Saturday, November 21, 2026

John Dickson Carr, The Hollow Man

 Introduction

Opening Passage:

To the murder of Professor Grimaud, and later the equally incredible crime in Cagliostro Street, many fantastic terms could be applied -- with reason. Those of Dr Fell's friends who like impossible situations will not find in his casebook any puzzle more baffling or more terrifying. Thus: two murders were committed, in such fashion that the murderer must not o nly have been invisible, but lighter than air. According to the evidence, this person killed his first victim and literally disappeared. Again, according to the evidence, he killed his second victim in the middle of an empty street, with watchers at either end; yet not a soul saw him, and no footprint appeared in the snow. (p. 1)

Summary: Dr Gideon Fell is called in to help his friend (sometimes very longsuffering friend) Superintendent Hadley on a puzzler of a case. Professor Charles Grimaud, noted expert on the history of magic, is shot. Neither the murderer nor the murder weapon are found in the room where he is discovered. What is more, the killer is completely unknown; he entered the building under an assumed name that certainly wasn't his, wearing a Guy Fawkes mask. He also vanished without a trace. He could not have exited the window; the snow is still fresh and unmarked outside it. He could not have exited the door; there are also no footprints in the snow outside. He also could not be one of the people already in the building. He also could not have committed suicide. Before he died, he babbled something about his brother doing it. (Nobody had known that Grimaud had had a brother.) He continues to babble, in fragments: Not suicide. He couldn't use rope. Roof. Snow. Too much light. Got gun. Fox. Don't blame poor----.

It gets worse. A gathering by Professor Grimaud had been crashed by a stage magician named Pierre Fley, a slightly crazed man ranting about his brother seeking to kill Grimaud. In response, Grimaud sends him packing, but also goes out and buys a painting of three coffins which, he tells someone, will protect him. On the very same night he is shot, Pierre Fley is also shot in a street nearby, just a few minutes walk away, apparently in the middle of the street (people heard the shot). There were witnesses at each end of the street who saw nobody but Fley, and the only footprints in the street are Fley's. According to the witnesses, someone shouted, "The second bullet is for you!" The gun which shot both Grimaud and Fley is found in the snow not far from Fley.

A little additional sleuthing by Grimauld turns up that Grimauld is not Grimauld, but a Hungarian man who fled from a labor camp with his two brothers by faking their own deaths and being buried alive, hoping to claw their way out of their graves and to freedom. Pierre Fley is plausibly one of the other two brothers, who was caught again and returned to prison to serve out his sentence; the third is said to be dead, but at this point, who knows?

Saying much beyond this would perhaps give too much away; precisely the cleverness of the book is its tangling of the lines, and a summary would likely untangle them too much. But we have here a set of layered apparent impossibilities. All of the evidence, including the testimonial evidence, is good; nobody is outright lying. But evidence does not carry its own authenticated interpretation with it, and the same evidence can often be interpreted in more than one way. More than that, there's a very crucial and dangerous assumption we tend to make when faced with a clever and baffling crime: that the crime that we have is the crime as it was actually intended. In every crime there are intentional and accidental elements, and sometimes things are not distributed into those categories in the way you might think.

One of the things that actually surprised me about the book was how funny it often is. Dr Fell is brilliant but hard to endure, especially for a very practical and levelheaded investigator like Superintendent Hadley, and Carr does very well with capturing the reactions people may have to an apparently impossible crime.

Favorite Passage:

'I think,' stated Dr Fell, with energy, 'that O'Rourke is the most stimulating, enlightening, and suggestive witness we have heard so far in this nightmare. He has saved my intellectual self-respect. He is, in fact, almost as enlightening as the church bells.'

Hadley, who was peering through the crack between the curtains, turned his head round. The line of light across his eyes showed a certain wildness.

'Church bells? What church bells?'

'Any church bells,' said Dr Fell's voice out of the gloom. 'I tell you that to me in my heathen blindness the thought of those bells has brought light and balm. It may save me from making an awful mistake...Yes, I'm quite sane.' The ferrule of a stick rapped the floor and his voice became tense. 'Light, Hadley! Light at last, and glorious messages in the belfrey.'

