Friday, October 26, 2012

Poem Draft

Not quite in season, but it came to me this evening.

On Butterflies, for Brigitte and Arsen

Soft visions unfold, untwist like string,
like harmonies birds in the garden sing,
and burst to bloom
with colored wing
in dusty, sunny, windowed room:
by joke or grace (only God knows why)
the fairest flowers learn to fly.

Unfolding Every Hour

Light Shining Out of Darkness
by William Cowper


God moves in a mysterious way
His wonders to perform;
He plants His footsteps in the sea,
And rides upon the storm.

Deep in unfathomable mines
Of never-failing skill
He treasures up His bright designs,
And works His sovereign will.

Ye fearful saints, fresh courage take,
The clouds ye so much dread
Are big with mercy, and shall break
In blessings on your head.

Judge not the Lord by feeble sense,
But trust Him for His grace;
Behind a frowning providence
He hides a smiling face.

His purposes will ripen fast,
Unfolding every hour;
The bud may have a bitter taste,
But sweet will be the flower.

Blind unbelief is sure to err,
And scan his work in vain;
God is His own interpreter,
And He will make it plain.

It's unclear whether Cowper invented the phrase in the first line (by which the poem is most commonly known) or is simply the earliest witness to a phrase used more commonly; but, of course, Cowper's popular poem has been a contributing factor to the widespread recognition of similar phrases. Like many of Cowper's hymns, it is chiaroscuro; Cowper suffered from severe depression, severe enough that he had attempted suicide several times. Thus a great many of Cowper's poems are about darkness; but, at the same time, they are also often about how it is never the whole story, and never has the last word.

Thursday, October 25, 2012

Greater Scandinavia and Fennoscandia

For various reasons I've been researching, off and on, various features of what might be called Greater Scandinavian and Fennoscandian cultural sphere. It's somewhat difficult to pin down the bounds of it, so I'm trying to think through its boundaries, and I thought I'd do so 'out loud' here on the blog, in case anyone had any thoughts.

Scandinavia as such, Scandinavia Proper, we might call it, is pretty clearly established as the following countries:

Sweden
Norway
Denmark

Sweden and Norway are both on the Scandinavian Peninsula, which they share with Finland; Denmark is across the way on the Jutland Peninsula and the Danish Islands. It's not normal to think of them as such because of their significant differences, but they can be said to share a language, broadly speaking -- Danish, Swedish, and Norwegian, while in many ways very different, nonetheless share enough that they are, with a little work, mutually intelligible. They are, so to speak, clearly dialects of the Scandinavian superlanguage. There are ethnic and historical links, all of them quite close.

Nonetheless, there are complicating factors. Take, for instance, Denmark. Denmark is itself part of a Commonwealth of nations, the Danish Realm, which includes the following nations:

Denmark
Faroe Islands
Greenland

In effect, they constitute one nation with three autonomous jurisdictions, all under the Danish Crown. All three were at one time part of the Kingdom of Norway. Danish is certainly spoken in both Greenland and the Faroe Islands. The only official language of Greenland is Kalaallisut, which is an Inuit language, but this is a relatively recent thing (2009), as it used to share the honors with Danish, and Danish is still widely spoken. The Scandinavian links with Greenland are extensive and go back a thousand years; allowing for a few centuries of interruption, Greenland has been linked with Scandinavia in one way or another. The Faroe Islands, which are north of Britain, are a similar story, except that the Faroese are ethnically Scottish as well as Scandinavian, and that Faroese is itself a descendant of Old Norse, and so is itself a Scandinavian language. So if we include the Danish Realm in Greater Scandinavia, we've added an Inuit nation in North America, and while one would technically include the Faroe Islands in Europe, it's notable that while Denmark is part of the European Union, the Faroe Islands are not.

If, however, we take the entire Danish Realm into Greater Scandinavia, it makes sense to count in Iceland, too. Iceland is not part of the Danish Realm, but it used to be, until 1944. Icelandic, like Faroese, is an Old Norse derivative and thus related to Norwegian. And Denmark and Norway at one time formed two relatively autonomous parts of one kingdom, which had Greenland, the Faroe Islands, and Iceland as its dependencies.

