Tuesday, January 05, 2010

In the Direction of the Palm Gardens

Royalty
by Arthur Rimbaud
(Bertrand Mathieu, tr.)


One fine morning, in a land of extremely gentle people, a very beautiful man and woman called out, quite loud, in a public space: "Dear friends, I want her to be queen!" "And I want to be queen!" She was laughing and trembling. He was telling friends about a revelation, about an ordeal they'd come through. They were weak with happiness.

As a matter of fact, they were royalty for a whole morning, while the houses were covered with bright-red bunting, and for a whole afternoon, while they walked in the direction of the palm gardens.

Sunday, January 03, 2010

Seventh Day of the Month

As I sometimes do at the turn of a New Year, here is a list of the posts on the seventh day of each month of 2009.

January: no post on the seventh day of the month

February: Flowers Preach

March: Sidecar Bar & Grill
Kant and 'Existence Is Not a Real Predicate'
Lenten Giving

April: Chaospet on "The End of Philosophy"
The End of Philosophy?
Clothed with the Wisdom and the Power

May: Clausewitz on the Use of Historical Examples

June: Not Acceptable
Malebranche's Infinity Challenge (Repost)
We Have Not Sighed Deep, Laughed Free

July: Usury and Titles to Interest
Physics and Philosophy

August: Neo-Humean Theology

September: Aquinas on Manual Labor

October: Five Ways of Teaching

November: The Lotus (Part I)

December: Marenbon on 'Aquinas's Principle' (Repost)

Object and Occasion

Pascal Boyer, Religion Explained, Basic Books (New York: 2001), p. 86:

In many places Christians also treat some artifacts as endowed with special powers. People for instance go to a distant place to pray to a particualr Madonna, which means standing in front of an artifact and talking to it. (You may find this description rather crude, and retort that no one is really talking to a man-made object; peple are considering a "symbol" of the Virgin, a "sign" or "representation" of her presence and power. But that is not the case. First, people are really representing the Madonna as an artifact. If I tell them who made it, using what kind of wood and paint, they will find all that information perfectly sensible, as it would be indeed of any other man-made object. Second, it really is the artifact they are addressing. If I proposed to chop the Madonna to pieces because I needed firewood, and suggested that I could replace it with a photograph of the statue or with a sign reading "pray to the Virgin here," they would find that shocking.)


I think the conclusion Boyer is ultimately angling toward here is actually quite right: focusing on the question of representation and setting aside the question of belief (which are independent questions, the latter being rather more complicated, and having a very complicated and rarely straightforward relationship with the former) such cases are clearly cases of representing artifacts as having special powers. But this is a singularly bad argument for this conclusion. If we took Boyer's first point seriously as relevant to the conclusion, this would be as much as to say that there are no signs, symbols, or representations -- pretty much all signs, symbols, or representations are artifacts, so it is irrelevant to whether we are treating something as a sign, symbol, or representation that we represent it as having artifactual features. If I paint a squiggle on a sign to represent water, there is no question that this is an artifact; it is also a sign.

But it's the second point I just find funny. Obviously if you suggest cutting up a Madonna for firewood people will find that shocking, but this in itself tells us nothing. If the local veterans put up a wooden copy of the Marine Corps War Memorial and you suggested cutting it up for firewood, people would be shocked at that, too; but there's nothing to guarantee that people typically represent war memorials as artifacts with cognitive powers, or, indeed, any powers. People are shocked by mistreatment of symbols precisely because they are functioning as symbols. Whether they are shocked by mistreatment does not seem to have any relevance to whether they treat the artifact as an artifact simply or as possessing other-than-artifactual characteristics; but it would have to if it were to function as a sign that the artifact is an object of address rather than merely an occasion of it.

