Wednesday, February 15, 2023

The Shimmery Ladders of My Soul

 Forbidden Magic
by Robert E. Howard 

There came to me a Man one summer night,
When all the world lay silent in the stars,
And moonlight crossed my room with ghostly bars.
He whispered hints of weird, unhallowed sight;
I followed – then in waves of spectral light
Mounted the shimmery ladders of my soul
Where moon-pale spiders, huge as dragons, stole –
Great forms like moths, with wings of wispy white. 

 Around the world the sighing of the loon
Shook misty lakes beneath the false-dawn’s gleams;
Rose tinted shone the sky-line’s minaret;
I rose in fear, and then with blood and sweat
Beat out the iron fabrics of my dreams,
And shaped of them a web to snare the moon.

Tuesday, February 14, 2023

Links of Note

 * Donald L. M. Baxter, Instantiation as partial identity (PDF)

* Thomas Szanto, Collective Emotions, Normativity, and Empathy: A Steinian Account (scroll down)

* Robert Di Ceglie, Divine Hiddenness and the Concept of God (PDF)

* Stefan Blancke, Science as a moral system

* Enno Fischer, Actual causation and the challenge of purpose

* Oliver Traldi, Busting the myth of left and right, reviews Lewis & Lewis, The Myth of Left and Right

* Bret Devereaux on Rings of Power, at "A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry":
Why Rings of Power's Middle Earth Feels Flat
Nitpicks of Power, Part I: Exploding Forges
Nitpicks of Power, Part II: Falling Towers
Nitpicks of Power, Part III: That Numenorean Charge

* Carlo Lancellotti, Sexual Colonization

* TheOFloinn on poetry: O Tempo! O Morae!

* Roy Cook, Frege's Logic, at the SEP

* The Sojourner Truth Project on the two main written versions of Sojourner Truth's most famous speech

* Clare Marie Moriarty, Berkeley's Gland Tour into Speculative Fiction, Part I: Homer, Descartes, and Pope

* Vicent Lloyd, A Black Professor Trapped in Anti-Racist Hell

* Jon Haidt, The Teen Mental Illness Epidemic Began Around 2012

* The Complete Review reviews George Schuyler's Black Empire. The book is an interesting one; it's a deliberately pulpy potboiler, and Schuyler's intention in writing seems to have been a half-sarcastic response to other stories of a similar type, but Dr. Belsidus ends up being a fascinating character.

* Kevin Vallier, Defining social trust is a first step toward nurturing it

* James Berquist, Uncommon Confusion: The New Natural Law Theory's Confusion of Predication and Causality Destroys the Natural Order, at "The Josias"

Monday, February 13, 2023

Logres XIV

 continuing Book II

Chapter 13

It was the morning of Candlemas day and King Arthur and his men were viewing matters outside of the castle of Bedegraine when they came to a brook, beside which stood a carl with a bow in his hand and arrows in his girdle. He was dressed in a russet cloak and black sheepskin and had great boots of leather. In the brook were wild geese and ducks, sporting gently in the waters as their kind often do. With one arrow the man shot a goose through the neck and with another immediately afterward shot a mallard as it took flight; both were excellent shooting. Then King Arthur asked the man if he would sell the birds he had taken.

"Yes," said the carl, "and gladly."

"And what do you ask in return?" King Arthur said in reply. 

But the man gave no answer for a moment. Then he said, "Kings are stingy folk and not apt to reward good service. I give you these birds freely, but will you dare to give me a gift in return?"

"What gift do you wish?" asked the king.

"A great measure of treasure," said the man.

"Surely these birds are not worth a great measure of treasure, however one measures it," the king replied.

"You are mistaken," the carl said in return, "because if you give me a great measure of treasure, you will be wealthier for it, and these birds are surely worth becoming richer."

And King Arthur began to be somewhat angry with him. "How can I become richer by giving you much treasure for few birds?"

"It is easy enough, if you pay with a treasure you only have in buying the birds. Will you promise to buy them, in return for a third of such a treasure?"

"I promise to buy them, if you promise I will be wealthier by doing so," said the king.

