Monday, November 16, 2026

Unheaven'd the City Lies

 November Blue
by Alice Meynell

The golden tint of the electric lights seems to give a complementary colour to the air in the early evening.—Essay on London 

O heavenly colour, London town
Has blurred it from her skies;
And, hooded in an earthly brown,
Unheaven’d the city lies.
No longer, standard-like, this hue
Above the broad road flies;
Nor does the narrow street the blue
Wear, slender pennon-wise.

But when the gold and silver lamps
Colour the London dew,
And, misted by the winter damps,
The shops shine bright anew---
Blue comes to earth, it walks the street,
It dyes the wide air through;
A mimic sky about their feet,
The throng go crowned with blue.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Fire Serpent and Water Mountain V

Previous


Chapter Five: The Gods Play the Game of Two Heavens

Tera was nervous about attending her first olam game, and fretted in particular about what to wear. She had appalling visions of showing up in entirely unsuitable clothes and be mocked behind her back about it. She recognized these visions as absurd, but this did not make it any better; the reason the visions were absurd was that she could not accurately imagine what it would be to wear unsuitable clothes, but the reason she could not imagine it is that she had no idea what would even count as suitable or unsuitable. What even happened at an olam game?

Uncle Llew was of no real help. The first time she asked what she should wear, he looked at her in complete bafflement and said, "Clothes, preferably."

She gave him an annoyed look that apparently amused him. "Should it be formal or informal? How many layers? What do people expect?"

"I have not been to an olam in about a thousand years," said Uncle Llew. "Who knows what stupid fashions are popular in The City these days?" Then, seeing that she was becoming even more irritated, he hurriedly said, as if to placate her, "But the rules of olam restrict uses of the Davnan power around the olam court. No one can use the Vaults, so possibility shifts can only be minor; it's considered extremely bad form to make shifts that are not directly concerned with the game. If it's hot, you can't make it cooler; if it's cold, you can't make it warmer; if it's stuffy, you can't make it breezier. Even on a small scale. You will want to wear something that is comfortable, on its own, and won't make you too hot or too cold."

"That's better," said Tera. "I can do something with that, I suppose."

"It does not matter whether you do," said Llew. "The first rule of divine fashion is the same first rule that governs all Davnan affairs: No law binds the gods. The rules are conveniences, and there is nothing Davnan admire more than clever cheating. The closest thing we have to absolute rules are the rules of olam, simply because you will be packed into a small space with a lot of gods who will get angry if you obviously break them. What you wear is entirely your own concern. Go dressed as a zebra."

"I am absolutely not going dressed as a zebra."

"Why not? You can."

"I would look ridiculous."

"To whom? You are the Goddess-Princess of Davir. What higher authority on fashion could there be?"

"The other gods, of course," Tera said, getting irritated again.

She regetted saying it, because she could almost have predicted what happened next. Uncle Llew said, "Pah," with an expression of disgust, and dismissed all the gods of all the world with a contemptuous wave of a hand. "It is stupid for a god to seek the approval of other gods," he said. "They are not so worthy. They are not so wise. They are fools all, and not even worth the trouble of enlightening. If they stupidly don't like something you do, leave them in their stupidity with the disdain they deserve."

"That's easy for you to say; you don't care what anyone thinks, and you don't have to, because you grew up with it all."

Llew's face grew very sober and grave at this. He looked at her a moment and said, in a quieter, more subdued voice than he usually used, "It is not at all easy for me to say. But it is true. The other Davnan have no power over you unless you give it to them. Do not give it to them, even in a matter like this."

This was no more useful than anything else he said on the subject, and yet somehow it was helpful. She still had no idea what to wear, but she felt less nervous about it.

In any case, the problem more or less solved itself. The Embiadwei servants mostly scurried out of her way like mice, but the waiting-ladies had to talk to her. She told one of them, whose name was Anangkaki, or something like that, that she was going to an olam game, and Anangkaki nodded and said, "Yes, Your Glory," and began setting out an outfit for her approval, a very summery, gauzy kind of dress with a sweeping hat, long silk gloves, and light, simple shoes. It came with a small painted handfan. She changed the color scheme, which was bright reds and yellows, to one that she liked better (pale yellows and greens), but otherwise made no changes. It was quite a relief, although Tera was self-aware enough to recognize that one cause of her relief was that now she could blame someone else if things were not right.

Relief at that problem being solved did not relieve all anxieties. She was supposed to meet Rhiannon at Bryn Abernant, and that seemed to mean that she needed to take the Platform, which she had never done. Uncle Llew was slightly more helpful here, because it gave him a chance to make it a lesson. He loved making things lessons.

"The principle is basic," he said. "Anything can be anywhere; 'where' is a possibility, not a thing. The possibility of being here, related to these things around here, is much, much more available to us than the possibility of being somewhere else.  But we can shift what possibilities are available, which means that, starting anywhere, we can in principle be anywhere. Using the Platform is not fundamentally different from just walking over. When you walk, you shift the possibilities that are available to you. When you use the Platform, you shift the possibilities that are available to you. That is the principle, and it really is that simple. In practice, however, there are complications. Being far away is distant, not just physically, but as a possibility; it is not easily available, and it takes great effort to shift to it. The farther it is, the more possibilities there are to be tracked, and this difficulty multiplies very quickly. For those Enrolled in the Manifest, these are easily solved. You use the Vault for the power and Oracle for keeping track of the possibilities."

