Tuesday, June 02, 2020

The Solidarity of the Shaken

One of the recurring ideas in Scruton's Notes from Underground is that of 'the solidarity of the shaken', an idea derived from the phenomenology of Jan Patočka. Patočka was a student of Husserl. He was banned from teaching by the Communist regime in 1972, and most of his later works circulated only as samizdat, typed up on carbon copies and circulated a dozen or so copies at a time. In 1976, a number of dissident intellectuals put together a criticism of Czechoslovakia's failure to implement the human rights conventions that it had signed; this criticism was published the next year and became known as Charter 77 (a term that was sometimes also applied metonymically to its signatories). Patočka was one of the signatories, and, indeed, a major spokesperson for the group. The state came down hard on everyone involved; Patočka was subjected to an extended interrogation and, being almost seventy years old at the time, died about a week and a half later.

'The solidarity of the shaken' is primarily discussed in his Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History, published as samizdat in 1975. The work, which is quite dark, is a reflection in six essays on nihilism and war, and could be regarded as an extending of the Heraclitean saying, "War (Polemos) is father of all." We find ourselves going about our lives in the comfort of the familiar, the habitual everyday, and this prereflective attitude is one that becomes severely disrupted by major events. In the face of a truly major event, one such that we can no longer trust to the familiar categories and ordinary ways, we are stimulated to a higher reflection -- our assumptions about reality are ripped by reality itself, we are shaken from our everyday, and we are forced to find a way to continue in the face of this shaking. Patočka posits this as a significant driver of history. Polemos is the father of all; polemos gives us the polis and philosophy. In the Persian and Peloponnesian Wars, for instance, Athens undergoes a transformation, and the transformation is that of an awareness of itself as a city, and a city of a certain kind.

Perhaps the most important of Patočka's examples are taken from the twentieth century, which is in a very preeminent way a century of war. And Patočka points to an experience not uncommonly had in the trenches on the front, of all the assumed meanings of the world vanishing away, but this being experienced not merely as a loss but also as a liberation. You are faced with the fact that you were sent there as a sacrifice but this also brings to the fore a sense of one's freedom for self-sacrifice, not for this or that particular cause, but as such, as a free and living being; and one also is faced with something so immense that it puts everything in a new perspective -- the enemy is not merely the enemy, but someone enduring the same hellish situation. It is a situation in which one might expect nihilism but instead in which openness to this reality becomes a new kind of meaning, and a result of it is the solidarity of the shaken, "the solidarity of those who are capable of understanding what life and death are all about, and so what history is about" (p. 134). This solidarity is not so much deliberately formed as called forth by the experience of the shaking itself; it is a sense of 'we are all in this together', where this is something terrible -- but also terrible enough to bring a sort of clarity of mind with it.

Everydayness is what leads to war; we go about our plans for peace, and strife grows from the conflict of plans that we are assuming. The solidarity of the shaken raises us out of that:

The solidarity of the shaken is built up in persecution and uncertainty: that is its front line, quiet, without fanfare or sensation even there where this aspect of the ruling Force seeks to seize it. It does not fear being unpopular but rather seeks it out and calls out quietly, wordlessly. Humankind will not attain peace by devoting and surrendering itself to the criteria of everydayness and of its promises. All who betray this solidarity must realize that they are sustaining war and are the parasites on the sidelines who live off the blood of others. (p. 135)

This solidarity, in other words, can be communicated; the shaking is not ineffable. But notice also that the solidarity can be betrayed. There is a sense in which this solidarity is fragile. It is hard for us all to be in this together if this ceases to be; we can slip easily back into the everyday. This is an aspect Scruton explores in his novel at some length.

***

Jan Patočka, Heretical Essays in the Philosophy of History, Kohák, tr., Dodd, ed., Open Court (Chicago, IL: 1996).

Monday, June 01, 2020

Mater Ecclesiae

Today is also the feast of Mary, Mother of the Church.

Meanwhile, standing near the cross of Jesus were his mother,
and his mother’s sister, Mary the wife of Clopas,
and Mary Magdalene.
When Jesus saw his mother and the disciple whom he loved standing beside her,
he said to his mother, “Woman, here is your son.”
Then he said to the disciple, “Here is your mother.”
And from that hour the disciple took her into his own home.
[John 19:25-27 (NRSV).]

One of the literary functions of the references to the beloved disciple, never given a proper name in the Gospel, is that it makes it possible for readers to 'occupy', as readers, the beloved disciple's place in the story and see it from that perspective. Despite emphasis on reading Scripture, we often don't really consider the ways in which Scripture teaches precisely by being read, drawing us into the narrative as readers in such a way that we are taught as readers. This is true throughout Holy Writ; this is just a particularly good example of it.