"So do I promise," said the carl, "and my promises are more sure than the promises of kings. Beneath this very field a large treasure is buried, put there for safekeeping in the days of King Cole by a chieftain long since dead. For the birds, give me a third, and you will be richer for the rest."

The king looked at him narrowly. "How do you know that there is a treasure buried beneath this field?"

The carl said, "A wild man named Merlin told me it was so, and he it was who told me I should be here to meet you at this time." Then the man turned to Sir Ulfius, who was standing by, saying, "Sir Steward, take these birds and cook them in a supper for your pauper lord who is so reluctant to become wealthy."

At this, Sir Ulfius burst out laughing, and Sir Brastias next to him began to smile. And when King Arthur asked him why he laughed so hard, Sir Ulfius only laughed harder.

Then the carl turned to Sir Kay, saying, "Sir Seneschal, perhaps you should take these birds and pluck them for supper, as no one else will, for surely your king must eat if he is not to waste away." And at this Sir Brastias also began to laugh. When the king asked him why he was laughing, he replied that he would tell the king, if the carl would give his consent.

At this, the carl began to laugh himself, and he said to Sir Ulfius, "Tell him so that he will finally take these birds and the treasure."

And Sir Ulfius said to King Arthur, "Sir, this man who speaks to you is Merlin."

Then King Arthur blessed himself in abashed wonder, for when he looked again at the carl, incredulous of Sir Ulfius's claim, he saw that it was indeed Merlin. Then all who were there had great merriment. 

The treasure was dug up and taken to Castle Bedegraine, where they feasted, including in the feast Merlin's birds. But Merlin sent part of his third to Blaise and, needing no money for himself, the rest distributed to the poor.


Chapter 14

In those days, many chieftains and nobles were pledging faith to King Arthur, and among them came a count named Savin, who arrived to pay his respects and swear his allegiance with his daughter Lysianor. She was surpassingly fair. King Arthur loved her swiftly, and she him, and they had much ado, and he begat a child on her. This child she named Amhar, and when he was old enough, he served as squire and guard to King Arthur's chambers. He became a good knight of the Round Table, and he was noble, and handsome, and skilled in spear and sword. His deed of greatest renown was the slaying of a giant, named Logrin, who had destroyed a hundred valiant knights before him. But in the battle, Sir Amhar was greatly wounded, and was never wholly right in the head again. He went about doing good for some time in various disguises and under various names, such as Sir Loholt, Sir Borre Stronghearted, and Sir Smervie, and when he took such names he seemed to forget that he was Sir Amhar for a while. He grew more and more unstable until one day he attacked King Arthur and Sir Kay with the violent force of a madman, and in protecting Sir Kay, King Arthur slew Sir Amhar, although he had tried to avoid it. Sir Amhar was buried in Ariconium, in Ergyng, in a place that the locals called Licat Amir, where the spring and head of the Gamber River is found. It was said in later days that when men would measure the cairn, it never had the same measurement twice.

But none of this was yet to come to pass. And Merlin a few days after Lysianor and King Arthur had sported said to King Arthur, "Desire is like the Baying Beast for the commotion it causes. For a king to have children out of wedlock is dangerous to a kingdom, and any bastard child you beget will be dangerous to you. Temperance is your wisest course." But King Arthur was a young man and gave this little heed.

One of the kings who paid homage to King Arthur, although through an envoy, was Leodegrance of Cameliard. This King Leodegrance when younger had been a friend of King Uther and a knight of Uther's Round Table. In retaliation for his alliance with Arthur, he was invaded by King Rience of North Wales. Then Merlin said to King Arthur, King Ban, and King Bors, "This man is an ally worth having, and your position among the kingdoms depends on aiding those allied with you."

King Arthur said, "You have no need to encourage me to this; I intended to give him aid as soon as I heard of this." Then the three kings rode forth with twenty thousand men. The forty days were at that time drawing toward their end and the paschal season was approaching, so that they came to the palace of King Leodegrance on the eve of Easter. As the kings entered the presence of King Leodegrance with their immediate guard, King Ban saluted him, saying, "We would not have presumed to enter your realm, good sir, except that we wished to serve you in the defense of your realm, on one condition alone, that you do not yet ask us our names."

