Tuesday, March 11, 2025

The Genius of Metaphysick

 A person who called himself the Genius of Metaphysick was continually busied in turning a large engine, like that described in Gulliver's travels, which threw up an endless variety of combinations of words and letters, out of which were framed sentences and paragraphs, sections, chapters, and treatises. He told me, he was much employed, and had the custom of all the literati of the place, particularly of the Governour, who (he said) was his very good friend; adding, that if I had any job on hand in the bookmaking way, he would furnish me with materials in the neatest and newest fashion, and on the most reasonable terms.

James Beattie, "The Castle of Scepticism" [from Ernest Campbell Mossner, "Beattie's 'The Castle of Scepticism': An Unpublished Allegory Against Hume, Voltaire, and Hobbes", Studies in English, Vol. 27, No. 1 (JUNE, 1948), p. 134]. The "Governour" is Hume. This seems particularly appropriate in our age of LLMs that endlessly jabber.

I think it's an interesting thing about many of the most recent AI programs that (1) they are getting to be quite good but (2) it becomes clear when you 'chat' with them a while that they are as good as they are because they are set up so that you are in a weird way talking to yourself. They repeat back to you things that you say in slightly different forms; they do connect what you say to other things, but usually in a fairly typical and tedious way. It's not surprising, I think, that people are very impressed by the intelligence of something that keeps agreeing with them and finding obvious confirmations that they are right. The Great Impostor, Ferdinand Demara, used this method to great success. When asked how he was able to fake being a psychology professor so well for so long, he pointed out that, no matter what you say, nobody ever thinks you are stupid or ignorant if you tell them that you are convinced by them and ask them to explain themselves further. 

But there is room to worry in this, the point that AI seems to work like a successful con artist. I have yet to come across an AI program that does not disappoint in any field with which I am familiar myself; a form of talking to myself it may be, but it's talking to a weirdly more limited version of myself. The answers are never actually more likely to be right than they used to be. What is worrisome, though, is that the errors, which are still quite common, are trickier to catch. They are not any more right, but they sound more plausible. I recently 'chatted' with Grok 3 on the paradox of fiction; it got multiple things wrong, provably so, but always gave long, plausible-sounding arguments for the errors. Someone who had not been reading for quite a while on the paradox of fiction, as I have, would almost certainly not have caught most of the errors. Indeed, I cannot even be certain that I caught them all. Perhaps, for at least a lot of topics, they just have fewer and fewer signs of error when they are wrong.

Beattie's Genius of Metaphysick in the Castle of Scepticism has detached literature from reality; his point, of course, is that you can be as skeptical as you please if your words are just combinations that aren't about anything. It's the 'about something', however, that actually makes what you say matter, and it's the 'about something' that provides the standard of discourse. If you are talking with something that has no connection to the 'about something', you might as well just be discussing matters with an idle reverie in your own imagination. Idle reveries have their place; but you shouldn't trust them until you have completed the turn to reality.

Monday, March 10, 2025

Correcting the Momentary Appearances

 In general, all sentiments of blame or praise are variable, according to our situation of nearness or remoteness, with regard to the person blamed or praised, and according to the present disposition of our mind. But these variations we regard not in our general decision, but still apply the terms expressive of our liking or dislike, in the same manner, as if we remained in one point of view. Experience soon teaches us this method of correcting our sentiments, or at least, of correcting our language, where the sentiments are more stubborn and inalterable. Our servant, if diligent and faithful, may excite stronger sentiments of love and kindness than Marcus Brutus, as represented in history; but we say not upon that account, that the former character is more laudable than the latter. We know, that were we to approach equally near to that renowned patriot, he would command a much higher degree of affection and admiration. Such corrections are common with regard to all the senses; and indeed it were impossible we could ever make use of language, or communicate our sentiments to one another, did we not correct the momentary appearances of things, and overlook our present situation.

Hume, Treatise 3.3.1. The point in the last sentence, I think, is an underappreciated point in philosophy of language; in communicating with others, we communicate not from our immediate point of view but from a projected 'steady and general point of view', what we might think of as an official or public point of view that detaches from the variations, foibles, quirks, gaps, and obscurities of our immediate and unofficial point of view. Communication, literally making common, begins with building, by inference or guess, a candidate for a common point of view.