"But I am not Enrolled yet," said Tera.

"Yes," said Llew. "But even for the Enrolled, there is a very difficult obstacle, one without any straightforward solution. Your body does not like having its possibilities drastically shifted. It actively resists it. All bodies, especially living bodies, do, in a sense, but the Davnan body has the advantage of being Davnan. It has the same power to shift available possibilities that you do, and if you try to shift things too much, it instinctually tries to shift them back, with the same power that you are trying to use in the first place. There is no easy way to solve this problem, so we work around it. Instead of trying to shift yourself, you shift by Platform; it uses its own small Vault, and its own link to Oracle, and you shift in a closed room that makes it less obvious to your body that anything has changed. You enter in one place, the light will blink to let you know that it is about to work, then it will blink again to let you know that it is done, and you exit in another place."

This description turned out to be exactly right. She walked into the Platform, and it was just a room, with a circle on the floor and an ornate lamp on the wall. She stepped into the circle, the lamp blinked at her in a bluish white color. She felt a sudden chill, then the lamp blinked again, this time in yellowish green. She hesitated a moment, then walked to the door, opened it, and she was somewhere else, a much more flowery somewhere else. Lavender and oleander and red clover were everywhere. A Vilim servant was waiting outside the door.

"Her Splendor is awaiting in the rose garden," said the servant, with a curtsy. "If Your Glory will kindly follow me, your humble servant will take you to her."

They went down a windy path. Compared to the steep inclines and precipices of Brickanbreck, Bryn Abernant was relatively level and easy to walk. They went through an open gate in a large garden wall, as the rose garden was apparently an enclosed garden. Rhiannon was there, in an outfit that Tera was glad to see was very much like her own, if a bit less gauzy and sweepy, inspecting a pink rose very carefully.

"Ah," said Rhiannon, "you are here, and you look lovely today."

Gratified, since she did not receive such compliments often, Tera briefly told of her ordeal with Uncle Llew over the clothes, although she abbreviated and softened all of his contempt for the gods to: "You should not worry so much about what the gods think."

Rhiannon laughed. "I would not say it quite that way. But of course Llew is right. You are Goddess of Davir, a Kingdom Goddess, and the youngest of the gods on top of that. You would be indulged in almost anything. Of course, the problem is always that the gods have long memories. Your uncle, perhaps, is bold enough not to care about that, but the rest of us are usually a little more cautious."

She stroked another rose and looked at it keenly. Then she said, "I am running a bit behind here, as this particular row has been causing me trouble. The flowers are more pale than I want, and the petals are too often blemished. I intend to rework the soil and the bushes, but in the meantime, I am pulling the flowers back to where they should be. If you could help me, that would make it much faster."

"Of course," said Tera, "but I am not very good with flowers, and, being un-Enrolled, I am limited in what I can do."

"That is perfectly fine, dear," said Rhiannon. "Most gods have difficulty with living things, but anything you could do would make my task easier and faster. Just try to freshen them up and make them as close to this pink, and as vivid, as you can. I am almost done; start on the last bush while I finish this one up, and we will be done in no time."

They worked a few minutes in silence, then Rhiannon finished her rosebush. She turned to the first rose on Tera's, and stopped, still as stone.

"Did I do it incorrectly?" asked Tera nervously.

Rhiannon turned and looked at her with an expression that Tera could not quite read. It seemed thoughtful and calculating and almost baffled. She said, "You are indeed a gifted member of a gifted family." She turned her gaze back to the rose. "You said you were no good with flowers, but I have never seen anyone not Enrolled do this so well. I know many on the Manifest who would still struggle to have this precision and consistency. It is good work." She quickly inspected the other flowers on the bush, slightly lightening the pink of one or two and freshening up one or two petals that Tera had missed or not quite done rightly. When she was done she looked back at Tera, again with that same strange thoughtful-calculating-baffled look. Then she smiled brightly.

"Well," she said, "I apologize for making you do some work on such an excellent day. Let us go and meet up with Manawydan."

They walked back up to the Bryn Avernant Platform, which worked exactly the way the Brickanbreck Platform did, although the colors of the blinking lights were pale blue and bright yellow, and when they stepped out, they were somewhere different again. In the distance, Tera could see the field, the Clearing, where she and Uncle Llew had first arrived. They headed down a path toward the olam court. There were many gods milling around and talking to each other, many of whom greeted, and were cheerfully greeted by, Rhiannon. Every so often, Rhiannon would stop and introduce Tera, and everyone would smile and beam and say how wonderful it was to meet her, and then they would move on. There was nothing obviously untoward about any of it, but it made her uncomfortable; she almost had the impression that she were being shown off by Rhiannon, like a sort of trophy or prize, and sometimes, although only sometimes, that the smiles were stretched a little tightly. But was this just the cynicism of Uncle Llew rubbing off on her? All this did not take very long, though; they soon met up with Manawydan, who was also dressed in a summery fashion, with a belted tunic of short sleeves and knee-breeches.