King Leodegrance in turn welcomed them all, for he did have the numbers of men to fight the invading forces of King Rience; for King Ban and King Bors were clearly men capable of war, and all of the men that King Leodegrance saw with them were strong bachelors richly arrayed. Afterward, Merlin led them to the lands of a vavasor, named Sir Blaires, who with his wife Dame Lionell ran a thriving estate; both were noble and fair and were good to God and to the world, much given to hospitality. There they prepared as King Leodegrance summoned has friends and followers to meet at Toraise by the feast of the Ascension to begin a major offensive campaign against King Rience. The main host of King Leodegrance was led by Sir Hervi, or Herveus, known as the Rivell, and Sir Cleodalis, the steward of King Leodegrance; Sir Hervi the Rivell had been a renowned knight of the Old Round Table of King Uther, and was now of considerable age, not having been young even in Uther's day, although still hale and clear of mind. But King Rience struck swiftly, and, having spies in the court of King Leodegrance, by a cunning trap seized King Leodegrance himself before the forces had fully assembled. Then he struck at the remaining army led by Sir Hervi and Sir Cleodalis with the fullness of his forces before they could otherwise respond. The army of King Leodegrance was hard-pressed, but as they fought, the host of the three kings, led by Merlin, came to the battlefield.

For a while the battle equalized and the upper hand went back and forth between the two armies; but after there had been much fighting, Merlin cried out in a great voice to the three kings to follow him. This shout they all heard clearly, but no one else on the battlefield could. Then the three kings withdrew with their immediate guard, leaving Sir Kay and Sir Ulfius in charge of their troops who remained, and followed after Merlin at full gallop. Soon they came to a deep valley and overtook the men who had seized King Leodegrance. 

Then Merlin cried, "Upon them in defense of the king, and let not a single one escape to bring reinforcements!" Then like a thunderstorm the knights drove into the midst of them, lance clashing on shield and armor, and they killed and slew all the foe, rescuing King Leodegrance, despite being outnumbered many to one. King Leodegrance marveled at these strange allies who, though so few, could destroy a host so much larger, and he thanked God for the help that had been sent him. Merlin and Sir Brastias unbound him, and aided him into his armor, and brought him a strong, swift steed.

Then Merlin cried out again, "Gentle knights, why do you tarry? There is yet a battle to be won!" And again he sped away, and they all followed, returning to the battle. There Merlin unfurled the dragon banner of Aurelius and Uther. It shone like gold and gems in the bright sunlight, and great flames of fire came out of the dragon's mouth, so that all who saw were astonished, and the light of it was seen even in sunlight from miles away. And King Ban unsheathed his famous sword Coreuseus, delivering stroke left and right, and it seemed as if the sword were enchanted, because nothing could stand in its way. Not far from him, King Bors did much the same and slew Sir Sarmedon, King Rience's standardbearer. The greatest of all the feats on the field were done by King Arthur, wielding the Sword from the Stone, shining with brilliant light, with Sir Kay at his side, smiting off hands and heads and arms and thighs, casting down knights and horses and men. But many were the knights in the guard of the three kings who achieved things out of the ordinary. So Leodegrance was saved and the army of King Rience was scattered.

King Leodegrance held a great feast in thanks for the three kings, and was thankful to an even greater degree in learning their names. At that feast, the three kings were given the highest hospitality, and instead of a servant serving their cups, they were served by King Leodegrance's own daughter. Her name was Guinevere. She was lively and beautiful, and King Arthur did not fail to notice her; nor did she fail to listen with great interest to the tales told of his valor.

Afterward, wealthy with the spoils of their battles, King Ban and King Bors returned to their own country. King Arthur wished to go with them, but King Bors said to him, "Nay, not at this time, for you still have much to do in these lands. We have received great treasures by your gift and grace, and we return to our lands better equipped to withstand the malice of King Claudas. If we have need of you, we will send for your aid, and if you have need of us, send for us and we will not tarry."