'Are you sure it's not something else in the belfry? Yes? Then for God's sake will you stop this mystification and tell me what you mean? I suppose the church bells tell you how the vanishing trick was worked?'

'Oh no,' said Dr Fell. 'Unfortunately not. They only tell me the name of the murderer.' (p. 128)

Recommendation: Highly Recommended.

****

John Dickson Carr, The Hollow Man, Orion (London: 2013).

Poetry and Speculation

 The poetic heritage of the Western theological canon (from, say, the Bible to John of the Cross) should be studied simply out of respect for the mature desires of human rationality, if for no other reason. It also serves, however, as a basis for dialogue with the poetic tradictions of the RigVeda, the Buddhist canon of sermons, the Confucian philosophy of the political significance of ritual, and the Daoist philosophy of nature. That is to say, it serves as a necessary partner to the high speculation of the Judeo-Christian tradition (in scholastic theology, for instance), which as built so extensively upon the foundation of Scriptural names of God. But it can also serve as a medium for interaction with the highly speculative reflection of other traditions, through the medium of their own symbolic and representative forms of thought, as well as in keeping with the consideration of their ontological and ethical concepts.

[Thomas Joseph White, OP, Principles of Catholic Theology, Book 3, On God, Trinity, Creation, and Christ, The Catholic University of America Press (Washington, DC: 2024) p. 63.]

Friday, November 20, 2026

Dashed Off XXXVI

This begins the notebook started in September 2025. This notebook will end up involving a lot of discussion of Kant and Kant-adjacent ideas, first sporadically then eventually much more intensively and extensively.


The body is an instrument for our own good and the good of others; it is ourselves being instrumental for the good of self and of others.

The health of a state is related to its value for the civil friendships in the society that forms the state.

We do not generally need methods to be flawless, but only their proper use to be better than not using them.

Circular argument is only a problem in situations in which there are alternatives or in situations in which there is independent need for actual proof; it is in other cases a sign of a candidate for self-evidence or of a trivial and harmless assumption.

Induction with memory/archive works differently from induction grounded solely on some local material warrant.

Because of the difficulty of political reasoning, democratic politics, which imposes a pressure to have a recognizable opinion, tends toward hyperbolic rhetoric.

sensical-babble poems

The greatest loves are normally expressed in small ways.

change-ringing as symbolic preaching

energy as mass or momentum treated as capacities to affect

Naturalism (or any other position at the same level) does not predict anything until you add evidence.

The claim that something is childish presupposes a teleology of adulthood.

"True philosophy is precise but not specialized." Godel

stability as a sign of sincerity

Sincerity is not some secret hidden state but something expressed.

We do not merely reason to conclude or to support or to defend a conclusion; we also reason to express and to symbolize our commitment to a conclusion we have already accepted.

Those who refuse to do theology by reasoning will try to do it instead by rhetoric.

"Every apology for poetry is an attempt to discern its place on the map of human activity; every defence attributes to poetic imagining a certain character and, in virtue of this character, a certain place on the map." Michael Oakeshott

To be a scholar is higher and better than to be an intellectual.

The most hateful people will always overlap the people who speak most piously, not because the latter causes the former, but because their former will always try to justify their hatefulness by speaking piously; this is true regardless of what an age accounts pious.

"If in any case, by merely pondering my conception of some *ens*, I know that a certain attribute, not included in that conception, is truly predicable of that *ens*, then such predication expresses a self-evidently necessary ampliative truth." W. G. Ward

'No ought from is' implies moral nonnaturalism. (Naturalism implies that oughts are reducible to something else. There is no way to prevent is's from resulting in oughts if the is's are the completely adequate constituents of the oughts. To say that you can't get ought from is requires that it not be so reducible, and this is the nonnaturalist position.)