The Latest, Loveliest Jest

June
by Clive Bell


They say you are the latest, loveliest jest
Of some transmigratory ghost,
The last embodiment, and best,
Of some small being—tell me, are you most
Yourself when most
A squirrel or jerboa?
Or rather,
Since you are tender, humorous, and wise,
Is yours the spirit of some steadier goer,
A grave, precautious donkey, whose wide eyes
See, far away, the thin ambiguous towers,
Nor miss the pebbly road nor truant flowers—
See farther,
And less painfully, than ours?
Or, as I think,
Have you, like some
Too curious spirit peering from the East,
O'erleant the ramparts or your little town
In Fairyland; and from the brink
Of The Impossible tumbled down
To where we now uneasily surmise
Your vagrant figure, trailing Sirenwise—
Strayed reveller, from some fairy banquet come
To sow sedition at our sober feast?

1915.

Sunday, May 31, 2020

Iustinus Martyr

Tomorrow, June 1, is the feast of St. Justin Martyr, who could perhaps be considered the patron saint of this blog, both because he is a patron saint of philosophers and because I first decided to do a blog on St. Justin's Day in 2004. What follows is a somewhat modified version of a post from 2016.

****

Over the years, I've noted St. Justin's Middle Platonism, his quotation of Plato's Timaeus, his account of philosophical disagreements, the irony of his martyrdom under Marcus Aurelius, the Stoic philosopher, by accusations from Crescens, the Cynic philosopher. But it might perhaps be worthwhile to consider martyrdom itself. Justin is fittingly remembered under the name 'Martyr', for more reasons than just the fact that he was one. Justin's Second Apology can be itself read as an account of the rationality of martyrdom.

The Stoics and Cynics, you might recall, seem to have taken the Christians to be zealots eager to die because they had excited their imaginations with fantastic stories. It's perhaps unsurprising, then, that Justin responds by emphasizing the ways in which both Stoic philosophers and their philosophical heroes insisted on dying when the matter was forced upon them:

And those of the Stoic school--since, so far as their moral teaching went, they were admirable, as were also the poets in some particulars, on account of the seed of reason [the Logos] implanted in every race of men-- were, we know, hated and put to death,--Heraclitus for instance, and, among those of our own time, Musonius and others. For, as we intimated, the devils have always effected, that all those who anyhow live a reasonable and earnest life and shun vice, be hated.

Contrary to the Cynic accusation, he argues, Christians do not rush toward their deaths; but death is a debt every human being must pay, and Christians, understanding the true nature of the world, give thanks when they pay that debt. This fearlessness in the face of death shows forth the true value of virtue, and, Justin notes, led to his own conversion:

For I myself, too, when I was delighting in the doctrines of Plato, and heard the Christians slandered, and saw them fearless of death, and of all other things which are counted fearful, perceived that it was impossible that they could be living in wickedness and pleasure. For what sensual or intemperate man, or who that counts it good to feast on human flesh, could welcome death that he might be deprived of his enjoyments, and would not rather continue always the present life, and attempt to escape the observation of the rulers; and much less would he denounce himself when the consequence would be death?...For I myself, when I discovered the wicked disguise which the evil spirits had thrown around the divine doctrines of the Christians, to turn aside others from joining them, laughed both at those who framed these falsehoods, and at the disguise itself, and at popular opinion; and I confess that I both boast and with all my strength strive to be found a Christian; not because the teachings of Plato are different from those of Christ, but because they are not in all respects similar, as neither are those of the others, Stoics, and poets, and historians.

Who does not have the faith of the martyrs, does not have the faith.

Saturday, May 30, 2020

La Pucelle

Today is the feast of St. Jeanne D'Arc. From "Joan of Arc, in Rheims", by Felicia Hemans:

–She unbound
The helm of many battles from her head,
And, with her bright locks bow'd to sweep the ground,
Lifting her voice up, wept for joy, and said,–
"Bless me, my father, bless me! and with thee,
To the still cabin and the beechen-tree,
Let me return!"

Oh! never did thine eye
Thro' the green haunts of happy infancy
Wander again, Joanne!–too much of fame
Had shed its radiance on thy peasant-name;
And bought alone by gifts beyond all price,
The trusting heart's repose, the paradise
Of home with all its loves, doth fate allow
The crown of glory unto woman's brow.

John Everett Millais - Joan of Arc
Joan of Arc, by John Everett Millais

Friday, May 29, 2020

Dashed Off XI

An experiment has (1) an introduction of something (2) into a boundary that bounds (3) process-parts and (4) structure-parts, and from this (5) educes a measurement. Kinds of experimental failure: introduction contamination (1); boundary collapse (2), eduction contamination (5), unaccounted-for defect of structure (4), unaccounted-for defect of process (3).