Merlin said to them, "It will not be necessary for you to come again to this island for purposes of war, for these eleven kings shall be dealt a great blow by two valiant brothers. But you will have great need within a year or two, and King Arthur will come to aid you and avenge you, as you have done to him."

Then they returned to their own lands across the channel. The eleven kings were greatly taxed in the north by the coming of the Saxons, who did not come in a single wave but in many. Nonetheless they did not cease to scheme their vengeance for the battle at Bedegraine.


Chapter 15

After the departure of King Ban and King Bors, Merlin went to visit Blaise. King Arthur rode to Caerleon, and there to his surprise was met by an envoy from King Lot of Lothian, which was led by King Lot's queen, Morgause. She came purportedly to consider possible options for peace, but in reality she had been sent to spy, a task for which she was well suited, for she was a woman of great beauty and charm. With her came her four sons, Gawain, Gaheris, Agravain, and Gareth, and many other knights and ladies. She and the king talked long, and he conceived a passion for her, encouraged by her, and he slept with her. She stayed a month, and then returned to Lothian, but she was by then pregnant with a child, who, when born, she named Mordred. Queen Morgause was in fact King Arthur's half-sister, being the daughter of Duke Gorlois and Igraine; but neither of them knew this at the time.

The queen had scarcely left when King Arthur had a dream that chilled him to his inmost core. In the dream, the land was overrun by great serpents and fierce griffins who slew and burned the people of the land. He fought them and slew them, although he was wounded sorely before he had succeeded. When he woke, he was heavy with the burden of the dream, so he called for his horse to go hunting, in the hope of lightening his mind. No sooner had King Arthur and his knights entered the horse than he saw a great hart, which leaped swiftly away. He gave pursuit so intensely and speedily and at such length that his horse lost its breath and fell down dead and a yeoman had to fetch the king another horse. Then King Arthur sat beside a fountain brooding, for he deemed the event a bad omen. As he sat, he heard a great noise like a pack of thirty hounds on the quest, but he saw no hounds. Instead, he saw the strangest creature he had ever seen coming to drink from the fountain. It was pure white, with a head like a snake, and a body like that of a leopard, and haunches like a lion, and feet like that of a hind. All of the noise like the pack of thirty hounds came from a rumbling in its belly, but the noise ceased while it was drinking and only continued again when it stopped. Then it left, moving swiftly through the trees, but not in a straight line. King Arthur marveled at this, but soon afterward a knight came through the undergrowth on foot.

Seeing Arthur, the knight said, "Good knight, pensive and sleepy, have you seen a strange beast pass this way?"

"I have," said King Arthur. "It is not two miles hence. Why do you seek this beast?"

"Sir," said the knight, "I have followed it long, for the past twelvemonth, so that my horse died in the pursuit."

At that moment, the yeoman returned with King Arthur's fresh horse, and the knight begged the king to have it.

"Sir," said King Arthur, "let me have this quest and follow it for twelvemonth."

"Your desire is in vain," said the knight, "for none but I or my kin shall catch it." And at this the knight mounted King Arthur's horse and said, "I will take this."

"You may take my horse by force," said the king, "but I would test whether you or I were better in the saddle."

"Well," said the knight, "I will be near here if you ever have the mind and means to do it." And he went his way.

King Arthur commanded his men to bring him a new horse, and as he waited he was deep in thought. Soon a youth, fourteen years of age, came by and saluted him, asking why he was so thoughtful.

"I have good reason to be thoughtful," said King Arthur, "for I have seen the strangest sight that one can imagine."

"I know this well," said the youth, "for I know the Baying Beast."

"And what can you know of the Baying Beast?" the king asked the boy with some surprise.

"All things that are to be known about it," said the boy. "The mother of the beast was a princess who conceived an unnatural desire for her brother. The devil then took his form, and she satisfied her lust with him, but he treated her in such a fashion that she accused him of rape to her father. In a rage, their father had the brother torn apart by a pack of thirty hounds, but before his death he prophesied that she would bear a strange and abominable beast with a voice like a pack of dogs. Such is the end of all disordered love. So you see that I know the Baying Beast, and I also know you, and all your thoughts, but you are fool, for thinking will make no amends."