Olam, the game of Two Heavens, is played on a long, narrow court of compacted earth, called the Court of Two Heavens, between outwardly two irregularly sloping stone walls. At the midcourt, well above the playing area, were two large stone rings, known as Firmaments. Each team is generally allowed only on one half of the court; to pass the Firmaments is to lose the game. Within this court, the players use a solid rubber ball, the size of which depends on both the kind of play and the phase of the game; it is known as the Sun. Players may not touch the Sun except with their hips, which they use to pass it back and forth. Both teams begin with seven points. The Sun may not bounce more than once before it is returned to the other team's half of the court; if it does, the team on whose side it has double-bounced loses a point. During the shorter phases of the game, each team must attempt to pass the Sun through a Firmament, with no penalty for failure; during the longer phases, if the Sun touches the Firmament but does not go through it, the team that failed loses a point. A point is also lost to the team that knocks the Sun out of the Two Heavens. A short phase is won by passing the Sun through one of the Firmaments; a long phase is won by either this or hitting the far wall, known as the Outer Bound. A team that loses all seven of its points loses the game immediately, which is called the weak victory for the other time, while a team that knocks the Sun through the Firmament three times wins immediately in what is called the strong victory. The long victory occurs when neither of these happen, and is given to the team that wins the most phases out of the seven that a long game can have.

All of this, of course, is only the outward aspect of the game. But olam is a game played by gods; it has an inner nature. The true game is played with the shifting of possibilities. In other games, spectators watch and perhaps cheer and jeer. But in the game played among the gods, those who watch also are players.

Manawydan explained all this to Tera as they found a place to stand on the wall on the Wenovar side of the court. It was quite crowded and a little breezy because everyone had a fan. The explanation stopped, however, when the teams came out. There is not much to an olam uniform, as it consists entirely of a loincloth and leather hip-guards. Tera hoped that she was not blushing. Rhys on the Wenovar side spotted them and waved cheerfully; they waved back.

Through all of this the Davnan all around had been chatting among each other. Suddenly, however, there was a hush. Amaethon, flanked by two members of the Crew of The City, spoke, his quiet voice reaching easily to all parts of the court in the way only a Davnan voice can. He reminded all that there was to be no use of the Vaults, no use of Oracle, on pain of forfeiture. He noted that any Vilim found within sight of the Two Heavens during the play of the gods was to be executed. Then with great ceremony, a casket was brought to him, from which he took a large gold coin, to be used to determine which team first received the Sun. He tossed it high, very high, and with that, the game began.

A coin being tossed is a swift flashing of possibilities in and out of availability. But the olam court is filled with gods who can shift which possibilities are available, simply by willing it. As the coin spun in the air, every Davnan there pushed. Tera, of course, had never felt anything like it. The cooperative push of many Davnan wills is a formidable thing, and it swept her and everyone else along. Back and forth, back and forth, back and forth went the possibilities. The coin slowed its descent and then hovered, spinning erratically, faster and faster. The Muriaki pushed. The Wenovar pushed, and Tera with them. Back and forth, back and forth, back and forth. Then suddenly the coin dived to the ground and the Wenovar had won the toss. A cry of joy went up among the Wenovar; a groan went up among the Muriaki. The Sun was given to the Wenovar team, a bell was struck, and the play on the Two Heavens began.

A Wenovar hip-hit the Sun across the Two Heavens, and a Muriaki player narrowly missed having it smash into his face. In The City, all olam games are formal, and no Vilim are allowed to participate in them, or even see them. But out in the Kingdoms, the Kingdom gods often have their Vilim play informal games for their entertainment. Such games can be immensely dangerous. No player leaves without severe bruising, since a solid robber ball is not soft. Players can die from the Sun to the face or to the kidneys. The gods are much more durable, although they too cannot always avoid injury. The Sun does not move as a ball would normally move. The available possibilities of its flight are being shifted here and there by the masses of the Davnan supporting each side, and the key to victory is to find the straight line to one's target through the ever-shifting paths. At the same time, the Sun can swerve in unexpected ways, and only the swift avoid injury.

For the first long phase, the Sun passed back and forth for a while, then suddenly the Wenovar gathered, passed the Sun from one player to another in extremely quick succession (Tera thought that it looked extremely painful, and the expressions of the players involved did not suggest otherwise), then suddenly shot the Sun down to the Muriaki Outer Bound. First long phase to the Wenovar.

Having won the long phase, the Wenovar received the Sun first again for the short phase. Each member of the Wenovar team attempted from a spot in the middle of their side of the Two Heavens to hit the ball through one of the Firmaments. All the Wenovar watching strove to keep the Sun on course, all the Muriaki watching pushed to knock it off course, and the Sun moved across the Two Heavens like a drunken bird. None of the Wenovar succeeded, but the Muriaki then had their turn, and they failed as well. Draw on the first short phase. When Rhys's turn had come during the Wenovar attempt, he did no better than anyone else, but Rhiannon and Manawydan and all the Wenovar cheered him on, and Tera did as well.