A True Adoption

Come, let us give thanks and glorify our good God, as much as we are able, for his benefits to our race: honor him for our establishment, from the beginning, in the name of his honorable Image; and, when the enemy envied our honor and cast us out of our glory, the Lord was revealed to us, and spoke to us in his Son, who is the Inheritance and Progenitor of the world to come; in whose birth gathered us from the error of ignorance to the knowledge of his Divinity; who was baptized and gave us a true adoption; who fasted and gave encouragement to our weariness that we might overcome Satan; in whose death conquered the tyrant; and who justified us, lifted us up and raised us with him in glory.

[From the Basilica hymn for the Second Week of Lent, in The Book of Before and After: The Liturgy of the Hours of the Church of the East, Fr. Andrew Younan, ed. and tr., The Catholic University of America Press (Washington, DC: 2024), p. 477.] 

Sunday, March 09, 2025

Fortnightly Book, March 9

 Maurice LeBlanc (1864-1941) was born to a wealthy business family, but he left behind a secure factory career in order to pursue a career in writing. He struggled for a while, but then in 1905 he received a commission to write a story that was intended to be in the gentleman-thief genre that had recently become popular due to the A. J. Raffles stories of E. W. Hornung (the brother-in-law of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle). The short story, "The Arrest of Arsène Lupin", was a smashing success, and LeBlanc began turning out several other stories about the gentleman thief, imagining him to be a French version of the very British Raffles, and to be Sherlock Holmes's equal-and-opposite in the thieving world. The latter would eventually get LeBlanc in some legal trouble from the Doyle estate; unperturbed, LeBlanc just started calling the equal-and-opposite of Lupin in the detective world, 'Herlock Sholmes'. Ironically, LeBlanc would soon have the same problems with Arsène Lupin that Doyle had with Sherlock Holmes. The character was difficult to write convincingly and it was impossible to keep up with the demand for new stories; so, like Doyle, LeBlanc would eventually try to kill off his character and yet, like Doyle, find that when a character reaches a certain level of popularity, the author no longer has complete say on whether they stay killed. Nonetheless, LeBlanc seems to have reconciled to this more easily than Doyle, buying a house and calling it "Clos Lupin". He lived his last years as World War II began to ramp up, leaving Clos Lupin out of worries of German invasion, and died of pneumonia in 1941.

I've previously done all the Sherlock Holmes stories for the Fortnightly Book, and I have wanted to do all the Lupin stories as well. I read the first one, I think, a very long time ago, and a few years ago, I listened to several of them on audiobook, and ever since they have been on the list, and I have had the box set of the first ten sitting on my to-do pile, and I have just not gotten around to them. So let's start remedying that; the next Fortnightly Book is Arsène Lupin, Gentleman Burglar, the collection of nine short stories that started the character's career.

A Poem Draft and a Poem Re-Draft

 Carcosa

Carcosa, city sorrow-tossed,
the glory once and always lost,
in dreadful gray and dying dusk
sends up half-towers like a husk,

and here, where elsewhere gardens grow,
the trees are rotting with a glow
like ghostly phantoms dripping fear;
the grave alone can blossom here.

And all the graves there ever be
Carcosa holds like waves on sea,
including yours, which sadly states
your name and those two burning dates,

and no one walks here save the mad,
in rhythms echoing and sad,
and those who come here fade like frost,
all but these tombstones ever-lost,

for in Carcosa, far away,
and yet too near, the sunsets stay,
and time without a future sighs,
reflecting on the past that dies.


Extreme Unction 

Reminiscent,
as with some ancient memory,
but of what is above as well as what is behind,
a recollection of serenity,
too often lost,
yet always there,
descends with soothing scent,
a holy and confirming scent;
the flesh pants like a hart,
yearning for living water,
yearning to love,
with kiss on crucifix.
The heart is sick in God's presence,
sickness a distance from God,
a distance as upon a cross,
an aching distance,
a burning gap,
a purifying as if by fire.
Upon the head which knows,
upon the hands which do,
upon the body and its means,
the Spirit is given,
the oil is given,
and like the penitent thief,
stealing into paradise,
the soul shares the Passion
(its mortality the Passion),
and the spirit overflows,
redounding in splendid glory,
that the body be made
sign of its own resurrection,
the beginning of resurrection.