"You know nothing about me," said King Arthur.

"I know that you are the son of King Uther Pendragon," said the youth, "who begot you on the Duchess Igraine."

"This is false," said King Arthur, "and in any case, how could a boy such as you know these things?"

"I know these things better than anyone," said the youth, "for people like you are blind to what is clear and see only in a fog."

Then King Arthur was angry with the child, but the child passed on. Soon there came by an old man, of about eighty years of age.

"Why are you so sorrowful?" asked the old man of the king.

"I have many things for which to be sad," said the king. "But most recently, because a boy told me terrible things he should not be able to know."

"And yet the boy was right," said the old man, "and he would have told you many more things if you had had the patience of a king and endured his telling of it. But you do have reason to sorrow, for God is displeased with you and you have lain with your sister; a child will be born of her come May Day, and there is in him the destiny to destroy you and all the knights of your kingdom."

"What are you," asked the king, "that you tell me these things?"

"I am Merlin," said the old man, and he was no longer an old man but Merlin as the king had known him, "and I was Merlin when I walked by a little while ago as a boy."

"You are a man of marvels," said King Arthur, "but the greatest marvel is your prophecy of my destruction."

"It is not so great a thing to predict that men will die," replied Merlin. "But it is indeed God's will that you be punished in body for the transgression of sacred bounds. But you may yet have honor in these things. I will be denied such, and have first a living death and then at the end be slain in a terrible way by the Antichrist."

As they were talking, the new horse arrived. King Arthur mounted the horse and rode back to Caerleon, where he found Merlin already there. The king summoned both Sir Ector and Sir Ulfius and asked if it was true that he was the son of King Uther Pendragon, and they told him all they knew. 

Then the king said to Merlin, "I wish to speak with my mother, and if she says the same, I will believe it."

"If that is what is required," said Merlin.

The queen was sent for in great haste, and she came, bringing her daughter with her. Her daughter's name was Morgan, who was later called the Fay, and she was a beautiful young woman with cleverness and savvy beyond the normal lot. The king welcomed them both in the fairest way.

To Clouds and Winds and Ghosts that Shun the Sun

 Cimmeria
by Robert E. Howard

I remember
The dark woods, masking slopes of sombre hills;
The grey clouds' leaden everlasting arch;
The dusky streams that flowed without a sound,
And the lone winds that whispered down the passes.

 Vista upon vista marching, hills on hills,
Slope beyond slope, each dark with sullen trees,
Our gaunt land lay. So when a man climbed up
A rugged peak and gazed, his shaded eye
Saw but the endless vista--hill on hill,
Slope beyond slope, each hooded like its brothers. 

 It was a gloomy land that seemed to hold
All winds and clouds and dreams that shun the sun,
With bare boughs rattling in the lonesome winds,
And the dark woodlands brooding over all,
Not even lightened by the rare dim sun
Which made squat shadows out of men; they called it
Cimmeria, land of Darkness and deep Night. 

 It was so long ago and far away
I have forgotten the very name men called me.
The axe and flint-tipped spear are like a dream,
And hunts and wars are like shadows. I recall
Only the stillness of that sombre land;
The clouds that piled forever on the hills,
The dimness of the everlasting woods.
Cimmeria, land of Darkness and the Night. 

 Oh, soul of mine, born out of shadowed hills,
 To clouds and winds and ghosts that shun the sun,
 How many deaths shall serve to break at last
 This heritage which wraps me in the grey
 Apparel of ghosts? I search my heart and find
 Cimmeria, land of Darkness and the Night.