That one concept is not another is always a synthetic judgment.

attitudes on behalf of others

All moral agents, as they make moral judgments and apply them, find phenomena that serve as indirect nonmoral confirmations of these moral judgments -- virtue tends to make people more psychologically healthy, doing one's duty usually supports smooth-running society, morality often get useful secondary and incidental results, and so forth. These confirmations are not themselves strictly logical, as they could not be deduced from the moral judgments and as they are plurative ('for the most part' or 'often') rather than universal, and as they do not strictly require that the moral judgments be true. They are nonetheless grounds for taking the moral judgments to be practically reasonable, and they psychologically consolidate our motivations and habits in favor of the moral judgments, 
If, however, we postulate a moral providence, these confirmations, without changing their logical structure have indirect theoretical, and not merely practical and psychological, force. Without something like this, they cannot be reliable or even occasionally reliable guides, only aids that sometimes happen to be useful, unless we try to reduce morality to them. But there are many different kinds of indirect moral confirmation, and in a reduction we only salvage one kind. Any convergence requires some broader cause, which requires either something like a moral providence or an attempt to reduce them all to one.

"Have I the power of *recognizing* -- of confessing to myself -- that such or such premises, known by me, reasonably claim my absolute assent to such or such conclusion; while, nevertheless, through indolence or the like, I fail to *elicit* such absolute assent? We are disposed to the think the supposition a possible one; though, of course, in the vast majority of instances, pride would withhold me from such recognition." W. G. Ward
"The sincere inquirer must be allowed his full time for patient consideration and healthy resolve."
"Nothing can be clearer than that God desires mankind to cultivate experimental science. He has imprinted on nature fixed laws, which make it amenable to such science; and He endowed man with an intellect capable of investigating those laws. Then, such investigation is morally advantageous to many; is a good intellectual discipline to all; and has issued, moreover, in the discovery of innumerable truths, which have promoted physical enjoyment and social comfort in a degree almost incredible."

Phenomenal uniformity does not establish nomological uniformity, and uniformity, whether phenomenal or nomological, does not exclude the intelligent but capricious.

Everything worthwhile makes for worthwhile hobbies, if they are consistent with and appropriate to it.

Our pleasures are often our burdens.

A painting always has 3 objects:
(1) the model object (what is painted)
(2) the purported object (what it is a painting of)
(3) the alluded object (what the painting is about)
For instance: a painter may paint a painting in which a prostitute models a Maenad representing drunkenness. However, even though all paintings have all three objects, (a) any two or all three may overlap (e.g., in a self-portrait a painter may paint themselves as a model for themselves to represent themselves) and (b) any of the objects may be imaginary. The interaction among these three is often the source of the 'genre' (e.g., 'portrait') and the thematic depth of a painting.

David's anointing at Bethlehem (1 Sam 16:13) : Baptism :: at Hebron (2 Sam 2:4) : Confirmation :: at Hebron again (2 Sam 5:3) : Ordination

If time travel would be ill-advised because we could have no idea what consequences changing the past could have, it is only because it is ill-advised to make decisions based wholly on the overall consequences of our action, for analogous reason. In the time travel case, we even have an advantage -- definite knowledge of one possible path of consequence, that we don't have in making decisions about the future.

All miracles involve means in contexts.

It's important, in responding to or fixing injustices, not to disrupt processes that are working justly.

"And so human rationality says to each person, 'You are this or that animal,' since animals have in them qualities similar to the nature of the human." Hildegard von Bingen

Shared traditions are the great buffer against political violence.

From (p->q) and Fictional(p) we cannot conclude Fiction(q), although we can do so with Fictional(p->q).

-- it seems to make sense for a logic of fictional operators to be a justification logic; think about this.

We praise or blame other animals insofar as they indirectly participate in human actions in a way appropriate to human standards (e.g., pets).

If we have pure intuitions of space and time, we have pure intuition of being.

the phenomenal as the finite pole and the noumenal as the infinite pole of everything

"To know ourselves as knowers, we need to know we are alive. But living things are defined by where they are. They are entities striving to orient themselves in an environment." Marjorie Grene

All of our responsibilities have an incompleteness to them, the completeness being found only in responsibility to God.

assenting to p vs. going along with p

cut-flower ideologies

drone pictures as performed mosaics

Christ's Resurrection is in a sense a pause in His Ascension; it is His Ascension except He delays its completion for the comfort of His disciples and the confirmation of the Church.

As clever people regularly have evidence of their cleverness, they are always liable to think themselves more clever than they are.

Cleverness always works best when you are not trying to be clever.

the contuition of reality with sign

The probable has an essentially facultative truth; the mind assents to it as true, for the sake of truth, in a way that does not rule out the alternatives and admits further inquiry into whether it is true. It is truth that is necessary as a stepping stone in discovery of truth.