Saturday, March 08, 2025

Faroe-Islander Saga

 Introduction

Opening Passage:

There was a man named Grimur Kamban who was the first to settle in the Faroe Islands. In those days, a great number of men were seeking refuge from the tyranny of King Haraldur Fine-Hair; some men settled themselves in the Faroe Islands and farmed there, while other men sought land on other islands.

When Aud the Deep-Minded was traveling to Iceland, she came first to the Faroe Islands. There she married off Alofa, daughter of Thorstein the Red, from whom descends the entire family line of Faroe-Islanders called the Götuskeggjar who live on Austurey. (p. 31)

Summary: The Faereyinga saga hints at its theme in the very beginning of the work: this is the saga of the independence of the Faroe Islands, settled by men seeking to escape tyranny, who will maintain a sort of independence despite being in some ways the least significant and least powerful of the Scandinavian lands. It primarily takes place over the course of the conversion of the Faroe Islands to Christianity; as with Njal's Saga, the islands are pagan at the beginning and Christian by the end. But the role of the conversion is somewhat different; in Njal's Saga, Christianity provides the means for the resolution of the problem of Iceland spiralling out of control, whereas the primary issue in Faroe-Islander Saga is how the Faroe Islands will genuinely convert to Christianity on its own terms rather than being forced into a pseudo-conversion by the rising power of Christian Norway.

But that is the saga considered at a very abstract level. The saga is actually the story of a wily and ruthless pagan family, the family of Thrandur, one of the Götuskeggjar from the island of Eysteroy, or Austurey, as it is known today. Despite being a younger brother, Thrandur, who we are told is exceptionally lucky, manages to inherit the family farm, which he rents out as he sails away to make a fortune -- which he makes in spades, as an unlikely series of events results in his coming into a massive amount of money. Meanwhile, an accidental death leads to a feud between two other families, those of Hafgrimur of Sudoroy and the brothers Brestir and Breinir Sigmundursson of Skuvoy.  Hafgrimur gets the help of Thrandur in a course of events that leads to the death of the two brothers; Thrandur wants to kill their sons, but is prevented by his allies, so instead sells them into slavery. They end up in Norway, where, after they are freed, they are raised by an extraordinarily talented outlaw family who takes them in during a snowstorm and then teaches them to fight and track; Brestir's son, Sigmundur, marries the daughter of the family, Thurid. Sigmundur and his cousin Thorir make their way to the court of Earl Hakon, where they do very well; as a result Sigmundur receives a ring from Earl Hakon that belonged to the goddess Thorgerd and renders its bearer lucky. The boys return to the Faroe Islands, where Sigmundur has to retake his family farm by force, and the two press Thrandur for legal compensation for the death of their father. They eventually agree to travel to the court of Earl Hakon in Trondheim to have him mediate; when only Sigmundur arrives at Trondheim, Earl Hakon decides very generously for Sigmundur and Thorir, and the two then have quite the task of trying to force Thrandur to comply, because Thrandur is not the kind of person to give anything freely.

The invasion of the Jomsvikings furthers the fortunes of Sigmundur and Thorir as they join Earl Hakon to fight them off, and this leads to Sigmundur being in good favor as King Olaf Tryggvason takes the throne and Christianizes Norway. Sigmundur becomes Christian and is tasked by King Olaf with Christianizing the Faroe Islands. Thrandur becomes his major opponent in this, but his luck outmatches Thrandur's for the moment, and he effectively forces Thrandur to convert, although it is clear that the conversion is less than even skin-deep. It also massively aggravates the feud between the two families. Thrandur's foster sons (Sigurthur, Thorthur, Gautur, and Leifur) attempt to assassinate the two cousins twice, but fail both times; the escalation brings things to a head, and finally Thrandur leads a violent raid against Sigmundur's farm, thinking to catch both Sigmundur and Thorir there, but he misses them, and they are repelled by Sigmundur's household led by the very impressive Thorid. Tracked by Thrandur, Sigmundur and Thorir and a servant named Einar manage to get away, although Einar dies in the process, and reach another island. But Sigmundur's luck runs out when they are discovered by a man named Thorgrimur, who murders them both and buries the body so that no one will know that he did it.