Sunday, February 12, 2023

Fortnightly Book, February 12

 Robert E. Howard was born in Peaster, Texas in 1906. He was fascinated by poetry and stories from an early age, and, because of an extraordinary memory, often could recite what he had read after only one or two readings. Eventually he started submitting his own creations to magazines; he did not have much luck for a while, in part because he had to discover on his own what would sell. He slowly began to hit his stride when he found that he could occasionally something to Weird Tales. He then had a few instances of unusually good success with an experimental form of story, one about a man from Atlantis named Kull and another about a Puritan swashbuckler named Solomon Kane, and with these the genre of sword-and-sorcery was born. And in 1932, he began to have a new set of ideas for where to take this line; Cimmeria, the land populated by descendants of Atlantis, and a new hero, Conan the Cimmerian, was born. From the very first published story in which he appeared, Conan became a hit with readers, always in demand, and in the next few years Howard sold a fair number of stories about him. This success gave Howard some room to write more widely; despite its popularity and lasting appeal, in his own lifetime Howard actually made more money with westerns. But despite being a prolific writer, Howard had not long left. As his mother approached death due to tuberculosis in 1936, Howard, already subject to long bouts of depression, walked out to his car one June day, pulled a gun out of the glove compartment, and shot himself in the head.

The next fortnightly book is a book that I picked up some years ago at Half Price Books and it has mostly just gathered dust in a box until, wondering what next to read, I happened to see it. It is simply titled Conan the Barbarian and consists of nine short stories plus Howard's essay, "The Hyborian Age", about the world of Conan. The short stories were all published in Weird Tales and are as follows (with their first publication date in parentheses):

"Shadows in the Moonlight" (April 1934)
"Queen of the Black Coast" (May 1934)
"The Devil in Iron" (August 1934)
"The People of the Black Circle" (September-November 1934)
"A Witch Shall Be Born" (December 1934)
"Jewels of Gwahlur" (March 1935)
"Beyond the Black River" (May-June 1935)
"Shadows in Zamboula" (November 1935)
"Red Nails" (July-September-October 1936)

This is about half of the total number of Conan stories that were published by Weird Tales, so it covers a fair amount.

The realm of Atlantis has fallen and been forgotten. The various Hyborian nations have conquered almost all of the northwest of the world. But nations rise and nations fall. The mighty Hyrkanians press in from the East; the South resists Hyborian rule and expansion; and from the North the descendants of the snow apes the Hyborians had once driven north have begun to press southward with ever more irresistible force. It is an age of tumult and destruction, of chaos and ferment. Conan, once a warrior of some renown, wanders throughout the world in search of adventure. He will surely find it....

Saturday, February 11, 2023

Certain Members of the Detection Club, The Floating Admiral

 Introduction

Opening Passage: There are several different things that one could identify as 'the beginning' of the book: Sayers's Introduction, Chesterton's Prologue, Whitechurch's Chapter I. Given the peculiar character of the book as a unified narrative with divided authorship, and the fact that much of the interest of the book consists in how the different mystery authors come together, I choose to treat Sayers's Introduction, which explains the rules by which it was written, as the 'real' beginning of the work:

When members of the official police force are invited to express an opinion about the great detectives of fiction, they usually say with a kindly smile: "Well, of course, it's not the same for them as it is for us. The author knows beforehand who did the job, and the great detective has only to pick up the clues that are laid down for him. It's wonderful," they indulgently add, "the clever ideas these authors hit upon, but we don't think they would work very well in real life." (p. 1)

Summary:  A mystery work written by thirteen different authors, each taking a chapter and able to take the story anywhere as long as they respect what came before, is truly a mystery, even to the authors. Canon Whitechurch's first chapter gives us the basic puzzle. A man, the Admiral, was stabbed to death. He is found in a boat which had drifted to the shore. There is no blood in the boat. The Admiral was last seen, it seems, crossing the river in his own boat, having had dinner with his daughter and the Vicar. But the boat in which the Admiral's corpse has been found is not his own boat. It is the Vicar's boat, and nobody knows the course of events between when the Admiral was last seen alive in his own boat and when his corpse was discovered elsewhere in the Vicar's boat. Nor does anyone have any obvious motive to stab the Admiral to death; nor does there seem an obvious explanation for why anyone, after having stabbed him to death, would put him in the Vicar's boat and set it adrift. What's more, the little village of Lingham where all this happens is a tiny insular place, in which could have lived for a decade and still be seen as an outsider, so Inspector Rudge will have a bit of work to do to get people to open up.