The Church's attitude to politics should often be: Everything of value saved from a burning house is a gain.

memorative - combinatorial - inductive - analogical - deductive - narrative

-- no possible naturalistic proof of naturalism
-- either simply investigate the natural (and thus no need to naturalize metaphysics) or develop metaphysics on the evidence you have for it, whatever it may be (and thus no need to naturalize metaphysics). 'Naturalizing metaphysics' simply shows you to be an idiot in two directions.
-- naturalism is a have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too philosophy

Lombard's Sentences can be seen as a treatise on sacraments:
Res
---Bk 1: Fruition (God)
---Bk 2: Use (Creation)
---Bk 3: Christ
Signum
---Bk 4

"We properly call 'sacrament' that which is a sign of God's grace and the appearance of invisible grace, in such a way as to carry its image and to be its cause." Lombard

The sacrament of matrimony, through conjugal acts and other acts of friendship between the spouses, remits venial sin. (Note that this is different from cases where the sacrament makes what would be a mortal sin merely venial; matrimony as a sacrament remits venial sins in general through its acts.) See Thomas Aquinas on 1 Corinthians (sect. 329). This is due to the role of charity, which remits venial sins, in the sacrament.

No Catholic, without grave sin, may treat the tribunal of mercy as subordinate to any human tribunal or magistrate.

nonsacramental confession // nonsacramental anointing for healing
-- the primary difference is only that we have an individual moral obligation to confession, even if there is no opportunity for the sacrament

genuine repentance where absolution cannot be received in sacrament // baptism of desire

Beginning a dialogue in itself posits that general relativism is false.

When I see a brown table, I am not 'appeared to brownly'; nothing about the act of appearing is brown in mode; what I find is a brown-desk appearing, not an appearing that is a brown kind of activity, whatever that would be.

God called the patriarchs to form a people (baptism), strengthened them with prophets (confirmation), and formed a priesthood for them (ordination).

Prayer is not something 'in our heads' but an interaction with our environment in light of the object of prayer, an attending with body and soul.

Unction affirms the place of the sick in the Body of Christ.

the logical agent as represented by a system of operations

life, the good life, eternal life

funerals as an adjunct to baptism

Even under natural law, marriage is a sign of the union of the divine and the human, and of the fruitfulness of the world God has created.

Matrimony confers a grace, an office, and a remedy.

Alexander of Hales holds that penance, like matrimony, is an uplifting of something prior to the Fall: namely a preservative medicine. (He takes this to be the reason why the two don't have an immediately obvious sensible element.) Unlike marriage, the uplift (adding the power of the keys) adds a modification, a relation to temporal punishment, which is why it requires a new minister and marriage does not.
-- Alexander's view of penance makes sense if one thinks of the original relations of Adam and Eve as union with each other (marriage) and subordinating union with God.

When we say that God creates all things visible and invisible, we are not excluding things audible and inaudible; and likewise when we say that sacraments are visible signs of invisible grace.

In the Eucharist, by being united to Christ people are united to each other; in Matrimony, by being united to each other people are united to Christ.

baptism : unction :: eucharist : matrimony :: interior : exterior

Henry of Ghent, the four powers a person can have over the same thing
(1) fas (equity by nature)
(2) licitum (law)
(3) ius (equity giving claims)
(4) necessitas (opportuneness)
-- from the Decretum; look more closely

W. P. Boring (2010): Both Bonaventure and Aquinas read Augustine as rejecting a purely Platonic epistemology and thus as being (generally) more consistent with Aristotelian epistemology than with Plato. Aquinas (ST 1.84) takes Augustine, like himself, to walk a middle road: the key to this is the agent intellect, which is required to make phantasms actually intelligible. Bonaventure (DQ4) reads Contra Academicos as taking Platonic epistemology to result in Academic skepticism, and thus rejecting it with the latter; the key again, is the agent intellect. They are, however, considering different questions. More precisely, what Bonaventure takes as a unified question, Aquinas takes as multiple questions. Both contrast with Henry of Ghent, who replatonizes Augustine.

By the sacrament of matrimony, God makes the Church a society suitable for union with Christ.

Nestorianism as implying a false idea of motherhood

The Virgin's being Mother of God is a reflection from the Hypostatic Union; it is not structured like the Hypostatic Union.