Leifur, one of Thrandur's foster sons (and the biological son of the man whom Sigmundur had killed in order to take back his family farm), wants to marry Thora, the daughter of Sigmundur and Thorid, and Thora demands that if Leifur is even to have a chance, he must discover who killed her father and bring them to justice. Thrandur tracks it down to Thorgrimur, and by pagan death-magic is able to find the evidence that convicts Thorgrimur, who is executed for it. (Killing a man is not so great a misdeed in medieval Scandinavian society, and would under most circumstances just legally require a fine, but killing a man and then covering up the killing is a capital crime.) Leifur marries Thora, although there's some indication that Thorid, now known as Thorid Strong-Widow, only allows this because she thinks it may eventually provide a way to get back at Thrandur.

A new King of Norway, Olafur Haraldursson (more commonly known today as St. Olaf), attempts to put the Faroe Islands under the Norwegian tax regimen, but the family of Thrandur repeatedly manages to foil this. In the course of doing this, Sigurthur, Thorthur, and Gautur end up murdering the tax envoy, which estranges them from Leifur, who had befriended him. They are exiled. With there being no one cunning enough or lucky enough to oppose him, however, Thrandur is able to engineer their return, and, even more than that, is able to arrange for Leifur's and Thora's son, Sigmundur Leifursson, to be fostered by him -- despite the fact that everyone in the family knows that the young Sigmundur is effectively a hostage. Sigurthur and Gautur manage to do well for themselves and in particular marry well, but in extraordinarily suspicious ways that lead to a sharp deterioration in their reputation. Thorthur, meanwhile, decides he wants to marry Thorid Strong-Widow, which gives Thorid the beginning of the thread she needs to unravel the family of Thrandur. The sons of Thrandur are caught in a carefully laid trap and killed, although at considerable cost, and Thrandur dies of grief. The family of Leifur and Thora become the dominant family in the Faroe Islands, which become Christian because the family of Thrandur had been the last obstacle to its doing so. Nonetheless, it's because of Thrandur's resistance that the Faroe Islands becomes Christian on Faroe-Islander terms rather than by being forced into it by the much more powerful Kingdom of Norway.

Of all the sagas I have read, this was in some ways the most difficult to read because it is subtle on a level that is far beyond even the ordinary subtle irony of most sagas. From the beginning, it is clear that there is something 'off' about Thrandur. The author never tells us anything about what it is. In fact, he has a habit of going very vague at crucial points in the story. We are told that Thrandur is very lucky, but he often seems too lucky. Some of this is no doubt ties to his entanglements with pagan magic -- for instance, every time anyone tries to work directly against him, they are opposed by bad weather -- but it's more than that. If it were only one or two instances in which Thrandur somehow came out on top agains the odds, okay, that's luck. But it happens again and again, and there is too much pattern to it. Thrandur seems to be cheating at every turn. We are never told that. Everything is told at a surface level in such a way that every individual case could be interpreted as just Thrandur lucking out. But over the course of the saga, we get repetitions, each slightly different, which start to raise questions about the cases we have already read about. And the author's not telling us about how things happened, his going vague at key moments, starts to look very deliberate.