In many ways, the course of the book is determined by the manner of its production. A mystery writer puts a twist or two into his or her story. Twelve mystery writers in a row (excluding Chesterton, who writes the Prologue that is supposed to intrigue but doesn't contribute to the actual course of the narrative), writing twelve chapters, means that there is a twist or two or three in every single chapter. The inevitable result is that this is a book of red herrings. Over and over and over again we are led up a path only to find it shut down in front of us. The obvious suspect turns out not to be in the right place. People keep turning up in places where they shouldn't be able to be at times they shouldn't be able to be there. Evidence will point to one person at one point, then the same evidence will swing around and suggest someone else. The result is a fascinating puzzle mystery, although, despite the immense talent on display, it is probably too bewildering to be counted as a great mystery story.

The authors of each chapter were expected to have a particular ending in mind, and we have some of their anticipated endings provided as an appendix. It underlines a point about the narrative, which is that so many authors guarantees that the very nature of the mystery story changes over the course of the book. We have an entire range of approaches on display, from the highly systematic writers (John Rhode, Dorothy Sayers, and Ronald Knox, in Chapters V, VII, and VIII, respectively) to writers who are mostly larking (Agatha Christie definitely, who in Chapter IV doesn't move the story much but gives the book its funniest character, the infinitely voluble Mrs. Davis, and whose anticipated ending is so off the wall that she's pretty obviously trying to find the most unlikely solution to the problem as it existed up to that point; perhaps also Clemence Dane, in Chapter XI, who seems most interested in the character dynamics). 

The personal preferences of the authors also play an obvious role. This is seen a bit in the character of Inspector Rudge, whose character mostly holds together, but is nonetheless not quite consistent -- the Rudge of Sayers comes across as more literary, and the Rudge of Knox as more methodical, than he does in other chapters, for instance. Likewise, each author has things he or she is not willing to tolerate, or a suspect that he or she thinks should not be a suspect, or a preferred method for handling some problem or others. The most obvious case is seen in the fact that the early chapters strongly suggest that the  murder had something to do with the Admiral's past in China; this builds and builds until it hits Fr. Knox, famous among other things for laying down the rule that the solution of your mystery should never depend on a Chinaman -- 'Chinaman' being a stand-in for any foreigner who has no obvious reason to be in the tale, but here put to the literal test by the burgeoning reliance on a past scandal in Hong Kong. As Knox says in his anticipated solution, perhaps with some asperity, "It appears that Admiral Penistone, Sir W. Denny, Walter Fitzgerald, Ware, and Holland are all intimate with China, which seems overdoing it" (p. 296). So unsurprisingly, Knox begins diverting the story elsewhere. The background is already set, so it still has some influence on the future course of things, but the focus definitely shifts in the latter part of the book.

The structure of the story is also constrained in some ways by the nature of telling a mystery story. It's probable from the beginning that Neddy Ware is of some importance, somehow, because he's the first person mentioned, finds the body, and provides the first crucial information about the tides that gives an inkling of where the Admiral's corpse might have been put into the Vicar's boat. The writers, however, don't have much agreement on how exactly he plays a role. It became very obvious very quickly to the writers, and at some point becomes obvious to the reader, that the only possible way to account for some of the evidence is that some people must at some point be impersonating some other people; but they have different views about who is impersonating whom. It likewise becomes clear that some of the characters, like Ware and the Vicar, know more than they are saying; but the writers have different assessments of things like whether they realize that they know some additional crucial information or whether they are deliberately keeping something back, and if so, whether they are doing so for innocent reasons or guilty reasons, and, if the latter, whether they are the relevant guilty reasons or some other guilty reasons. I found all of this aspect of the novel fascinating. For a while I've wanted to write a mystery story that specifically focused on this multi-branching nature of inference, so it was particularly neat to see some of the twentieth century's greatest mystery writers struggling through exactly this aspect of the story.

