Monday, March 17, 2025

Explorers

 These great philosophers are explorers. Those who are great are those who have discovered continents. Those who are not great are those who have only thought of being solemnly accepted at the Sorbonne.

 There is a certain world, a universe of thought. On the face of this world geographies can be drawn. In the depth of this world geologies can make deeper engravings. The public, so to speak, always believes, and the philosophers almost always believe, that they are quarreling over the the same terrain. Neither sees that they are plunging into different continents. 

[Charles Péguy, Notes on Bergson and Descartes, Ward, tr., Cascade Books (Eugene, OR: 2019) p. 58.]

As from Sheol

If you enter into judgment with your servant, O Lord God, what excuse will I find? And where can I beg for forgiveness? For I have rejected and broken all your laws, and have become a dead man in the greatness of my sins. As from Sheol, from the sea of sin draw me out, in your mercy: O Christ the King, have mercy on me!

[From the Basilica hymn for the Third Week of Lent, in The Book of Before and After: The Liturgy of the Hours of the Church of the East, Fr. Andrew Younan, ed. and tr., The Catholic University of America Press (Washington, DC: 2024), p. 479.]

Sunday, March 16, 2025

To Show a Heart Grief-Rent

 To Keep a True Lent
by Robert Herrick 

 Is this a fast, to keep
The larder lean?
And clean
From fat of veals and sheep? 

 Is it to quit the dish
Of flesh, yet still
To fill
The platter high with fish?

 Is it to fast an hour,
Or ragg’d to go,
Or show
A downcast look and sour? 

 No; ‘tis a fast to dole
Thy sheaf of wheat,
And meat,
Unto the hungry soul. 

 It is to fast from strife,
From old debate
And hate;
To circumcise thy life. 

 To show a heart grief-rent;
To starve thy sin,
Not bin;
And that’s to keep thy Lent.

Saturday, March 15, 2025

Links of Note

 * Troy Jollimore, I Used to Teach Students. Now I Catch ChatGPT Cheats., at "The Walrus"

* Heather Parry, Modern Life Is Ruining Storytelling, at "Persuasion"

* Simon Hewett, Elucidating the Eucharist (PDF). Transignification is inevitably an incomplete account of the Eucharist but, of course, it is one of the things that does occur.

* Bradley J. Birzer, The Breakfast Club at 40, at "Law & Liberty"

* Brandon Robshaw, The Necessity of Nussbaum, at "Aeon"

* Francesca Bellazi, The Metaphysics of Pregnancy (PDF)

* H. M. A. Leow, Debating the Definition of Taoism, at "JSTOR Daily"

* Michael Hannon, The Puzzle of Political Knowledge, at "Political Epistemology".

* Ragnar Van Der Merwe, Whewell's Fundamental Antithesis: A Lineage of Influence (PDF)

* Laurence R. Horn and Heinrich Wansing, Negation, at the SEP
Justin Winzenrieth, The Textual Transmission of the Aristotelian Corpus, at the SEP

* Apple Pie, Politika, at "Things to Read". Factor analysis always has to be taken with a box of salt, but it's generally useful for raising questions about the categories we use, and in politics the categories often carry a lot of baggage that can easily mislead.

* Louis Larue, Against Guala and Hindriks' functionalist theory of institutions (PDF)

* Colin Gorrie, When Poetry Didn't Rhyme, on alliterative poetry, at "Dead Language Society"

* Isaac Kolding, Why Is Uncle Tom's Cabin So Controversial?, at "Amateur Criticism"

* Samuel Meister, Aristotle's Nature-Bound Theology in Metaphysics Λ (PDF)

* Owen Flanagan, The shame felt in addiction isn't toxic -- it's healing, at "Psyche"

Friday, March 14, 2025

Aristotle on Intractable Problems

 In general, it is safe to suppose that, whenever any problem proves intractable, it either needs definition or else bears either several senses, or a metaphorical sense, or it is not far removed from the first principles; or else the reason is that we have yet to discover in the first place just this -- in which of the aforesaid directions the source of our difficulty lies: when we have made this clear, then obviously our business must be either to define or to distinguish, or to supply the intermediate premisses: for it is through these that the final conclusions are shown. 

 Aristotle, Topics VIII.3

Thursday, March 13, 2025

Let Steady Reason Urge the Struggling Oar

 Epitaph, Intended for Himself
by James Beattie

Escap'd the gloom of mortal life, a soul
Here leaves its mouldering tenement of clay,
Safe, where no cares their whelming billows roll,
No doubts bewilder, and no hopes betray. 

Like thee, I once have stemm'd the sea of life;
Like thee, have languish'd after empty joys;
Like thee, have labour'd in the stormy strife;
Been griev'd for trifles, and amus'd with toys. 

Yet, for awhile, 'gainst Passion's threatful blast
Let steady Reason urge the struggling oar;
Shot through the dreary gloom, the morn at last
Gives to thy longing eye the blissful shore. 

Forget my frailties, thou art also frail;
Forgive my lapses, for thyself may'st fall;
Nor read, unmov'd, my artless tender tale,
I was a friend, O man! to thee, to all.

Wednesday, March 12, 2025

For Odour, Light, and Sound are Truthful Dreams

 Springtide
by Constance Naden 

 The silver birch, with pure-green flickering leaves,
 Flooded by morn with golden light, rejoices,
 And mingles with the kindred merriment
 Of perfume-laden winds and happy voices:
 No child of spring is lonely, but receives
 Some subtle charm, by diverse beauty lent,
 And with another life its own inweaves;
 E'en man's creative eyes win all their gain
 From light, whose glory, but for him, were vain.
 While bud the flowers, while May-tide sunshine beams,
 Through all the world of mind and body streams
 One constant rapture of melodious thought,
 One fragrant joy, with summer promise fraught,
 And one eternal love illumes the whole;
 For odour, light, and sound are truthful dreams,
 Inspired by Nature in the human soul.
 This fresh young life, whereof my own is part,
 With boundless hope all earth and heaven fills;
 The birds are waking music in my heart,
 A voiceless chant, more sweet than they can sing;
 My thoughts are sunbeams; all my being thrills
 With that exultant joy whose name is Spring.