For instance, at one point an associate of Thrandur, Eldjarn, is accidentally killed; this leads to the feud between Thrandur and the sons of Brestir and Beinir. Later, however, he shows up again helping Thrandur. Perhaps the author just forgot that Eldjarn had already died, or made a mistake in confusing him with someone else? Perhaps. But then there is also the episode in which the sons of Thrandur are killed, and then their ghosts start haunting the coast, stealing things and killing people, and then they show up alive again at the most auspicious time. Are both 'deaths' in fact just deceptions perpetrated by Thrandur and his family? The text doesn't tell us -- in fact, it goes very vague at every point where it could tell us something that would tell us yay or nay. If it just happened once -- fine. If something so strange happens twice -- odd. If something so strange happens twice and the narrator keeps denying us the relevant information about what is happening -- there is something going on. There are several other examples of this, like the fact that Sigurthur and Gautur both end up marrying wealthy widows, with whom there had already been rumors that they had been having affairs, shortly after their husbands die and they avenge -- or perhaps "avenge" -- their husbands deaths. We are never told that Sigurthur and Gautur killed the husbands. In fact, we are explicitly given the death scene that leads to Gautur's good fortune, and it very definitely does not say that Gautur killed the husband. In fact, the whole scene can be read as implying someone else's doing it. But when you stop and consider the scene carefully, it doesn't actually say that, either, and everything it says is, strictly speaking, consistent with the possibility that Gautur killed the husband and then blamed someone else, killing them before they could defend themselves. When it also happens to Sigurthur, with only slight variations in the details, it becomes practically certain that the latter interpretation is right. We don't know the details -- we are denied the details -- but Thrandur's family is a frighteningly cunning lot.

That perhaps make the eventual success of Sigmundur's and Thorid's family, and the triumph of Christianity, all the more remarkable.

Favorite Passage:

Next Thrandur instructed a blazing fire be made in the fire-house, and he had four metal grates placed in a square, and Thrandur himself scored nine furrows in the earthen floor, making nine concentric circles around the square, and he sat down on a stool between the fire and the grated pen. He asked his men not to speak to him, and they stood silently by.

For a long while Thrandur sat there.

After some time had passed, a man entered the fire-house. He was all wet. Everyone recognized the man as Einar South-Islander. Einar went up to the fire and warmed his hands; he stood there a long while; then he turned and let. More time went by, and another man came into the fire-house. He went to the fire, warmed his hands, and then departed. Soon after Thorir had left, a third man came into the fire-house, a great man covered in blood, who carried his head in his hands. They all recognized him as Sigmundur Brestirsson. Sigmundure halted at a certain spot on the floor for a time, then he made his departure. (pp. 96-97)

Recommendation: Highly Recommended


***

Faroe-Islander Saga, Robert K. Painter, tr., McFarland & Company, Inc. (Jefferson, NC: 2016).

Friday, March 07, 2025

Dashed Off V

 Accidents are likenesses of substances with respect to being.

Whatever we know of a thing, we know through knowing its substance.

"Any proposition whatever concerning the order of Nature must touch more or less upon religion." C. S. Peirce

"It is impossible to define velocity without some reference to the past and to the future." Whitehead

When young, we tend to act in light of what we think might work; when old, in light of what we know will not.

Political sovereignty has the same root as human rights.

the infant as a natural icon of the promise of humanity

Freedom of speech plays an important role in making it possible to assess and diagnose the moral rot of society.

Ritual is important for medicine in providing a clear framework, putting patients at ease, simplifying the work of doctors in dealing with patients, providing people with insulation from difficult events, etc.

The formal cause of justification is divine justice as given, and it is given morally (renewal of mind), jurally (imputation of justice before the divine tribunal), and sacrally (integration into heavenly liturgy).

It is remarkable how easily socialized healthcare slides into euthanizing infants and the elderly.

"God, grant human beings the power to see in small things the common principle of things both small and great." Augustine

We only have knowledge of the future in the sense that we have knowledge of dispositions.

Interpretation of Scripture is done before God the Teacher and Judge.

The 'state of nature' was a philosophical fiction constructed to evade and overwrite the actual state from which modern states arose: that which is broadly called 'feudal'.

We find no object adequate to the depths of the potential andpromise of human loyalty and fidelity except in God.

We generally think of successions as having a first; to get an infinite succession, we start with the first and move forward. Given this, we can turn it around and think of infinite succession backward; given this, we can splice the first of the backward succession to the first of the forward succession and get infinity both ways with respect to our reference point, the dual-sided first. Then we recognize that any point could be treated as first in this way, and abstract from the first by, so to speak, spreading it everywhere.

"For by Moses the one God attuned the Holy Scriptures to the minds of many people, who would see different things in those words, all of them true." Augustine
"For God in his Christ has made in us too a heaven and earth, the spiritual and the carnal members of his Church."