The Wenovar having failed on the short phase, the Sun went to the Muriaki, who tried and failed to hit the Outer Bound in a single shot; the Wenovar returned it, and the Muriaki attempted to get the Sun through the Firmament. It was a very narrow thing, but they missed, losing a point; but it was obvious even to Tera that the Muriaki had had a back-up plan for failure. When it bounced off the Firmament, it bounced directly to the ground on the Wenovar side, and the Wenovar had to scramble to prevent it from bouncing on their side again. It was also a close thing, but Rhys, moving quickly and smoothly, slid under the Sun so that it bounced off his hip, giving the Wenovar time to return it. The whole Wenovar side roared with delight, and even some of the Muriaki supporters shouted appreciatively. When Rhys rose, Tera could see a scrape down the entire side of his leg, which looked like it might hurt terribly. If it did, however, he showed no sign, and in fact, Rhys soon won the second long phase for the Wenovar by hitting the Muriaki Outer Bound.

The second short phase was a draw as well, although Rhys's attempt almost made it through the Firmament. All the Wenovar groaned.

In the third long phase, the Muriaki badly miscalculated and (whether through a bad hit or through the Muriaki overcompensating in their pushing or through the Wenovar supporters cleverly taking advantage of an opportunity, it was impossible to say) they lost two points when the Sun hit the Firmament, at which they had possibly not even been aiming, and did so with such force that it then bounced out of the Two Heavens and had to be retrieved. The phase went even worse for them when Rhys hit the Sun through the Firmament, winning the third long phase for the Wenovar. It had almost certainly been just sheer luck, but it made Rhys the instant darling of the game for the Wenovar, who began chanting his name.

The third short phase was a draw again, with all shots going wild. It was clear that both sides were fired up at this point, and the supporters on each side were visibly straining. Perhaps, however, the Muriaki were exhausting more quickly, because in the fourth long phase, one of the Wenovar players -- Tera thought she heard his name as Zenan -- quickly hit the Muriaki Outer Bound.  Fourth long phase to the Wenovar, and having won four of seven phases, long victory went to the Wenovar.

Manawydan, Rhiannon, and Tera made their way out of the court and waited for Rhys outside. Passing Wenovar, and even a few Muriaki, kept congratulating them, as they happily beamed. Shortly afterward, Rhys himself came up, still dressed in only a loincloth and hip-guards. He looked exhausted and happy, and exhausted and happy in an olam uniform was an extraordinarily good look on him. Tera hoped again that she was not blushing; in often-snowy Davir, and in Mizur as far as she knew it, men never wore so little in public. It was disconcerting here, and ironically the fact that he did it so casually and un-self-consciously made it even more so.

Rhys and Manawydan excitedly talked about some of the events of the game, in a conversation that Tera, having no experience with the game beyond what she had just seen, could not entirely follow. Suddenly, however, Rhys said, "Are they having the fruit ices today? I would love one." 

"I think so," said Rhiannon. "Go and get us all one. You'll need more than two hands so," she said looking at Tera, "perhaps Tera could go along and help you. In the meantime, we will find a good place to sit."

Rhys looked at his mother with a look that Tera could not decipher, never having seen it before, but which most other people would have recognized as halfway between sarcasm and resigned exasperation, a look that young men tend to reserve mostly for their mothers. He did not protest, though, and Tera of course had no reason to object, so off they went to find the fruit ices. It was a bit of a hike up and over a hill.

"Which flavor do you like, pomelo or citron?" asked Rhys, as they came to a booth. It was manned by a Wenovar -- one of the ones to which Tera had earlier been introduced, but whose name she unfortunately could not remember -- who greeted him enthusiastically and congratulated him on his game, and some docile Vilim

"I have no idea," said Tera. "I have never had any."

"Oh!" said Rhys, looking at her with surprise. "Then we need to catch you up and get you both." 

So they went off again with five fruit ices, Tera holding her two bowls and a handful of silver spoons, and Rhys skilfully balancing three bowls in what Tera thought was an admirable use of the Davnan power.

"The clan usually has someone volunteer to make these for the olam," said Rhys cheerfully, "and frankly they are my primary reason for playing. I suppose we could have them any time, but they always taste better after a game."

 She paid attention to what he was doing so she could copy and practice it later. They found Rhiannon and Manawydan at some benches near some pine trees. The bowls and spoons were distributed. Tera felt a bit awkward having two bowls when everyone else had one, but feeling awkward should never get in the way of dessert, and she ate them both. She enjoyed them both, as well, although she liked the pomelo better. They were, in any case, by far the best thing she had eaten during her entire stay in The City; the fruit ices were certainly made by a god, because only a Davnan could have made them so perfectly.