Forms of probable truth
(1) that to which an incomplete proof tends
(2) that which is in the neighborhood of the most properly true
(3) that which has the appearance of truth and no sign of falsehood, based on a means of discovery that can attain to truth
(4) that which is an incompletely proven truth whose application uncertain in relevance (we know the truth is some way, but not where its borders are)
-- the most common version of this is 'for the most part' truth?
(5) that which is necessary and proven but not known to us as such (e.g., mathematical truth whose genuine proof is accepted as existing only on testimony)

Albert the Great (Topicorum 1.1.2) on signs of verisimilitude (cf. Gardeil)
(1) found on the surface (e.g., sensible qualities, as whiteness of snow is showing its structure)
(2) intermediate between external phenomena and essential principles = what appears to many with a little reasoning (e.g., the unmoving pole star as indicating the earth's movement)
(3) this combes what appears to the wise when the indications become convertible with the essential principles (e.g., the eclipse and relative motion of the move)
-- (3a) on all the wise (signs convertible with principles in a way falling under senses)
-- (3b) on the most part of the wise (signs convertible with principles in a way requiring relevant priority)
-- (3c) on the excellent of the wise (signs convertible with principles in a way requiring great experience)

the Nyaya syllogism as a way of getting signs to convert with essential principles (the demonstrative regress is also such a method)

testimonial evidence to oneself (this seems related both to articulation and to recollection)

the deepening of plausible representation until it is convertible with persuasive presentation; the deepening of persuasive representation until it is convertible with probable truth

perversion vs alienation of faculty

Perversion of faculty, being based on inconsistency, is always wrong. Alienation of factuly that is unreasonable is wrong for the most part, being based on inappropriateness. Alieantion of faculty that is reasonable is mostly not wrong, although it may sometimes be wrong, depending on how it is reasonable. Appropriate use of faculty is never wrong.

The engine of capitalism is not competition for profit but investment for profit; competition for profit is the engine of consumerism in particular.

The primary lesson to be learned from LLM's is that human beings talk and publish a truly mind-boggling amount.

Rome always is and is not Rome.

Christ asks of us impossibilities and gives to us the means of possibility.

Inquiry often begins with telling a story.

The question is not whether there are miracles but whether we should be realist or anti-realist about them.

Creation is itself the possibility of Church.

diaries and journals as testimonial evidence to oneself

The modern way of educating has much episode and little plot.

"Numbers may excel by their special exactness, but even numbers have to be defined by words that are not numbers." Jaki
"No humiliation is involved in the fact that miracles are never automatically overwhelming proofs. They represent the challenge of external reality, not of axioms of logic."

readiness to appear --> continuant capacity to appear --> continuant subject

-- look into Gauss's mathematical criticisms of Kant

Recognizable evil is a sign of what still means something.

"The  moral order is protected on its borders by negative precepts, but in the interior positive precepts suggest the inexhaustible openness of the human good." McInerny

perspectivally dependent consequences
contextually dependent consequences

People often talk about freedom of speech as a substitute for talk about the freedom to be honest.

In order to prove we sometimes must assume/suppose things we do not know to be true, or ever that may be known to be false.

Gale ("The Fictive Use of Language") has a notion of 'purely locutionary acts of referring', but this is surely an abuse of the term 'locutionary'.

No necessary proposition can entail a contingent one *in a context in which the necessity distributes across entailment*. (Contexts in which it wouldn't seem to be cases in which the necessity in the first place canot be the same necessity across an entailment.) (Entailment is often just 'every truth assignment satisfying the premises satisfies the conclusion.')

We form metaphors not merely in light of what similarities there are, but also in light of similarities there might be.

The Dionysian is not set against the common everyday, but show itself to be already there in the common everyday; what destroys Pentheus is trying to seperate the common everyday out as if it were an independent thing.

What Nietzsche seems to have most appreciated in Wagner is the masterful presentation of the non-separation of the arts.