The young have difficulty disentangling ethics from their insecurities, and the old have difficulty disentangling their ethics from their comforts.

Animals, plants, and landmarks get something like rights from having roles in human traditions and communities.

A continual problem in talk of representation in political philosophy is equivocation between the sense in which representative represent everyone (i.e., exercise powers on their behalf) and the sense in which they definitely don't (i.e., picking which values and principles on which to act).

"A gift is the thing given by the person who bestows what we need, such as money, food, drink, clothing, shelter, assistance, whereas the fruit is the good and upright will of the giver." Augustine

To understand the demonstrative proof, you must understand the dialectical matrix.

Augustine's Confessions move from restlessness to rest.

In creating, God makes the capacity to imitate God.

"What is the principle of movement in the soul? Clearly just as in the whole it is God, so too in this. For the divine in us somehow moves all things." Aristotle (EE 1248a)

"Christ, according to his humanity, is the altar on high of God's majesty, on which we are offered when we are incorporated into him in glory." Albert

Too much discussion of evangelism focuses on the persona of the Christian and not on the person of Christ.

agent intellect : terminative object :: possible intellect : specificative object

Both bread and wine presuppose water.

In the sacraments, words represent the Spirit.

The Holy Spirit has, indeed is, absolutely infallible Magisterium; Scripture and the Church participate in this under certain conditions as the Spirit's instruments; Ecumenical Councils and the Pope under certain conditions participate in this instrumentality as representatives of the Church.

rememorative allegory as a principle of the liturgy

the scent of distance (related to concentrations detectable to the sense of smell)
--> arguably this requires a kinaesthetic element; it is change in intensity of scent that provides distance information

Nietzsche makes amor fati to be learning how to see the necessary as beautiful.

the internal morality of trade

"Usura solum in mutuo cadit." Bernardino

It is important to grasp that much of the traditional opposition to usury was driven by bankers and merchants. (It was seen as unfair trade practice, and also as endangering the reputation of the entire profession.)

the notes of development as modes of tradition

For Sikhs, the Sri Guru Granth Sahib is in a sense doubly Guru; it embodies the spirit of the Guru verbally (Guru Arjan Dev) but also receives commission as the Guru of the Panth (Guru Gobind Singh). In this twofold aspect it carries forward the double action of a guru: to teach the truth and to form a community for the truth.

Delicacy without good sense is a dangerous combination in both aesthetics and ethics.

"A poem is a stone thrown into the pool of the mind." David West

Caesarius of Arles on the ecclesiological interpretation of Pr 31 -- Sermon 139

Suffering does not bring wisdom; reflection, even on one's suffering, sometimes does.

(1) Recognizing the normative value of our own natural good, we must recognize the normative value of natural good in other cases.
(2) The child in the womb has a natural good.

A society that respects human dignity must prepare for those who will be born into it, as well as for those who will leave it by dying.

Faith is not a preoccupation; it is title to what is not immediate, like testimony, like inheritance, like promise, a having broadly what is not had strictly, and what is more, a shared having, a one faith and not many faiths, and what is more, it is received (as indeed testimony, inheritance, and promise are).

The Bible has its authority not as read by people but as addressing them, especially in a literal manner as read aloud in synagogue or church.

the cadence of being

intelligibility as being illuminated by the intellect

The invariances of the universe are together that whereby the universe imitates the immutable divine.

A book is a social entity, and Scripture is not an exception.

"When we ask how good a man is, we do not ask what he believes or hopes, but what he loves." Augustine
"Friendship begins with one's spouse and children, and from there moves on to strangers."

We do not force concepts onto objects; they are objects because we conceive them.

"God is the cause that acts and is not acted upon." Augustine Civ. Dei 5.9

Genuine conversation presupposes the free contribution of all parties involved. If we converse, we are free.

When people try to strip metaphysics out of something, they generally make it less human.

"...love is proportionate to apprehension." Maimonides Guide 3.51
"When you walk in the way of the moral virtues, you do justice to your rational soul, giving her the due that is her right." Guide 3.53

Our first conception of the cosmos is as a confused unity.