The plot is tangled, inevitably, but it's really characterization that struggles in a book like this. I mentioned already the inconsistencies of Inspector Rudge. These are not too serious, in part because Rudge's role gives him more external coherence than any other character in the book. But other characters, shifting in and out of the suspicion spotlight, have ultimate characterizations that can only be considered a bit muddled and outlandish. The Vicar in particular began to exasperate me, because his actions, which often play a role in adding new complications to the mystery, sometimes border on the inexplicable. There's explanation provided, certainly, but at least far as this reader was concerned, the Vicar seemed sometimes to come across as somewhere between being stupid and having a a personality disorder. He is the most egregious case, or so I thought, but a lot of people in this novel act in weird ways, because that's the only way the writers could find to solve the weird problems that the twists of previous writers had created.

Favorite Passage: From Edgar Jepson's Chapter X:

"But the very last place that anyone who'd committed the murder would want to be seen in, is about here," protested Hempstead.

"M'm," said the Inspector. "If you'd seen the silly things murderers do that I've seen. Besides, there are some people who call themselves criminologists, who say that a murdered always goes back to the scene of his crime."

"Does he now?"

"No, he doesn't," said the Inspector. (p. 192)

Recommendation: Recommended, particularly if you like puzzle mysteries.


****

Certain Members of the Detection Club, The Floating Admiral, Charter Books (New York: 1980).

Friday, February 10, 2023

One Categorical Imperative in Three Formulations

 On Twitter, Kevin Vallier recently asked:

This is a good question, and I've known professional philosophers who definitely do not get this correct. Nonetheless, it's not actually a difficult question. There is more than one way you can establish it, but I'll give the way that I think is simplest and most straightforward.

When Kant gives the categorical imperative as such, he gives a version that says (allowing for slightly different wordings):

Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become universal law.

This sentence is intended to capture the idea of morality as having maxims appropriate to universal law. There are three essential ideas here: maxim, universal, and law. And to facilitate understanding and application of the categorical imperative, Kant gives three re-formulations of the categorical imperative that brings one of these ideas front and center. The Law of Nature formulation emphasizes 'universal' by drawing an analogy to the most universal thing that directly impinges on our experience (the laws of nature), and it focuses on the formal structure of moral action; the End in Itself formulation (also known as the Humanity formulation) emphasizes 'maxim', which is the rule we make for ourselves in making a choice, and it focuses on the material content of moral action; and the Kingdom of Ends formulation (sometimes called the Autonomy formulation) emphasizes 'law' as something applicable to rational beings, and it focuses on how the formal structure organizes the material content of our choices, which Kant thinks of as its totality or wholeness.

To derive the End in Itself formulation, therefore, we need to know what a 'maxim' is. On Kant's account of willing, maxims are rules that have a means-end structure. They say what you are treating as valuable (the end) and how you are to treat it as valuable (the means). The categorical imperative tells us that we should only have maxims that are universalizable. But no maxim can be universalizable unless it has an end that is already universal -- that is relevant to every possible choice of every possible rational being. What is such that in every possible choice, no matter what, made by any possible rational being, it will be something that can be treated as valuable? Nothing, Kant thinks, except rationality itself. Kant uses the word 'humanity' as the popularly accessible word indicating rational nature. Thus, the categorical imperative tells us that we need always to treat humanity as an end. This, with a few clarificatory comments whose value is simply that they rule out potential mistakes of interpretation, gives us the End in Itself formulation:

Treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of another, always as an end and never merely as a means.

Similar derivations work for the Law of Nature formulation and the Kingdom of Ends formulation. The reason that all three express the one categorical imperative is that in their essential meaning, they differ only by emphasis. Each takes one of the three ideas and emphasizes it, but the other two have to be included. You can vary up the vocabulary using analogies to other things (laws of nature, laws of societies, prudential rules), but the ideas have to be retained. In all cases you have to be talking about maxims conforming to universal law.

Are there any weak points in Kant's derivation of the formulations? With the End in Itself formulation a possible weak point is the assumption that only rational nature is available as something of worth for every rational choice of every rational being. But I suspect anything that one could add to it, Kant would just take to be included in 'humanity'.