While they were eating, Amaethon came up to them. "Tera!" he said in a big, boomy, cheerful voice. "It was so good to see you here today! How did you enjoy olam?" When Tera said, she enjoyed it, he responded in the same boomy voice, "Glad to hear it. But you should come sometime to see an Embiadwei game. We actually know how to play." He went off.

"Typical empty boast of an Embiadwei," said Rhys after Amaethon was out of earshot. Then he apologized awkwardly to Tera for saying it without thinking.

"I am not bothered by it," said Tera. "For all I know you may be right."

"Nonetheless," said Manawydan, "the Embiadwei do take the game very seriously." That was said to no one in particular, but then he said to Tera, "I once saw a game in which your uncle played. It was Embiadwei against Tchanni -- I went with Caan One-Savy, I think --" (this was said to Rhiannon) "and it was the best olam I have ever seen." He turned to Rhys, saying, "The shortest, as well. Strong victory in the first three phases."

"Impossible," said Rhys. "How would you even do that?"

"Yet true, and what is more remarkable" (here he was back to Tera) "is that Llew made all three shots. He was an astoundingly good olam player. Something new everytime."

Tera could not in any way imagine Uncle Llew playing a ball game, much less in an olam uniform, but she nodded politely. She perhaps need not have bothered, because Manawydan was back to talking to Rhys.

"The winning pass was the most remarkable play I have ever seen. He seemed to be aiming for one Firmament, and all the possibilities were shifting that way, and then suddenly, he twisted around in the strangest way and hit it through the other Firmament. Everyone was caught off guard and before anyone could adjust, he just guided it right through. None of us were even focused on the right possibilities. For years people kept trying to replicate it, and no one ever could."

"A very good player," he said again to Tera. "But he only rarely played, and not long afterward he just stopped playing altogether. A pity. He was truly a gifted member of a gifted family."

The conversation turned to other things, some of which Tera could follow and some of which she barely understood. But even when she was not fully following, there was something nice about listening to this conversation under a shady tree, having just eaten some splendid fruit ices, with a beautiful landscape all around.

When she returned home, she was in a very good mood, and when Uncle Llew asked her how it went, could honestly say it went well, and enjoyed relating it all. 

Uncle Llew listened with a pleased smile, occasionally interspersing a comment. When she talked about Rhiannon and the roses, he said drily, "Well, that was clumsier than I would have expected of her; she was testing your abilities. How well did you do?"

"She said I was a gifted member of a gifted family."

"That is always true. But it is also the greatest compliment a Davnan give another Davnan, so it seems you passed the test."

He listened without saying much all through the description of the game, but he laughed at her enthusiastic description of the fruit ices.

"I have never liked fruit ices," he said, "but apparently they are going to become more common at the Hall of the Fire Serpent."

"I heard as well," she said in playful accusation, "that you were an excellent olam player in your day. You were keeping that from me."

"I suppose some might say so," said Uncle Llew indifferently. "But what does it really mean to be excellent at such a thing?"

"Manawydan said you stopped playing. Did you just get tired of it?"

Llew's face took on a grave and somber cast that Tera could not quite read. "I came to recognize that it was all just a child's picture of something we were long before we came here, the last thread of a past we had left behind. And I became much more interested in discovering what the reality might have been."

"What did you find?"

"Very little," said Uncle Llew. "If you have not yet learned it, outside of bits and pieces of family history, we Davnan mostly see the past as nothing but a thing to leave behind." He seemed in a dark mood for a moment. But then he shook it off, and said with a genuine smile, "I am glad you enjoyed your day. That alone is enough to justify coming here."

They talked a bit more, and then Uncle Llew went off to his workshop. Tera played around a bit with one of the looms she had come across on the first day, getting a feel for how it worked, but mostly her mind was not on the weaving but on the day. It had been a remarkable feeling, being in the Court of Two Heavens with so many other gods, cooperating with them, competing with them, all together participating in the game. It had felt right, and for the first time Tera's trepidation about the gods and The City were replaced entirely by excitement to see more of what life as a goddess might be.

to be continued


Two Poem Drafts

 Atlantis or Avalon

Some poems seem fairy and elfin
and suggestive of brilliance of dawn
that broke on eye and intellect
in Atlantis or Avalon.

The word is a union of glories,
the thought that encircles the sky,
a transient puff that will vanish,
an obect that never can die;

the verse is a turning of pathways
like a serpent both forward and back
that flies through the air on its dove-wings
with a speed only hunters can track

who, wearing their tunics of lincoln,
with their bows shooting arrows of light,
have long know those regions most parlous
and learned from the eagles their sight.

Here, drink from the fountain of image
but 'ware, lest its ghostly delights
become not the grace of the Spirit
but madness that roams in the night..

Like mirrors that tell all your futures
and shadow out never-were pasts,
you draw out whole worlds in your goblet
as fishers draw hopes with their casts

as they stand at the edge of the cosmos,
their lines in the depthless abyss
where swim all our virtues and vices
that bring us damnation or bliss.

Some poems are more mythic than legend,
the tradition of satyr and faun,
the last rites and wisdom remaining
from Atlantis or Avalon.