By prayer, even considered only as a human activity, we given things a relational status.

NB that Maimonides holds that prayer is a duty in the Law, whereas Nahmanides holds that it is not but rather a natural & spontaneous response to God's lovingkindness.
-- Maimonides' foundation for his position: Ex 23:25, Dt 13:5, Dt 11:13, Dt 6:13, Nm 10:9

"Know that all the practices of wroship, such as the reading of Torah, prayer, and the performance of the other commandments, have only teh end of training you to occupy yourself with His commandments, may He be exalted, rather than with matters pertaining to this world; you should act as if you were occupied with Him, may He be exalted, and not with that which is other than He." Maimonides Guide 3.51
"We, the community of those who adhere to Law, say that He knows with one single knowledge teh many and numerous things. For as far as He, may He be exalted, is concerned, insigths do not differ because of the difference of the things known, as is the case with respect to us." Guide 3.20

R. Joshua b. Levi: Hallelujah is the most perfect kind of praise, because it includes both praise and the Name (BT Perakhim 117A).

Paraphrases of literal expressions are often only indirect or approximate, so we should expect the same of paraphrases of figurative expressions.

broadcastmindedness (Knox): "the habit of taking over, from self-constituted mentors, a ready-made, standardized philosophy of life, instead of constructing, with however imperfect materials, a philosophy of life for oneself"

Professional ethics is inherently casuistical.

History absolves no one.

Every 'bounded ideality' has within it an abstract form or general structure, a historical representation, a functional timeline, geography, demographic, etiology, etc., that conforms to its general principles.

Interpreting the Good Samaritan as a figure of Christ, "Go and do likewise" is a command to be Christlike. Cf. Knox: "The mercy of God shown to us in the Incarnation is to be the model for all our acts of human mercy."

The Church is as if God, finding the treasure of Christ buried in the field of humanity, bought the whole field for the sake of the treasure.

The work of the vineyard is not to make the plants grow but to provide what they need.

Civil rights are always deteriorating and so always needing to be renewed.

The rosary is a conceptual prayer-garden.

"If you start by treating the uniformity of nature as a hypothesis and no more, you will find your hypothesis is upset by every recorded case of witches flying, tables turning, Saints being levitated, oracles coming true, horoscopes being verified, broken limbs being cured by faith-healing, and the like." Knox
"Everybody knows that all hypotheses are in the last resort partial and insecure as a representation of truth; at the best, they cannot be postiively proved, they can only escape refutation."
"The witness of power needs to be supplemented: that does not mean that it can be dispensed with."

It is easy to prepare oneself intellectually for matters of faith; the difficulty is preparing oneself morally.

All sacraments, major and minor, are transsignified and transfinalized.

Someone's being blameworthy implies that it is permissible to blame them.

Moving from confused and obscure cognition to distinct and clear cognition is generally a slow process requiring custom-tailored adjustment.

Our knowledge of our concepts is reflective, not direct, and is expanded by causal reasoning from communicating, whether by word or deed, as well as classificatory extrapolation from perception and practice. In a prephilosophical posture, things are known conceptually but the concepts are 'in use' rather than 'under study'. Puzzles about things lead to reflection on the concepts that we use; this is often done briefly, loosely, and in a limited way. The Socratic innovation is to take this reflection to a full study.

In practical classification, classes often do not correspond to unified concepts.

Our first articulated believing presupposes the guidance of authority.

"No explanation of the universe can be regarded as adequate which does not take account of all the phenomena of the universe, and among these human intelligence is surely not the least important." E. W. Trueman Dicken
"Morality is no less of an art than is the making of violins."

The point of the Sermon on the Mount is not the replacement of the Law but the transfiguration of the Law.

categories -> transcendentals -> immaterial being

Gratitude to God expands the circle of human beings to whom and for whom we must be thankful.

the motivational state of rule-regulation (Darwall) -- the commitment to abiding by rules of conventions of justice

self-love, private benevolence, public benevolence
(these can be regarded as three categories of wanting to do good, classified according to whose good)

Classification by smell is arguably the classification that best fits nominalist and empiricist accounts of classification.