In practice the difference between object and occasion is made in a rather different way. Suppose you and I are interacting via avatars in Second Life or some similar virtual reality program. When I respond to something you say I am addressing your avatar: it is an object of address. It is also an artifact (and, indeed, a sign, symbol, or representation), and in representing the object of my address I am treating it as an artifact with cognitive characteristics -- the cognitive characteristics it displays, which are, of course, yours. I actually address the avatar; it is not merely functioning as an indicator of presence (in the way that, for instance, an instant messaging indicator that you are online). Likewise, it is clear that an icon of Mary is not functioning as a mere indicator that Mary is available or a reminder that she may be addressed, although it may do that as well; this is inconsistent with actual behavior toward the icon. It's the actual behavior involved in the address that is crucial, not the sort of emotional attachment that is the reason for being shocked at the destruction or replacement of the icon; the emotional attachment could be due to the fact that the icon is an object of address, but it could be due to any number of other things as well.

Saturday, January 02, 2010

Two Poem Re-Drafts and a New Poem Draft

The first is a minor re-drafting, the second a cannibalizing of a poem based on a poem by Seneca, and the third new.

Gray Skies

Skies are gray today; but what of it?
Every gray sky has blue sky above it,
and warm light;
when gray clouds are done
out will spring the splendid sun,
clear and bright.

Pagan

Swiftly spring to winter tends
as all things hurry to their place;
but swifter far than to this end
do human hearts to nothing race.
With nothing left, no more than death,
the final goal, so swiftly found,
let craving flee with fleeing breath,
resign to fate with reason sound,
and, if you fear the heart's last beat,
then bury fear within the grave.
Time and night do not retreat.
Death will not in mercy save.
The road before is yet unknown;
who of our spirit's fate is sure?
Ask those now laid beneath the stone,
ask those who never lived nor were --
but still the battle-lines are drawn,
still I stand, though but a husk,
and though there may not be a dawn
I yet may have a hero's dusk.

On the Genealogy of Christ

Long years stretch back
where legends walk and men
who toiled in the lack
and famine born of sin;
long years, and endless days
of men at city gates
as women in sundry ways
bore children and life's weight,
and not one, not one, knew
the things God had in store,
how simple things and true
heaven's promise bore,
not one person dreamed
in households in the land
the light of heaven gleamed
in married life's demand,
that fathers grown from sons
and mothers made from maids
would be the chosen ones,
foundations heaven-laid,
that in their daily work
to live and to survive
hope would begin to lurk
and glory to revive,
that God, our God, in men
blood and womb would mesh
to make himself our kin,
our cousin, Word made flesh.

Friday, January 01, 2010

Admin Note

Haloscan, the free commenting service I have used since almost the beginning of this blog (back in the long-ago days before Blogger was acquired by Google), is being phased out, so I'm trying out a different commenting platform. We'll see how it goes. In the meantime, there may be some oddities in how comments are handled here, until I decide how best to arrange the settings.

Transfiguring, Subtle, Mad, Divine

Every artist knows how far from any real feeling of letting himself go his "most natural" state is--the free ordering, placing, disposing, giving form in the moment of "inspiration"--and how strictly and subtly he obeys thousandfold laws precisely then, laws that precisely on account of their hardness and determination defy all formulation through concepts (even the firmest concept is, compared with them, not free of fluctuation, multiplicity, and ambiguity).

What is essential "in heaven and on earth" seems to be, to say it once more, that there should be obedience over a long period of time and in a single direction: given that, something always develops, and has developed, for whose sake it is worth while to live on earth; for example, virtue, art, music, dance, reason, spirituality--something transfiguring, subtle, mad, and divine.


Friedrich Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil, Part V, section 188, Kaufmann, tr. Vintage (New York: 1966), pp. 100-101. As he calls it earlier in the passage, it is a 'long compulsion', and to understand what is inestimably valuable in, say, Stoicism, you should look for that in it which can be compared to something like the compulsion of meter and rhyme on language, which educates and strengthens and makes more alive the very words we use.

Parables

I collect little parables and fables that I think are interesting. Here are some of the ones that have made it here to Siris.

Scratches on Silver
Morning Three, Afternoon Four
Sufi at Prayer
The One Overlooked Thing
The Fox and the Grapes
The Rooster Prince
The Container of Water
Monkeys and Shoes
Broken Window
Naked in a Barrel
Crossing the River
The Bag Behind
The Mountains in Labor
The Dog in the River
Race to Mecca
What You Should Never Forget
Three Pods of Pepper