Thursday, November 19, 2026

Locked Room

 Chapter 17 of John Dickson Carr's The Hollow Man, "The Locked-Room Lecture", is one of the most famous chapters in all of detective fiction. In it, Dr. Gideon Fell delivers a lecture (to a not entirely willing audience) on the possible solutions to a locked-room mystery. He admits that his account is only a "rough offhand outline" (p. 159) and not perfectly systematic. Can we work out a somewhat more systematic account? Is there a possible solution to a locked-room mystery not included in Dr. Fell's lecture?

The essential elements of a locked-room mystery are these:

an apparent murder victim
apparently unreachable as such by any murderer
or
an apparent murder victim
with an apparent escaped murderer
for whom escape was apparently unreachable.

This gives us the two primary ways in which we can have a solvable locked-room mystery: the apparent murder victim is only apparently so, and the unreachability is only apparent.

I. THE APPARENT MURDER VICTIM IS NOT A MURDER VICTIM

Murder requires that someone be killed, non-accidentally, by someone else. Thus we get three possible solutions right at the beginning.

I.A. THERE IS NO DEATH. The death is in fact faked, and there is no murder. This meets the criterion for an option that is not explicitly discussed in Dr. Fell's lectuer.

I.B. THE DEATH IS ACCIDENTAL. This is Dr. Fell's Explanation #1: "a series of coincidences ending in an accident which looks like a murder" (p. 155). Dr. Fell proposes the obvious way this could happen: a set of unrelated events are assumed to be related.

I.C. THE DEATH IS A SUICIDE. Dr. Fell's Explanation #4, a suicide intended to look like a murder, is one possible case, but, of course, you could have a suicide that looked like a murder unintentionally, as well.


II. THE APPARENTLY LOCKED ROOM IS NOT RELEVANTLY LOCKED

The locked room, like any location, consists generally in a space at a time in various causal relations; for a room to be really 'locked' it must be spatially, temporally, and causally unreachable, all togther, or insofar as they are relevant to the crime. Therefore we get three basic general ways an apparently unreachable crime can turn out to be reachable; the temporal case divides into further sub-cases. We can also have combinations of the three. We can, in each case, think in terms of the crime being committed by a muderer apparently outside the room, or a murderer inside the room apparently escaping; these are different cases, but they are symmetrical for our purposes.

II.A. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS SPATIALLY REACHABLE. The most obvious examples are a set of cases that Dr. Fell just sets aside as cheating -- namely, where there is some kind of secret opening into the room.

II.B. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS TEMPORALLY REACHABLE.

This breaks down into two further cases, the past-shifted and the future-shifted cases:

II.B.1. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE FROM BEFORE THE APPARENT DEATH. That is to say, the victim was actually murdered before the room was locked. Dr. Fell's Explanation #5, "from illusion and impersonation" (p. 157) is a fairly baroque possible example.

II.B.2. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE AFTER THE APPARENT DEATH. Dr. Fell's Explanation #7, in which the murder victim is in reality murdered after the locked room is opened, goes here; Dr. Fell's suggested example is that the victim was actually just asleep and is murdered by the person who opens the room, who is not suspected because the victim is thought already to have been dead.

II.C. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE BY NONOBVIOUS CAUSAL CONNECTION. 

This would be Dr. Fell's Explanation #6: "It is a murder which, although committed by somebody outside the room at the time, neertheless seems to have been committed by somebody who must have been inside" (p. 157). Dr. Fell calls this a "Long-Distance or Icicle Crime". The 'Icicle Crime' comes from the detective story in which the murder victim was shot from outside the locked room by an icicle bullet, which melted.

II.D. THE CRIME (OR ESCAPE) IS REACHABLE BY A COMBINATION OF SPATIAL, TEMPORAL, AND CAUSAL MEANS.

An example would be Dr. Fell's Explanation #3, in which the murderer planted a device beforehand that then later killed the victim when the room was locked. What kind of device, of course, is limited only by ingenuity. Arguably, his Explanation #2 would also be the case: the victim kills himself at the murderer's instigation through the murderer setting up the room so that there is a gas or apparent haunting or some such; this seems to be fit better here than as a variant of I.C.

One could perhaps argue that II.C and II.D should be collapsed, and that Dr. Fell's #6 is really a combination of causal and spatial access. But there is a need for a distinct II.C, I think; imagine a fantasy locked room in which a victim is murdered by someone who kills him through his dreams; this is neither a spatial nor temporal opening, but is certainly a causal one. Another case is possible with escapes: perhaps the murderer was in the room and did something so as to dissolve without a trace. Further, it makes sense to treat spatial access as spatial access of the murderer, and to treat spatial access of the murder weapon as part of the murderer's causal access, and the same with temporal access. 

I noted above that I.A is a case not included in Dr. Fell's account. Are there any others? Yes, there is another logically possible set of solutions, although they would need rather different circumstances than we usually think of with a locked room.


III. THE LOCKED ROOM IS NOT THE MURDER ROOM.

So one possible example would be if someone apparently saw someone being murdered in a locked room (through a window, perhaps), and when the locked room was opened, there were signs of murder, but no victim; in reality, the signs of murder were planted beforehand and what the witness saw was in fact a projection or reflection of someone being murdered somewhere else. Another possible example would be the victim being killed elsewhere and moved to the locked room by the person who opened the room.

***

John Dickson Carr, The Hollow Man, Orion (London: 2013).