It would in any case be a candidate for other reasons. When we are talking about Greater Scandinavia, we are usually talking about the nations of the Nordic Council, or Nordic Nations:

Denmark
Iceland
Norway
Sweden
Finland

Thus Iceland gets on the list as a full member. The following are associate members of the Nordic Council:

Greenland
Faroe Islands
Åland Islands

The Åland Islands are an autonomous Swedish-speaking jurisdiction associated with Finland. And the following have observer status:

Estonia
Latvia
Lithuania

Should one include these? Well, if you are including Finland there's very little reason not to include Estonia, which is a Baltic nation just across the way from Finland, has an ethnically Finnic population, and has a language that is very closely related to Finnish. And Estonia spent time both as Danish territory and as Swedish territory.

Finland, in turn, is an odd nation. It is on the Scandinavian Peninsula and one of its official languages is Swedish, but its other official, and certainly primary, language, Finnish, is a radically different language from any of the Scandinavian languages. The Scandinavian languages are all Indo-European languages of North Germanic type, all deriving from Old Norse. Finnish, on the other hand, is not even Indo-European; it is a Uralic language. There are a lot of cultural similarities, and a lot of cultural differences.

Sweden is in a sense the culprit here. It's difficult for us to remember it, since Sweden comes across now as an unassuming nation, but this is a modern thing. Sweden, of course, was a Viking nation. And in the seventeenth century it was one of the greatest powers in Europe. There's an argument that can be made that for at least a short time it was the most powerful European nation. Swedish military reforms had made the Swedish army an almost unstoppable juggernaut. At its height the Swedish Empire included not only Sweden but also Finland, modern-day Estonia, much of modern-day Latvia and Lithuania (hence, I suppose, their observer status), Russian Karelia, and bits and pieces of north Germany (Pomerania, in particular). Finland was Swedish for about five and a half centuries, and an important part of the Swedish Empire at its height. Then it was seized by Russia, and was a Russian Grand Duchy for quite some time. It broke away in 1917, and after a civil war, managed to stabilize for a while. (Estonia was also seized by Russia, also broke away in 1917, managed to avoid civil war, but had to extricate itself from a short German occupation.)

There is another designation, Fennoscandia, which includes the following:

Norway
Sweden
Finland
(in Russia) Karelian areas and the Kola Peninsula

And this does seem to identify some significant cultural commonality.

So, of the Scandinavian countries we've noted imperial reach. But how far should one really take it? Northern Scotland was Norwegian territory for centuries; the Danes had kingdoms in England once long ago; and so forth. Some of this reach dried up, of course. And, of course, there are various immigration cultures linked to it, as well -- Norwegian by way of Minnesota, and the like. While Greater Scandinavia is generally taken to be the Scandinavian Peninsula plus Denmark, the full sphere of Scandinavian influence is quite extensive.

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Nearest Kin of the Moon

The Cat And The Moon
by William Butler Yeats


The cat went here and there
And the moon spun round like a top,
And the nearest kin of the moon,
The creeping cat, looked up.
Black Minnaloushe stared at the moon,
For, wander and wail as he would,
The pure cold light in the sky
Troubled his animal blood.
Minnaloushe runs in the grass
Lifting his delicate feet.
Do you dance, Minnaloushe, do you dance?
When two close kindred meet
What better than call a dance?
Maybe the moon may learn,
Tired of that courtly fashion,
A new dance turn.
Minnaloushe creeps through the grass
From moonlit place to place,
The sacred moon overhead
Has taken a new phase.
Does Minnaloushe know that his pupils
Will pass from change to change,
And that from round to crescent,
From crescent to round they range?
Minnaloushe creeps through the grass
Alone, important and wise,
And lifts to the changing moon
His changing eyes.

On Humean Axiomatics

There is a lovely book, little read now, I suppose (although it still makes it into footnotes), but lovely and worth reading for anyone who is interested in the philosophy of David Hume, called Hume's First Principles. It was published in the 1960s and its author was Robert Fendel Anderson. One of the points of the book is that a great deal of Hume's basic philosophy derives from two principles:

(1) Whatever is conceivable is possible.
(2) Whatever is distinguishable is separable.

From these two, with very little work, Hume is able to derive two more substantive claims:

(3) The mind does not perceive any real connection among distinct existences.
(4) Distinct perceptions are distinct existences.

These already have substantive ramifications. You get something even more Humean if you add to them the basic principle of Hume's empiricism, the Copy Principle:

(5) All our simple ideas in their first appearance are deriv’d from simple impressions, which are correspondent to them, and which they exactly represent.

I've noted before that Hume's arguments are often more carefully reasoned than they look. So I was thinking today about how one might go about constructing Humean philosophy synthetically. You'd start with (1), (2), and (5); you'd need to postulate the existence of at least one mind; you'd need definitions for perceptions/ideas, real connections, impressions, and the like. What else might you need to add, or at least have in the system? An obvious candidate are the principles of association.