Shade and Flame

The shades of time are shifting;
like quaking sand they turn and change;
they blur and blend in patterns
like visions surreal and phantoms strange.
The dreams through veils are sighing,
each one a spirit like to bright flame,
the brighter analogue of shadow,
elusive in their order and their name.
The flicker, the fading, the flow,
are all apprehension's seeking can find,
with nothing of substance to know,
though they are known in the waver of mind.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Links of Note

 * Edward Feser, The Metaphysical Foundations of Conservatism (PDF)

* Derk Pereboom, Kant's Transcendental Arguments, at the SEP

* Mind of the Church is a website providing translations of various works of theology.

* Porphyrian Trees of virtues in St. Thomas's Summa (the navigation seems a bit wonky at times, but you can search for a virtue and then 'Find in Tree') -- Tim Pawl discusses the project here.

* Michael, Ascent to the Meaning of Being, on St. Edith Stein's argument for God's existence, at "The Summa Wayfarer"

* Ray Imgrund, Dante, Lewis, and a Fairy Tale about Overcoming Despair, on Over the Garden Wall, at "Harmony of the Heavens"

* Ham Calculus has an interesting set of tutorials on Lambda Calculus and Term Functor Logic.

* Divyavacana, Divine Simplicity in the Dvaita Vedanta Tradition

* Peirce Concordance at the Lyceum Institute

* Gyongyi Hegedus, Saadya, at the SEP

* Tyler Jagt, My Students Can't Read, at "The Review"

* Researchers have recently been using AI to decipher Kurt Godel's notebooks (which were mostly written in a now-very-rare form of shorthand notation).

* Brad Skow, Fan Service, Easter Eggs, at "Mostly Aesthetics" -- I think one very simple but important difference is that fan service is deliberately made to be obvious, whereas easter eggs are, as their name suggests, deliberately made to be partly hidden, so that they can be discovered.

* Francis Young reviews Sarah Clegg's Perilous Enchantment

* Nancy French, I Was Taught to Read Using an Alphabet that No Longer Exists, on the here-then-gone i/t/a attempt to reform reading education, at "Pardon My French"

* Cordithicus, Manuscript Art of St. Thomas Aquinas in the 15th Century


I had hoped to have the fortnightly book done, but, embarrassingly, I completely misplaced the book for nearly a week, and have been mostly catching up on other things since, so it will have to be next week.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Dashed Off XXXV

This finishes the notebook that was completed in September 2025.


 What is the relation between causation and memory?
--- Irrelevant (Noncausal Theories)
--- Relevant: Is appropriate causation necessary and sufficient?
--- --- No: Is it neither necessary nor sufficient?
--- --- --- --- No: Hybrid Causal Theories
--- --- --- --- Yes: Post-causal Theories
--- --- Yes: Does it involve some form of transmission?
--- --- --- --- No: Distributed/Procedural Causal Theories
--- --- --- --- Yes: Does it involve some form of preservation?
--- --- --- --- --- --- No: Constructive Causal Theories
--- --- --- --- --- --- Yes: (Neo-)Classical Causal Theories
[Roughed out from Michaelian & Robins, "Beyond Causal Theory?"]

There is no violation of rights that one can make that cannot be done by a state through its officials or representatives.

human beings collectively as utility monsters relative to other species

rhetorical inventio: thinking through the true and true-like that render a case or its explanation probable

(1) We know how to make moral statements.
(2) This competence requires that some of these be true.
(3) Therefore some moral statements are true.
-- (2) would be based on the idea that skill at using kinds of statements excludes systematic misuse.

Persons are causes of both order and exception to order.

Most things can be done by genius, by art, by method, or by diligence.

method as external art, as skill-like diligence

A middle term may be descriptive, comparative, relational, circumstantial, or authoritative.

stages in deterioration of factional politics
(1) argumentative collaboration
(2) passive-aggressive negotiation
(3) aggressive negotiation
(4) passive-aggressive reaction
(5) preemptive prevention
(6) aggressive reaction
(7) aggression on grounds of what is anticipated
(8) hostility

justified true at-least-belief
justified true no-less-than-belief
justified true beliefishness

order : system :: form : substance

observational vs narratival counterexamples to arguments

sign proper (manifests object) vs sign inverse (manifests interpretant)

fictionalisms that appeal to fiction vs those that use 'fiction' as an analogy vs those that are structurally like other fictionalisms but have no clear relation to fiction

Unlimited semiosis implies a capacity, not a process or network.

Pascal's Wager is not based on expected value but on a theory of reasons.

We find external bodies not only resistance to our wills but obscure to our intellects.

interpolative vs extrapolative inferences in reading fiction

grounds of reasonable incredulous stare
(1) apparent direct contradiction
(2) apparent self-defeat
(3) apparent contradiction of experience
(4) apparent violation of consensus sapientorum
(5) apparent violation of consensus gentium
(6) apparent impracticability
(7) apparent lack of evidence

interpolation into a model of an extrapolative object

In every discipline, there are rules of thumb and simple methods done at first for practical convenience that then slowly settle into confirmation as more than merely practical.