That something makes one happier does not entail that it is true, but one should surely ask why it makes one happier, and one possible reason -- even, perhaps, a common reason -- is that it is at least partially true.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Locked Room

 Chapter 17 of John Dickson Carr's The Hollow Man, "The Locked-Room Lecture", is one of the most famous chapters in all of detective fiction. In it, Dr. Gideon Fell delivers a lecture (to a not entirely willing audience) on the possible solutions to a locked-room mystery. He admits that his account is only a "rough offhand outline" (p. 159) and not perfectly systematic. Can we work out a somewhat more systematic account? Is there a possible solution to a locked-room mystery not included in Dr. Fell's lecture?

The essential elements of a locked-room mystery are these:

an apparent murder victim
apparently unreachable as such by any murderer
or
an apparent murder victim
with an apparent escaped murderer
for whom escape was apparently unreachable.

This gives us the two primary ways in which we can have a solvable locked-room mystery: the apparent murder victim is only apparently so, and the unreachability is only apparent.

I. THE APPARENT MURDER VICTIM IS NOT A MURDER VICTIM

Murder requires that someone be killed, non-accidentally, by someone else. Thus we get three possible solutions right at the beginning.

I.A. THERE IS NO DEATH. The death is in fact faked, and there is no murder. This meets the criterion for an option that is not explicitly discussed in Dr. Fell's lectuer.

I.B. THE DEATH IS ACCIDENTAL. This is Dr. Fell's Explanation #1: "a series of coincidences ending in an accident which looks like a murder" (p. 155). Dr. Fell proposes the obvious way this could happen: a set of unrelated events are assumed to be related.

I.C. THE DEATH IS A SUICIDE. Dr. Fell's Explanation #4, a suicide intended to look like a murder, is one possible case, but, of course, you could have a suicide that looked like a murder unintentionally, as well.


II. THE APPARENTLY LOCKED ROOM IS NOT RELEVANTLY LOCKED

The locked room, like any location, consists generally in a space at a time in various causal relations; for a room to be really 'locked' it must be spatially, temporally, and causally unreachable, all togther, or insofar as they are relevant to the crime. Therefore we get three basic general ways an apparently unreachable crime can turn out to be reachable; the temporal case divides into further sub-cases. We can also have combinations of the three. We can, in each case, think in terms of the crime being committed by a muderer apparently outside the room, or a murderer inside the room apparently escaping; these are different cases, but they are symmetrical for our purposes.

II.A. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS SPATIALLY REACHABLE. The most obvious examples are a set of cases that Dr. Fell just sets aside as cheating -- namely, where there is some kind of secret opening into the room.

II.B. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS TEMPORALLY REACHABLE.

This breaks down into two further cases, the past-shifted and the future-shifted cases:

II.B.1. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE FROM BEFORE THE APPARENT DEATH. That is to say, the victim was actually murdered before the room was locked. Dr. Fell's Explanation #5, "from illusion and impersonation" (p. 157) is a fairly baroque possible example.

II.B.2. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE AFTER THE APPARENT DEATH. Dr. Fell's Explanation #7, in which the murder victim is in reality murdered after the locked room is opened, goes here; Dr. Fell's suggested example is that the victim was actually just asleep and is murdered by the person who opens the room, who is not suspected because the victim is thought already to have been dead.

II.C. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE BY NONOBVIOUS CAUSAL CONNECTION. 

This would be Dr. Fell's Explanation #6: "It is a murder which, although committed by somebody outside the room at the time, neertheless seems to have been committed by somebody who must have been inside" (p. 157). Dr. Fell calls this a "Long-Distance or Icicle Crime". The 'Icicle Crime' comes from the detective story in which the murder victim was shot from outside the locked room by an icicle bullet, which melted.

II.D. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE BY A COMBINATION OF SPATIAL, TEMPORAL, AND CAUSAL MEANS.

An example would be Dr. Fell's Explanation #3, in which the murderer planted a device beforehand that then later killed the victim when the room was locked. What kind of device, of course, is limited only by ingenuity. Arguably, his Explanation #2 would also be the case: the victim kills himself at the murderer's instigation through the murderer setting up the room so that there is a gas or apparent haunting or some such; this seems to be fit better here than as a variant of I.C.