(6) Ideas are associated by resemblance, contiguity in time and place, or causation.

Which would require definitions for association, resemblance, contiguity, and causation, and would probably need to be specified into several different principles. The definition for causation would obviously be something like Hume's own. Hume scholars often talk about Hume's account of causation in terms of 'revival sets', so if you gave a definition of a 'revival set' -- roughly, the set of ideas that can come to mind when itis faced with another idea -- you could probably use it as a basis for your association principles. In any case, you'd want Hume's Rules by which to Judge of Cause and Effect somewhere:

(7) The cause and effect must be contiguous in space and time.

(8) The cause must be prior to the effect.

(9) There must be a constant union betwixt the cause and effect.

(10) The same cause always produces the same effect, and the same effect never arises but from the same cause.

(11) Where several different objects produce the same effect, it must be by means of some quality, which we discover to be common amongst them.

(12) The difference in the effects of two resembling objects must proceed from that particular, in which they differ.

(13) When any object encreases or diminishes with the encrease or diminution of its cause, it is to be regarded as a compounded effect, derived from the union of the several different effects, which arise from the several different parts of the cause.

(14) An object, which exists for any time in its full perfection without any effect, is not the sole cause of that effect, but requires to be assisted by some other principle, which may forward its influence and operation.

The relation among these is somewhat interesting. (7), (8), and (9) are obviously just Hume's basic account of what causation is (objectively speaking). Hume says (10) is derived directly from experience, so it also is basic; it, which can be called the Experimental Principle, is also extremely important, since Hume says most philosophical reasoning (which would include most scientific reasoning) depends on it. Hume explicitly appeals to (10) in his arguments for (11), (12), and (14), and while he is somewhat vague, I think (13) is based on (9). It has been noted that (10) and (11) are very similar to principles of reasoning formulated by Isaac Newton, and this is certainly deliberate.

From (10) and (13) Hume elsewhere ("Of Interest") derives another principle,

(14) An effect always holds proportion with its cause.

And so one could continue on. One of the reasons why one would do this would be to clarify the relations between Hume and other people. For instance, I get off the boat quite early, since I don't think (2) is correct (it makes modal logic impossible, at least in any robust interpretation, which I imagine would be fine with Hume, but which is not fine with me). James Clerk Maxwell, the physicist, has an interesting passage in one of his books (Matter and Motion, I think), in which he argues that the second half of (10), "The same effects have the same causes" is a sort of general philosophical maxim from which one can derive what Maxwell calls the "Statement of the General Maxim of Science" -- "The difference between one event and another does not depend on the mere difference of the times or the places at which they occur, but only on differences in the nature, configuration, or motion of the bodies considered". So Maxwell certainly accepts the second half of (10), although he thinks it needs to be clarified and specified further. However, Maxwell also explicitly denies the first half of (10), at least as Hume would understand it: Maxwell famously insists that it is only true when the system is such that small initial variations only produce small final variations (what we would call a non-chaotic system). So we see something of how a Maxwellian account of Newtonian physics would diverge from a Humean account of Newtonian physics.

The second reason, of course, why one would do this is simply to get a better sense of Hume's philosophy itself, in much the same way that, while Heyting's logic is not the same as Brouwer's intuitionism, it gives one a better sense of what the latter implies.

ADDED LATER: Another one of note (from T 1.1.5 (SBN 14-15)):

(15) No objects will admit of comparison, but what have some degree of resemblance.

And another possibility (from T 1.3.2 (SBN 75)):

(16) There is nothing existent, either externally or internally, which is not to be consider'd either as a cause or an effect.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Music on My Mind



Club for Five, "Brothers in Arms". Originally a Dire Straits song, of course.

Two Poem Drafts

New Helen

Your beauty is disastrous, dear,
as when a man sleeps, dreaming,
and visions come, inspiring fear
and setting cities screaming --

so lovely is your brilliant eye,
so full of angel-weather,
their hurricanes can make men die
or run in fear forever.

Herdsman's Song

My joy has journeyed on this path;
my loved one set her foot here;
my dear one has walked this road.
In the glade, a print: she stepped here,
there she sat on rising stone.
This stone is better than the next stone,
this glade is brighter than the last glade,
that grove is sparkling, its honey sweeter,
all the forest fairer she has made
by walking on this road, my dear one.