We use the term 'make believe' of a wide variety of activities that have a wide range of quasi-doxastic effects and formats.

Need does not entitle, although it may give priority or further specification to already existing title.

Paradigm case arguments got correct the idea that an account of meaning must accommodate ostension when relevant, and actual ostension rules out empty classification. Paradigm case arguments, however, cannot establish the quality of the classification itself. They prove that a position is not purely verbal, in the sense of using words that correspond to nothing, but not that it is articulated into words on the most appropriate way.
PCA's work most effectively against *unqualified* skepticisms, specifically about *existence*, where this is taken to imply that discourse is *either meaningless or purely verbal*; it also can serve as a *ground of challenge* (the skeptic must clarify the classification/analysis/definition relevant to his conclusion).

What counts as a mistake depends on the ends.

It's odd that philosophers discussing the 'method of cases' talk about 'intuitions' and 'elicited judgmetns' rather than the cases themselves. They talk about whether *responses to cases* are evidence, whetehr this is due to the constitution or the causation of the *responses*, and not about the cases.

appearance + reliability principle -> truth of, inferred from, or evidenced by appearance
appearance + causal principle -> existence of causes of a sort to cause appearance
appearance + method of questioning -> questions suggested by appearance

Taht something is a 'category mistake' is established by reductio ad absurdum. (Ryle)

Some of what is imaginary is not dependent on us and some of what is real, is.

Intellectual inquiry is not a Markov process.

"Every philosopher of the present day has his 'aggressive' as well as his 'affirmative' position. You understand his 'aggressive' position so far as you understand what those tenets are which he desires to overthrow; and you understand his 'affirmative' position so far as you understand what those tenets are which he desires to establish in their place." W. G. Ward

free will in a state of probation vs free will in a state of consummation

God is always in our future and unavoidable.

the experience of anti-impulsive effort
the experience of anti-inertial effort
the experience of meaning in action not derivable from circumstance or antecedent because different in kind
the experience of selection of alternatives

Value is what the intellect understands through the will; inquiry is what the will intends through the intellect.

categorizing kinds of fiction by modal axioms

the sensible as a kind of representamenality

We storytell ourselves to ourselves and otehrs, characterize ourselves and organize our memories by plot and scene and episode, extract themes from our lives, and take for the diction, spectacle, and melody of those lives.

The structuring of language is an exegesis of phenomena.

Meaning is intelligible structuring or ordering to an end

Realism in excessive doses is highly toxic to fine arts.

"If we are open to recognize a person in one member of a species, we are open to recognize a person in all members of it." Oliver O'Donovan

Persons are both providential and provident.

conscience as the High Court, consciousness as the adminsitrative court

People are not hypocrites about things that can't be done; hypocrisy is only about the attainable.

Millians confuse a use of proper naming with proper names themselves; in fact, you can treat even common nouns in a Millian way without their ceasing to be common nouns with an articulable sense.

Gn 2:24 as a prophecy of the Church (Grosseteste argues on this ground that the union of Christ and the Church would have happened even without sin)

Proper names should not be conflated with singular reference.

being is not a genus -> no division can dequately divide being into well defined classes or concepts

one : reference :: true : sense :: good : function

Fiction is possible because of the mind, but is not itself a psychological matter.

Words are always mediate rather than immediate signs; they are signs of signs, not incidentally, but by nature.

definition per additamentum

Every concept virtually contains other concepts.

Not all doubts are the same kind of doubt, and skeptics generally do not recognize these differences.

Augustine De Trin 8 on Alexandria

nominatio per se vs. nominatio per alio

We know ourselves with the help of other people.

It is often a great advantage to let nature do your detailed thinking for you; this is an advantage of the experimental sciences.

We inject realities into our imaginations and coat our realities with imaginations.

binary incipit and desinit
incipit (x,y): x incipiates y; x makes y begin to b

Much of the work of the Church is done by kind and pious friends.

Relaxation and inactivity are not the same.

We tend to reject the idea of death as an end because we see ourselves as having an affinity with eternal things.

In assessing evidence, we need to consider not just probabilities of and given particular evidences, but the quality of the overall state of evidence. We assess this by cultivating expert familiarity.

figments of the saints as icons (we find something like this in Bridget of Sweden, Margery Kempe, and other mystics with very visual, or sometimes auditory, experiences)

iconology as providing the framework for all private revelation

mystical experience -> internal realization as icon -> communication in writing -> internal realization for reader as icon -> testimonially mediated sharing in iconic experience

Dreams and ambitions without clear-eyed prudence are merely lovely temptations.

"For that is to be called love which is true; otherwise it is desire." Augustine

In human society, necessity often works like a declarative speech act.

From our social ontology interacting with the world, we causally extrapolate a physical ontology.

Human beings unite around particular people and around abstractions.

exists as, true in, good for

"Given any sufficiently determinate standards, it will be an objective issue, a matter of truth and falsehood, how well any particular speicmen measures up to these standards." Mackie

(1) It is objectively true that rational beings in societies have standards.
(2) Therefore it is objectively true or false whether human actions measure up to them.