One could perhaps argue that II.C and II.D should be collapsed, and that Dr. Fell's #6 is really a combination of causal and spatial access. But there is a need for a distinct II.C, I think; imagine a fantasy locked room in which a victim is murdered by someone who kills him through his dreams; this is neither a spatial nor temporal opening, but is certainly a causal one. Another case is possible with escapes: perhaps the murderer was in the room and did something so as to dissolve without a trace. Further, it makes sense to treat spatial access as spatial access of the murderer, and to treat spatial access of the murder weapon as part of the murderer's causal access, and the same with temporal access. 

I noted above that I.A is a case not included in Dr. Fell's account. Are there any others? Yes, there is another logically possible set of solutions, although they would need rather different circumstances than we usually think of with a locked room.


III. THE LOCKED ROOM IS NOT THE MURDER ROOM.

So one possible example would be if someone apparently saw someone being murdered in a locked room (through a window, perhaps), and when the locked room was opened, there were signs of murder, but no victim; in reality, the signs of murder were planted beforehand and what the witness saw was in fact a projection or reflection of someone being murdered somewhere else. Another possible example would be the victim being killed elsewhere and moved to the locked room by the person who opened the room.

***

John Dickson Carr, The Hollow Man, Orion (London: 2013).

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

After-Comers Cannot Guess the Beauty Been

Binsey Poplars 
by Gerard Manley Hopkins 

felled 1879 

My aspens dear, whose airy cages quelled, 
Quelled or quenched in leaves the leaping sun,
All felled, felled, are all felled;
Of a fresh and following folded rank 
Not spared, not one 
That dandled a sandalled
Shadow that swam or sank
On meadow & river & wind-wandering weed-winding bank.

O if we but knew what we do
When we delve or hew ---
Hack and rack the growing green!
Since country is so tender
To touch, her being só slender,
That, like this sleek and seeing ball
But a prick will make no eye at all,
Where we, even where we mean
To mend her we end her,
When we hew or delve:
After-comers cannot guess the beauty been.
Ten or twelve, only ten or twelve
Strokes of havoc únselve
The sweet especial scene,
Rural scene, a rural scene,
Sweet especial rural scene.

Religious Emotion

 No one (it is plain) can be religious without having his heart in his religion; his affections must be actively engaged in it; and it is the aim of all Christian instruction to promote this. But if so, doubtless there is great danger lest a perverse use should be made of the affections. In proportion as a religious duty is difficult, so is it open to abuse. For the very reason, then, that I desire to make you earnest in religion, must I also warn you against a counterfeit earnestness, which often misleads men from the plain path of obedience, and which most men are apt to fall into just on their first awakening to a serious consideration of their duty. It is not enough to bid you to serve Christ in faith, fear, love, and gratitude; care must be taken that it is the faith, fear, love, and gratitude of a sound mind. That vehement tumult of zeal which St. Peter felt before his trial failed him under it. That open-mouthed admiration of the populace at our Saviour's miracle was suddenly changed to blasphemy. This may happen now as then; and it often happens in a way distressing to the Christian teacher. He finds it is far easier to interest men in the subject of religion (hard though this be), than to rule the spirit which he has excited. His hearers, when their attention is gained, soon begin to think he does not go far enough; then they seek means which he will not supply, of encouraging and indulging their mere feelings to the neglect of humble practical efforts to serve God. After a time, like the multitude, they suddenly turn round to the world, abjuring Christ altogether, or denying Him with Peter, or gradually sinking into a mere form of obedience, while they still think themselves true Christians, and secure of the favour of Almighty God.

[John Henry Newman, "Religious Emotion", Parochial and Plain Sermons, Volume I.]

Monday, November 16, 2026

Unheaven'd the City Lies

 November Blue
by Alice Meynell

The golden tint of the electric lights seems to give a complementary colour to the air in the early evening.—Essay on London 

O heavenly colour, London town
Has blurred it from her skies;
And, hooded in an earthly brown,
Unheaven’d the city lies.
No longer, standard-like, this hue
Above the broad road flies;
Nor does the narrow street the blue
Wear, slender pennon-wise.

But when the gold and silver lamps
Colour the London dew,
And, misted by the winter damps,
The shops shine bright anew---
Blue comes to earth, it walks the street,
It dyes the wide air through;
A mimic sky about their feet,
The throng go crowned with blue.