals with the essences of things; mathematics, with numbers and figures; and physics, with natures, powers, and diffusive operations. Thus the first leads to the first Principle, the Father; the second, to His Image, the Son; and the third, to the gift of the Holy Spirit.
The second, rational philosophy, is divided into grammar, which makes men capable of expressing themselves; logic, which makes them keen in argumentation; and rhetoric, which makes them apt to persuade or move others. This likewise suggests the most Blessed Trinity.
The third, moral philosophy, is divided into individual, familial, and political. The first of these suggests the unbegettable nature of the First Principle [primi pincipii innascibilitatem]; the second, the familial relationship of the Son [Filii familiaritatem]; and the third, the liberality of the Holy Spirit.
All these triads are traditional, but the steady adaptation of traditional triads to Trinitarian thought is one of Bonaventure's strengths.
These are by no means the only things Bonaventure says about the Image of God. But a full account of them, with adequate commentary, would take a book. My intention here is just to point out some of them.
[English translations are from Saint Bonaventure, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum, Philotheus Boehner, tr. The Franciscan Institute (Saint Bonaventure, New York: 1956) 63-71. I don't entirely like this translation, but it is the most easily available. I've added the Latin, not very consistently, where I think the translation might be a little misleading.]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)