"I concede that if the requisite theological doctrine [i.e., divine purpose for human life] is true, a kind of objective prescriptivity could be thus introduced." Mackie

In solving a problem we have to have some sense of what is solving it *enough*.

Bail is a social threshold -- those who can make bail have social connections at least sufficient to make it.

Truth is warrant for daring.

Our happiness consists not only of good results, even if we assume consequentialism, but also reasonableness and proportion and nonregrettableness of means.

Relative to a fictional world, everything in the real world is *hypothetical* and confirmed or disconfirmed (1) by what is true in the fictional world and (2) by authorial intention.

"The response to fiction is a complete product of make-believe and judgments about the work that do not occur within the scope of the make-believe at all." Gregory Currie

They style of fiction affects the style of the fictional world.

Make-believe is not an attitude but an activity.

Most M are P --> All non-R M are P
Most S are M --> All non-R S are M + All M where S are non-R M
 --> All nonR S are P 
Therefore Some S are P
(one would always need a way not to equivocate on residue R)

Thursday, November 12, 2026

History and Free-Will

Again, it is not in the history of man, as in natural history, where the structure of the various plants and animals forms by close analogy one connected system of species and genera; and where the growth, bloom, decay and extinction of individuals follow in an uniform order, like day and night, or like the change of the seasons. But in the sphere of human freedom; as man is a natural creature, but a natural creature endowed with free-will, that is to say, with the faculty of moral determination between the good or heavenly impulse, and the wicked or hostile principle; all these organic laws of nature form only the physical basis of his progress and history. And hardly do they form this—but rather a mere disposition of which the direction depends on man, or on the use he makes of his own freedom. It is only when that higher principle of man’s free-will has been weakened, debased, obscured, extinguished, and utterly confounded, that those laws of nature can hold good in history. Then indeed the symptoms of a diseased age, the organic vices of a nation, the prognostics of a general crisis of the world may be determined to a certain extent with the precision of medical science.

[Friedrich Schlegel, The Philosophy of History, James Burton Robertson, tr., Volume II, Lecture XV.]

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Bo Motori Clamitabo

Motor Bus
by A.D. Godley
 

What is this that roareth thus?
Can it be a Motor Bus?
Yes, the smell and hideous hum
Indicat Motorem Bum!
Implet in the Corn and High
Terror me Motoris Bi:
Bo Motori clamitabo
Ne Motore caedar a Bo---
Dative be or Ablative
So thou only let us live:
Whither shall thy victims flee?
Spare us, spare us, Motor Be!
Thus I sang; and still anigh
Came in hordes Motores Bi,
Et complebat omne forum
Copia Motorum Borum.
How shall wretches live like us
Cincti Bis Motoribus?
Domine, defende nos
Contra hos Motores Bos!

 

This was once an extraoardinarily popular poem. The joke, of course, lies in declining motor and bus as if they were true Latin nouns. 'Bus' is in reality a shortened form of omnibus, which is the dative form of omnis. (It is also the ablative form, hence the line in the poem 'Dative Be or Ablative'.) The original expression was a French use of omnibus as an adjective -- voiture omnibus meant a vehicle for everyone, and this got shortened to 'bus' in English.* Thus we get all the declensions of the fictional Latin word 'bus'. On the singular side: Bus, of course, is the nominative; Be is the vocative; Bi is the genitive; Bo is both the dative and the ablative (they each get one of the Bo's in the poem); and Bum is the accusative. On the plural side: Bi is the nominative; Borum is the genitive; Bis is the ablative; Bos is the accusative. Motor is also declined appropriately, as an adjectival noun.

Bo Motori clamitabo / Ne Motore caedar a Bo is absolute brilliance: it means 'I will cry out against the Motor Bus, lest I be struck down by a Motor Bus'. 


* This has nothing to do with the poem, but this is vividly reminding me of the time in sixth grade (I think) when I lost points on an English assignment about etymology for (correctly) saying that 'cab' was the shortened form of cabriolet. 'Cabriolet' is related to a word for 'goat', and it was a popular way of describing how the cabriolet carriage moved, i.e., in a skipping, bouncy kind of way. Cabriolets eventually got replaced by heavier, more durable hackney carriages; nobody knows why they were called 'hackneys', but popularly all vehicles for hire had come to be called 'cabs', so the hackneys often were still called 'cabs' too. At the end of the nineteenth century, cab owners began installing mechanical and electrical taximeters to better keep track of fares, hence the name 'taxi cab'. (The word 'taxi' is indeed related to the word 'tax'; a taximeter is a measuring device for what you are being charged or 'taxed'. We have since shortened 'taximeter' to 'meter'.) The assignment, of course, had been written in the expectation that someone would say that 'cab' is the shortened form of 'taxi cab'. But this is not right. 'Taxi' is a shortened form of 'taxi cab'; but 'taxi cab' is an expanded form of 'cab', which predates it by over a hundred years. I suppose the assignment accidentally did its job, though; I remember nothing else whatsoever about it, and, indeed, very little from the class, but I will never, ever, ever forget the etymology of 'cab'.