Predicate | said of | found in (e.g.) |
---|---|---|
wise | God and man | ST 1.13.5 |
healthy | medicine, urine, body, food | ST 1.13.5; SCG 1.34 |
being | substance and accident | ST 1.13.10, SCG 1.34 |
God | God and idol | ST 1.13.10 |
animal | animal and painted animal | ST 1.13.10ad4 |
seeing/vision | act of eye and act of intellect | DV 2.11; Defensiones 1.35 (Capreolus) |
military | sword and soldier | In Eth 1.7 |
body | terrestrial and celestial body | I Sent. 19.5.2ad1 |
Hercules | Hercules and statue of Hercules | Defensiones 1.2.1.1 (Capreolus) |
principle/source | unit, point, heart, axiom | Quaestiones de div. praed. 18 (James of Viterbo) |
principle/source | heart, river | Quaestiones Ordinariae 33 ad 5 (Thomas Sutton) |
mover | God and creatures | Quaestiones Ordinariae 33 ad 24 (Thomas Sutton) |
Wednesday, April 08, 2020
Examples of Analogical Predication
This is mostly for my own use: some common examples used in discussing analogical predication, with locations. Some of the examples are from Domenic D'Ettore's Analogy after Aquinas; he notes that the examples used sometimes matter for conclusions drawn -- there was an active dispute post-Thomas, for instance, between those who held that analogical predication primarily worked like the health example and those who held that it primarily worked like the principle example.