"The most holy Virgin is truly the precious ark which received the whole treasure of sanctity." Gregory Thaumaturgos

Mary's plenitude of grace as plenitudo redundantiae

intercession in Scripture
Abraham: Gn 18:23ff
Moses: Ex 32:11
Job: Job 42:8
Paul: Acts 27:34ff
Oniah and Jeremiah: 2 Macc 15:12ff

Prayers go up in the midst of the angels:
Angels offer prayers Tobit 12:12; Rv. 8:4
Angels rejoice over repentance: Lk 15:10

relics
Joseph's bones: Ex 13:19
Elisha's bones: II Chr 13:21
Jesus' garment: Mt 9:20ff
Peter's shadow: Acts 5:15
Paul & cloths: Acts 19:11ff

Gospel, Cross, Icons, and Relics as major material elements of the Tradition of the Church (II Nicaea)

If the Cross is sacred because it bore Christ, so Mary is sacred because she bore Christ. If the Ark of the Covenant was sacred because the Spirit of God came upon it, so Mary is sacred because the Spirit of God came upon her.

The great heresy for economics is to think that there is no distinction between reasonable and unreasonable price in an exchange.

Not mere markets, nor merely open (often misleadingly called 'free') markets, but open markest of free and informed people making exchanges that are mutually beneficial and consistent with common good, to the exten that this can be done.

two notes of human labor, which all economic policies must respect: labor is personal and labor is necessary (Leo XIII)

money as measure of value → medium of exchange → generic capital

Capital has no use beyond the bare using of it. It is remarkable how many economic theories ignore this.

Legitimate interest is protective of the equality and mutual beneficiality of the exchange; it is negotiated, not imposed; and it is open and not secret, being explained that the benefit may be known.

4 distinct leftist movements
Left-LARPists ( Stupid Young Things ( Worker-Left ( Old Guard Left

development of doctrine
(1) ratiocinative
--- (a) in explication
--- (b) in implication
--- (c) in insinuation
--- (d) in practical effect
(2) expressive
--- (a) translation
--- --- (1) new vocabulary
--- --- (2) new language
--- --- (3) new genre
--- (b) illustration
--- --- (1) new analogies
--- --- (2) new examples
--- (c) application
--- --- (1) new activities
--- --- (2) new contexts

technical writing
(1) work-guiding
--- (a) problem-solution breakdown
--- (b) reference
(2) background-building
--- (a) practice breakdown
--- (b) causal account

indigenic vs. cultigenic tradition-bearers
(With respecting to handing down the Passion, sermons on the Passion are indigenic; The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is cultigenic.)

All extrinsic denomination has some intrinsic ground or reason making it possible; asusming, of course, that the extrinsic denomination is not merely applied in error.

Substance both subsists and substands; the problem with the Lockean notion of substance is that it only really considers substance as substanding.

Abelard holds that God creates genera, as a human artisan makes particular works.

what the senses show, what they imply, what they suggest

the four elements of the conception of divine in American civil theology
(1) governance
(2) mercy
(3) observation
(4) distance
-- this is, I think, a more accurate way of framing than in "America's Four Gods" (Froese & Bader); when you look at actual people, it's a matter of emphasis, and many people think divine providence cuts across the borders (they are, as it happens, right).

Much of what calls itself liberalism is in fact pseudo-democratism.
constructed pseudo-demos, fictive demos

Irony requires recognizing different points of view; it is an inherently social figure of speech.

the distinctive, obligative, configurative, and dispositive aspects of the sacramental character as a sign

Baptism : King :: Confirmation : Prophet :: Ordination : Priest
(Pohle/Preuss)

But I, I Cannot Read It

The Song of the Strange Ascetic
by G. K. Chesterton


If I had been a Heathen,
I’d have praised the purple vine,
My slaves should dig the vineyards,
And I would drink the wine.
But Higgins is a Heathen,
And his slaves grow lean and grey,
That he may drink some tepid milk
Exactly twice a day.

If I had been a Heathen,
I’d have crowned Neaera’s curls,
And filled my life with love affairs,
My house with dancing girls;
But Higgins is a Heathen,
And to lecture rooms is forced,
Where his aunts, who are not married,
Demand to be divorced.

If I had been a Heathen,
I’d have sent my armies forth,
And dragged behind my chariots
The Chieftains of the North.
But Higgins is a Heathen,
And he drives the dreary quill,
To lend the poor that funny cash
That makes them poorer still.

If I had been a Heathen,
I’d have piled my pyre on high,
And in a great red whirlwind
Gone roaring to the sky;
But Higgins is a Heathen,
And a richer man than I:
And they put him in an oven,
Just as if he were a pie.

Now who that runs can read it,
The riddle that I write,
Of why this poor old sinner,
Should sin without delight-
But I, I cannot read it
(Although I run and run),
Of them that do not have the faith,
And will not have the fun.