Michael Sullivan at "The Smithy" has been musing on the recent Thomism vs. ID controversy from a Scotistic perspective:
Is "Intelligent Design" Scotistic?
Nature, Artifacts, and Machines 1
Nature, Artifacts, and Machines 2
"Intelligent Design" and Scotism
ADDED LATER:
Nature, Artifacts, Meaning, and Providence
Reply to Dr. Torley
The basic problems with ID from most
* scholastic perspectives will be the views it assumes of living things and of intelligence.
---
* I say 'most' because one could treat Cartesianism as a partially scholastic perspective -- Thomists, at least, have been classifying Cartesianism as a degenerate form of late scholasticism for years -- and Cartesianism and ID actually have the potential to get along very well and make a much more plausible alliance.
